16 ms·
Why India's Mars mission is so cheap – and thrilling
- kazinator 12y agoHow about reliable electricity and water for your people, then Mars. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_Resources_in_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_Resources_in_India "Water supply and sanitation in India continue to be inadequate ..." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_India "Over 300 million (300 million) people in India have no access to electricity. Of those who do, almost all find electricity supply intermittent and unreliable."
- pushtheenvelope 12y agobetter response than I can write. This is why: http://balajiviswanathan.quora.com/Indian-Space-Mission-Poverty-and-Closet-Racism http://balajiviswanathan.quora.com/Indian-Space-Mission-Pove...
- primelens 12y agoThank you! After reading this same statement about toilets vs space missions dozens of times I could hardly muster anything more articulate than "aaargh!" Apparently the West had solved all of humanity's problems and ensured a reign of perfect equality and peace before embarking on trivial things like research!
- chc 12y agoThis is pure ad hominem. "The West is dumb and mean" doesn't make anybody else's actions smart. You may as well criticize their odor for all the relevance it has to whether or not this is a sensible use of India's money. For the record, I actually think it's probably a good use of money. I just think this breed of response — "Shut up, because the West sucks!" — is singularly toxic.
- manish_gill 12y agoThe article in question specifically criticizes the journalists. The author (in subsequent comments) even discourages others from blatantly generalizing countries' reaction in the same manner as some of the components of the media.
- chc 12y agoThe OP doesn't really do that. The article linked by pushtheenvelope does, but that is what I was criticizing. It doesn't actually support India's program; it mostly just makes sarcastic and hostile comments about other countries. Regardless of your opinion of the West or of India, personally attacking critics (based on their ethnicity, no less) is not the same thing as supporting an idea.
- primelens 12y agoYou misunderstand my argument if you read it as "the West is dumb and mean". What I meant to emphasize was that the West made the (IMHO right) decision, to spend on research etc while it was working on other social problems. It is never one or the other. But I would add the same model should be extended to other countries as well.
- frandroid 12y agoI'm not sure I agree with Amos' argument, but the fact is that he does address this in the article.
- thirsteh 12y agoYou might as well ask the same question about anything the U.S. does, given that the U.S. undisputedly has "more important" and unresolved domestic problems. In the words of Carl Sagan: "Just now, there a great many matters that are pressing in on us that compete for the money it takes to send people to other worlds. Should we solve those problems first, or are they a reason for going? "
- baddox 12y agoPeople do ask the same question about many things the U.S. does.
- spindritf 12y agoThe US does have more important and unresolved domestic problems but there are vanishingly few that could be solved with just more money.
- cmdrfred 12y agoCorrect, but the majority of them can be solved with a more equitable distribution of said money.
- tn13 12y agoUS debt is one problem that can be solved purely by money and nothing else not especially Obama's rhetoric.
- dkokelley 12y agoI have a feeling this thread is leading down a very nonproductive path, but I'd like to salvage something of value from it and discuss the consequences of the national debt. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/10/21/141510617/what-if-we-paid-off-the-debt-the-secret-government-report http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/10/21/141510617/what-if-... I'd like to challenge the notion that the national debt is undisputedly a bad thing. The majority of the U.S.'s debt is in the form of treasury bonds - widely considered the most secure form of financial instrument. If the treasury bond can't be paid by the U.S., there are much bigger problems (such as the government of the largest national economy in the world collapsing). The treasury bond is utilized worldwide for its stability. It is used to moderate economic growth, and to stimulate it when it slows. I'm not convinced government debt is entirely good, but I'm also not convinced that things would be better by paying it off.
- roywiggins 12y agoIf you could provide reliable electricity and water for 300 million people for $74m ($0.25 per head) then you might have a point, but it's not really a lot of money for a country as large as India.
- baddox 12y agoHow many people could you provide reliable utilities to for $74m?
- pm90 12y agoNot very many. And for how long? If you look at it from another perspective: providing jobs for the scientists and all the industrial manufacturers with that money probably did a lot better in that regard.
- paramendra 12y agoSo true. $75 million is not a lot of money for India. The Prime Minister's Office just spent $50 million on latest equipment for his bodyguards (secret service detail). ONE Indian company just signed a deal with the Nepal government to spend $1 billion for ONE hydro project in Nepal. And it is nowhere in news in India.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- palakchokshi 12y agoUmmmm you like posting links without thinking? Here are a couple of them for you. You see the fallacy in your argument? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#Recent_poverty_rate_and_guidelines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#Re... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_Stat...
- dang 12y ago> you like posting links without thinking? No personal attacks on Hacker News, please, regardless of how annoying another's comment may be.
- seanflyon 12y agoWhile I completely disagree with kazinator, you have not pointed out a fallacy and your links do not contradict anything kazinator wrote.
- kazinator 12y agoYes, I see a fallacy and it is in your own argument. The fallacy you are invoking, in fact, has a fancy Latin name; it may be this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
- wehadfun 12y agoWe are quick to call comments like this racist but I don't know. If Singapor or Qutar did the same thing I doubt anyone would say their priorities are jacked up.
- mullingitover 12y agoAh yes, the 2014 ode to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtBy_ppG4hY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtBy_ppG4hY
- ericd 12y agoThey're spending $75M to inspire a generation. It's dirt cheap.
- anigbrowl 12y agoDon't be so short-sighted. Putting an orbiter around Mars on a relative shoestring is likely to generate a lot of inward investment in India, which will help to pay for very expensive things like content-scale infrastructure.
- paramendra 12y agoThe best comment to date. This 75 million will come back in droves as India now high gears its space exports.
- grownseed 12y agoThis is what I show people with this perspective: http://me.brandabrand.com/t/letter-by-ernst-stuhlinger/6288 http://me.brandabrand.com/t/letter-by-ernst-stuhlinger/6288. It's clever, touching and to the point.
- bsder 12y agoBecause the technology to send a spacecraft to another planet is the same technology to solve terrestrial problems. The Internet, nominally the single biggest technology solution for the developing world ever, runs on compression and error correction algorithms that were first implemented for Voyager. A manned mission to Mars must solve a the problem of a closed ecosystem. Think that might be important to developing countries who are polluting terribly (just like everybody did) in an effort to modernize? You can't solve everything. There will always be some problems. And, get enough good scientists together and those same scientists will start demanding that you make progress on domestic fronts as well.
- tn13 12y agoRemind me again how much surplus money did US have to fight wars in Iraq ? Please tell me that US is overflowing with so much money that they have an army stationed in Germany for absolutely no rational reason. Why exactly is US spending so much of higher education when most of the public elementary education is good enough to mass produce kids whose only skill is flipping burgers ? Large nations need to allocate money to all problems proportional to the seriousness of the problem. We have learned how to live with less. My classrooms did not have even a bulb. Did not prevent me from getting good education. My village did not have any water pipeline and we figured out how to survive.
- chc 12y agoThe fact that the US wastes huge wads of money doesn't exactly convince me that wasting money is a good idea. The US does lots of things that are questionable at best.
- tn13 12y agoThat was not really my point. What people need to understand is that each nation gives certain priority of all the problems and accordingly invests money into those problems. Saying that spending money on X is a waste when you have problem Y unsolved is stupid. India has 1/6th of world population and has very good reason to invest in space research. India is going to needs its own satellite guided missiles, ASAT, GPS and other systems down the line if those 1.2B people have to see a good future. Or these people will be held hostage to USA's Military Industrial Complex. India was already one of the largest Shipbuilding nation and had more Aircraft maintenance centers than most other countries in 1950s. India did not invest well into these industries, today our defense imports are obscene. We cant even manufacture a reliable pistol leave alone mortar. Had we invested in those tech also we could have saved a lot more money today which could have helped the poor.
- thisGuysAccount 12y ago"Why exactly is US spending so much of higher education when most of the public elementary education is good enough to mass produce kids whose only skill is flipping burgers ?" I'm not sure what point you're trying to make about 13 year olds, but I assure you I don't care what you have to say.
- vaishaksuresh 12y ago"INR5 billion (US$82 million) provided for ultra modern solar power plants in Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Ladakh in Jammu and Kashmir." "INR2 billion (US$33 million) provided for power reforms, INR5 billion (US$82 million) for water reforms in Delhi" "10-year tax holiday to be extended to companies that start power generation by March 31, 2017" Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Union_budget_of_India http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Union_budget_of_India And yet, you complain about the mere $67 million spent on this mission.
- rsynnott 12y agoOn this reasoning, really, all space programmes are unacceptable, and always have been. People are without healthcare in the US; scrap NASA! People are unemployed in Europe; cut funding to the ESA! Zero-sum! There seems to be a strange idea that spending on space is inherently wasteful. In fact, India spent ~$75m on this, mostly locally, thus providing economic stimulus, and no doubt assisting education.
- chernevik 12y agoMaybe folks in India will start asking, hey, we can orbit Mars, how come we can't get clean water around here? Raising the standards of competence, intelligence and honesty for that government probably does far more than piping another $74mm into the same decrepit apparatus.
- known 12y agoPeople in India HATE their neighbourhood. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2013/05/15/a-fascinating-map-of-the-worlds-most-and-least-racially-tolerant-countries/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2013/05/15...
- jgmmo 12y ago"They've kept it small. The payload weighs only about 15kg. " Whoa... So basically that whole mission was for 30ish pounds of actual 'useful equipment' in orbit?
- sliverstorm 12y agoYes. Remember that cost per kg for a launch- just in fuel costs- is still something like five figures USD. Weight is a tremendous source of cost savings. Compare to the Mars Science Laboratory, at 3,893 kg. They might have spent $150k in fuel costs, while we might have spent $38M.
- seanflyon 12y ago> just in fuel costs I think you mean 'just in rocket costs' as the fuel cost is negligible and the cost of the launch is 5 figures (dollars/kg). For example the falcon 9 costs $12,618/kg to GTO and $4,653/kg to LEO. I don't recall the exact figure but fuel cost is a low single digit percentage of that cost.
- sliverstorm 12y agoSorry, my mistake. I appreciate you pointing it out.
- mrb 12y agoNASA's MAVEN payload was just 4.3 times heavier (65kg vs. 15kg) but cost 9.1 times more ($671M vs. 74M). So NASA is still 2.1 times more expensive per kg of useful payload. And costs scale less than linearly with the payload mass, so a bigger Indian mission would have likely been even more than 2.1 times more efficient than NASA...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wodenokoto 12y agoWhat makes you think there's a linear relation between payload weight and cost?
- zizee 12y agoWhy do people always pass judgment on spending on things they don't agree with as if the money is destroyed. It's not like they pile all the cash onto the rocket and send it to space. Let's just forget for a moment that valuable skills and infrastructure are being created for India in this process and look at where the money is going. A large proportion of the expense of this mission goes to paying the wages of domestic scientists and engineers in India. This money will in turn get taxed and spent by the recipients and pumped back into the local economy. As far as I can see it is a win win win.
- donw 12y agoExactly. Projects like this generate huge amounts of value for a country -- not only because they help to push money around the economy, in terms of salaries and invoices paid to rocket-building companies -- but also in terms of the skills gained by everybody that works on the project, as well as the international capital of being a spacefaring country. Right now, launching satellites in the US is a pain in the ass, thanks to the combination of ITER[1] and the lack of a replacement for the shuttle. If India can become a launch destination for US companies looking to throw birds into orbit, that's big. Doubly so because it's not like they don't have plenty of engineers. Hell, this might be the case already, and I just don't know. [1] okay, now EAR, but still.
- jonwachob91 12y agoThe shuttle was never primarily used to send Satellites into space... It was used primarily for maned missions. The Atlas V is the current standard for putting satellites into space. Sierra Nevada Corporation puts a satellite into orbit almost once a week. The pain you speak of is non existent.
- leoedin 12y ago> The pain you speak of is non existent. That's simply untrue. Access to launchers is the bottleneck to satellite development. Large institutional customers have access to space, but almost nobody else does. The commercial satellite industry has been shaped by the shortage of launchers, with satellites designed to be launched infrequently with long design lives. As a result everything is tremendously expensive. This is changing slowly with the advent of SpaceX and the develoment of launchers by other countries. There's no reason launches can't be an order of magnitude cheaper. The fuel cost is actually a minimal part of the cost of a rocket system. I work in the space business. Getting access to a suitable launcher for smaller lower priority projects is hard.
- peter303 12y agoIndian labor is very cheap. Even cheaper in the Motherland.
- stcredzero 12y agoI hope India and China pull off a Mars Direct style mission and beat the US to Mars. The US needs another "Sputnik Moment" to get itself going in space again. I mean for real, not as an esoteric form of federal "pork."
- mikeleeorg 12y agoYes. And competition at a global scale like that should be good for everyone too.
- stcredzero 12y agoThere might be a bustling future market for organizations in China and India that can sell to the rest of the world that the US won't let domestic companies sell to.
- TheSoftwareGuy 12y agoIf India really did make it to mars before the US did, we would probably congradulate them, not try to compete with them. When the USSR put Sputnik into space, the US's response wasn't because oh no we need to beat them to the moon! it was because the fact that they could put a satellite into space meant they could also land a nuclear warhead on US soil.
- efuquen 12y ago> not try to compete with them I seriously doubt this. Sure, it wouldn't be seen as a threat, but it certainly would be seen as a clear sign of America's decay in technological leadership and capabilities. > oh no we need to beat them to the moon! Everything I've seen documented from that era actually points to this being exactly the attitude. Sending satellites into orbit and launching ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads involves a different set of skills then sending humans into space. Sure you need to launch rockets in all cases, but life support, pushing the extra payload (into orbit, and then the moon), developing a whole set of extra skills (docking, space walking, etc.) It's just way more complicated and expensive to send people into space and there was no military advantage for either country to do it. Both countries wanted to beat each other in a game of technological machismo, just plain old competition at work.
- doctorKrieger 12y agoNow India is capable of nuking USandA.
- paramendra 12y agoThe pride in India right now is as if it won the World Cup.
- r00fus 12y agoMore like they scored a goal for humankind.
- kesava 12y agoThe wrong world cup. In India, it means the Cricket World Cup.
- ptaipale 12y agoBut unfortunately, nobody (outside the British Commonwealth) understands the scoring anyway.
- smcl 12y agoNot strictly true, Cricket is making a comeback in the US it seems: http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2014/08/cricket-is-catching-on-in-America-where-it-was-popular-a-century-ago/378683/ http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2014/08/cri...
- prawn 12y agoI wish Australia had a comparable project and the public showed equivalent interest in space. But instead the current obsession is, once again, burqas.
- differentView 12y agoThe interest in the U.S. right now is as if whatever non-U.S. country just won the World Cup.
- tn13 12y agoIn the words of Vikaram Sarabhai, the founding father of ISRO: "There are some who question the relevance of space activities in a developing nation. To us, there is no ambiguity of purpose. We do not have the fantasy of competing with the economically advanced nations in the exploration of the moon or the planets or manned space-flight." "But we are convinced that if we are to play a meaningful role nationally, and in the community of nations, we must be second to none in the application of advanced technologies to the real problems of man and society."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- vithlani 12y agoI wish someone would write a headline like: "Why 750 million Indian citizens cannot enjoy basic sanitation facilities after 60 years of gaining so called independence of their nation" Seriously....
- abhididdigi 12y agoSeriously? I gather that you are not an Indian, and if you really are an Indian then either you are an illiterate about what's happening in country, or you are an NRI earning in dollars in US who really don't care about India, except in writing these snarky comments. If you are not an Indian citizen, you still should know the truth before you talk. 750 million Indian citizens aren't enjoying basic sanitation facilities because of the corruption in India. There was a Politician who was a son of Chief Minister who pledged more than 75 million in an election. This is just one example of the amount of corruption in India. Every state in India are filled with those politicians who are corrupt, and they own huge amounts of Black money. So, I don't see what is your basis in typing in useless comment, when this money was spent as per the Budget allocation. And finally, please don't write something unless you know the facts properly. The basic sanitation of all Indian Citizens will be improved, if the Political situation of the country is improved not by stopping Technological Advances. Sometimes, if you don't have anything to contribute, it's better to close your computer and get out than to write these kinds of comments.
- vithlani 12y agoI cannot be "illiterate" about what happens in the country, merely "ill-informed". FYI, there is a category of Indians who are not NRI and it might surprise you to know there are countries other than the US and....surprise.... currencies other then dollars!! Oh wow!! What has being an Indian citizen got to do with the truth? I write what I write so that the rah-rah-yay-yay idiots like you could draw their attention to the real problem in your country -- a civilization more than 10,000 years old that still cannot fix basic sanitation issues, where women are raped on a regular no-comment basis, where corruption is prevalent from birth-certificate to death-certificates, where swathes of your population are being driven to Naxal violence by the state as a means of defending their homes, culture and patrimony from greedy corporations. In the face of the staggering problems you face as a nation, shouldn't you turn your and your peer's attention to them rather than trying to rejoice at "look white man, me too MARS"? You may also be surprised to know, "Technological Advances" have been advanced enough for a couple of hundred years now to the point that sanitation, roads, etc are a non-issue -- you don't need to go to Mars for that! Or perhaps Slumdog tourism generates enough income for you to want to keep it that way? http://www.thebaffler.com/salvos/slumming-it http://www.thebaffler.com/salvos/slumming-it Down-vote me all you want, happy to give you my points if you make an honest effort to understand the point I make. You will also note that I post under my real name as I do not feel ashamed about having an honest discussion under my identity -- how about you?
- mataug 12y agoIt feels like they've built a startup, put only the essential things in and build a truly minimum viable product that works and that too quite well.
- someperson 12y ago(I posted a similar comment a few months ago.[1] To be clear I have nothing against the India, its space program or its achievements, but it's impossible to discuss the low price of the mission without discussing the elephant in the room) There is clear lack of sterilization techniques being used on the ISRO spacecraft. This is clearly visible in the public photos and videos. NASA spend a great deal of time and sterilizing deep space probes to reduce the chance of Earth microbes colonizing a place like Mars, or a moon of Jupiter, but ISRO does not. Watch this video and showing assembly of this particular spacecraft http://www.space.com/23199-indias-first-mars-mission-prepares-for-launch-video.html http://www.space.com/23199-indias-first-mars-mission-prepare... Compare the NASA cleanroom assembling Curiosity - http://www.nasa.gov/centers/jpl/images/content/482654main_pia13388-640.jpg http://www.nasa.gov/centers/jpl/images/content/482654main_pi.... Most engineers at the Indian Space Research Organisation seen directly operating on the spacecraft are not using facial masks or even gloves for interplanetary missions, let alone full cleanroom coveralls. http://www.thehindu.com/multimedia/dynamic/01608/vbk-05-mars_1608506g.jpg http://www.thehindu.com/multimedia/dynamic/01608/vbk-05-mars... (via http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/indias-october-28-mars-mission-on-schedule-isro/article5204371.ece http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/indias-october-28-m...) It would be a huge shame for us to have doubt whether the first extra terrestial microbes we find in the solar system were really alien or simply Space Age Earth based life It also jibes with this anecdote https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6552078 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6552078 This comment has nothing to do with India, ISRO, politics or Mars, but I am curious if anyone with expertise can comment on the clean room practices seen applied in this video. Is it odd that the workers don't have on full 'bunny' suits and have (what seems to be) a relatively large amount of skin/hair unprotected? I don't know if it matters that much, it just seems a little lax given the cost of failure. Firstly, I've visited ISRO Bangalore(A few years back). And I did see the exact things you mentioned. I did ask the guy(Not sure, if he was the PR guy) who took our class for the tour. His answer was, they were likely assembling some test equipment and not the real equipment that was going to space. (Which unlikely given parent's NYT article:) The modest budget did not allow for multiple iterations. So, instead of building many models (a qualification model, a flight model and a flight spare), as is the norm for American and European agencies, scientists built the final flight model right from the start. It's unclear whether the room is a climate and particulate controlled cleanroom up to the standards required for inplanetary probes, but they may (hopefully) do sterilization through chemical and heat treatments - but that alone isn't enough for planetary protection. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7964261#up_7964499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7964261#up_7964499
- Rapzid 12y agoI believe this could be very good for India on multiple fronts.. But I feel the comparison to NASA's spending is somewhat superficial and borderline disingenuous.
- sid1992 12y agoGo to ISRO's website and look at the starting salary for an engineer. Even for the most paid fields there it is not more than 40000 rupees per month or roughly 650 dollars
- kamaal 12y agoI was downvoted very badly yesterday for just saying ISRO engineers were paid less. Actually comparatively even compared to many Indian IT professionals salaries of these folks is actually low. Most people don't realize how low it is until you start comparing yourself with people of your same age some 10-15 years in to your career who are working with other software companies. Any decent IIT grad joining something like Amazon or Google gets ~15L-18L per annum these days, If you are from other colleges you can still get ~10L per annum. And this is for writing some HTML or some application around a data base. Heck even people working at IT services industry get paid around ~4-5 L per annum, and plus they can always move on to some nice after a few years, most do and within 8-10 years of their careers can reach atleast ~15L per annum. Plus some people also get foreign travel opportunities. If you have a good saving and investments discipline you can buy youself a home, a car and may be a nice wedding and a good deal of gold within 12 years of your career. To know how far those people who started their careers in the IT industry in 90's are, many are settled in the US. Many own 2-3 homes in a city like Bangalore drawing insane rent income, Many own stock options worth money you have never heard of. You can talk of Mars mission, pride and all that. But when you see your college mate driving a Honda Accord and eating a 3000 rupee dinner with his family after spending another 2000 on a movie on a Sunday evening. You begin to realize money has its own importance in life. Working in Government firms went out of fashion as early as mid 90's.
- Sven7 12y agoAnd yet they have reached Mars :)
- anupshinde 12y agoAren't you discounting the perks? I agree some IT guys like me earn in multiples of that - but most don't. And what about the amazing work-life balance (more life less work), job security and "serving-the-country" feeling. Compare that to a heavily stressful job, waking up at 3AM because some server in SF stopped executing some code that was written in SF. And absolutely no job security (I don't really care about job security). And constantly having that feeling "What if I could make this amazing product for my country" I'd exchange so-called-high paying job to get a job like ISRO now (Somebody misguided me in my early days with the same logic you mentioned) Obviously IT guys get paid a lot when they settle in US. I can tell you most of these guys are skilled a lot and can do that with little effort - Nobody's stopping them. And when they do, they earn in multiples than most of the IT jobs there.
- bipin-nag 12y agoThere are many point-of-views that one could(should) factor in to explain the circumstances: 1. Mindset due to poverty: There are many people below the poverty line so it makes sense for the scientific programs to aim for the cost-effective solutions not cutting-edge. 2. Experimental: If it was your first space mission, you wouldn't exactly load it with gadgets. Missions have a chance to succeed or to end in failure. Investment would only make sense after tasting some success. 3. Cost of living: If you are well-off in India, you may still be poor outside of India. Cost of living is lowest in India (http://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/rankings_by_country.jsp http://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/rankings_by_country.jsp). So cost of research and development will be lower than elsewhere too(maybe not everywhere). 4. Media attention(somewhat): It started with the headlines from British news "We pay for India's rocket to Mars" which raised a lot of eyebrows in India. Even though money from aid was used for intended purpose, it was questioned if India needed the aid. (To me its not worth the brouhaha. They will fancy paying for nuclear programmes next.) 5. GDP: US GDP is the largest in the world. They can afford to spend loads of money without worrying (lets say debt crisis was an exception). India has GDP which is smaller by orders of magnitude.
- chintan39 12y agoI think its because Indian Organizations know how to utilize their resources efficiently.
- mdemare 12y agoTo all those cynics who bitch about the price of this space mission: this mission cost $74M in total. India has a population of 1252M, and a per capita income of $1500. That means that after paying for this mission to Mars, Indians have still $1499.40 left to spend on other things. Now stop bitching.
- idreams 12y agoproud to be an Indian!!
- tomp 12y agoDid you do anything to contribute? If not, then there's nothing you can be proud of. It's like saying "proud to be white" when Neil Armstrong first stepped on the moon.
- cjcole 12y agoShifting "Indian" (nationality) to "white" (racial grouping) in your analogy is disingenuous and inflammatory. Policing other people's entirely natural and unobjectionable pride and joy is annoying and tiresome. ("American" would have been a better substitution, but maybe you judged it to be less effective as a rhetorical hammer?)
- tomp 12y ago> ("American" would have been a better substitution, but maybe you judged it to be less effective as a rhetorical hammer?) Probably, but I'm not American, so I didn't think of that. The only other commonality I have with Armstrong is being a man, but I don't think you would approve of that any more.
- gphilip 12y agoEight months back, three scientists from ISRO did an AMA on /r/india where they answered a lot of interesting questions and provided good insights into the good, the bad, the hopes and the struggles at ISRO and of being a scientist in India. That AMA will likely answer many of the questions here about ISRO and its operations. For instance: "All nations wanting to launch to Low Earth Orbits at low costs approach us. Germany, France, Israel, Norway, Denmark, Italy are examples. Yes, despite ESA. Because PSLV is a cost effective and reliable launch vehicle for launching to LEOs." And of course, Reddit being what it is, there were cute questions and answers as well. Sample: Qn: "Let's face it. You're definitely "cool" now. Were you "cool" growing up? How was your school/college life in general? Do women dig ISRO scientists?" Scientist 1: "Oh yes, cool all the way. I don't know about other scientists but they sure dig me." Scientist 2: "He's kidding. I know for a fact that he is more single than Lance Armstrong's nut." More here: "We are three ISRO scientists here to answer your questions -AMA" http://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1ujcmo/we_are_three_isro_scientists_here_to_answer_your/ http://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1ujcmo/we_are_three_i...