4 ms·
In the UK "checking accounts" (called Current Accounts) are free. With so called "Basic Current Accounts" (accounts with no overdraft/borrowing facility) being
by Someone1234 12y ago
In the UK "checking accounts" (called Current Accounts) are free. With so called "Basic Current Accounts" (accounts with no overdraft/borrowing facility) being available even to people with horrible/no credit at all.
The way UK banks make money on current accounts is via interest (the difference between the Bank of England rate and their rate, the spread). They can also charge non-basic current account customers for things like unagreed overdrafts and so on.
I don't really understand why current accounts in the US cost $12-8/month. It isn't like "checking accounts" in the US have much better interest rates. So they're likely double-dipping (getting $ off of the spread AND fees).
Plus a lot of US banks require you to have a savings account with $x in it on top of your "checking account" just to waive the fee. Which means they're still double dipping there too, the spread on both the savings in the savings account (their "savings" accounts have horrible interest rates) and any money in the "checking account."
This is also making it easy for fraudsters to move money. Since there are no "basic bank accounts" for the poor, throw-away/burner debit cards have become common which fraudsters can move stolen money onto and then spend it freely (as those cards have no ID check, etc).
Don't even get me started on how big of a scam the throw-away/burner debit cards are. Before you get someone one you should check out the fine print in terms of fees that mysteriously eat up any remaining balance. Aside from the risk of bankrupsy and loss of interest, normal gift cards are less of a scam.
- jstalin 12y agoThat's why many of us dumped banks for credit unions. Most credit unions offer free checking accounts and much better interest rates and customer service. The major banks were rocked by the 2007 meltdown and are still trying to recover.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I don't really understand why current accounts in the US cost $12-8/month. Mostly, as a way of dissuading customers whose support costs exceed provided revenue; its not so much to make money on the fees as to make people who can't afford to do what the bank wants (do their main deposits by direct deposit, maintain a certain minimum balance, maintain a savings account with a certain minimum balance, etc.) choose, from the expense, not to have an account at all. The US has for at least several decades had substantially greater wealth inequality than the UK (both before and after considering the effect of taxes and government assistance), and that has affected the way business approach the desirability of customers.
- Pxtl 12y agoHere in Canada they charge that cost only when you don't have a minimum balance in your account. So they idea is you either provide them with enough to collect interest or they take that fee from the account (and of course, the fee is far more than interst on the minimum balance would be, so functionally it's a monthly "fine" for going below your minimum).
- mcherm 12y agoBy way of comparison, the US bank that I work for (Capital One) offers checking accounts that have no monthly fees, no minimum balances, and even pay interest. HOWEVER, they will not offer them to all customers. Customers who have a sufficiently poor credit rating (we consider various factors) or other issues such as a history of writing bad checks or of engaging in bank fraud will be rejected for a normal checking account. The costs and risks of supporting such customers exceed the potential benefits. (NOTE: I am not privy to the details of the actual underwriting criteria, nor would I be authorized to disclose them if I DID know them. But if we reject someone for a banking product based on credit information we are required by law to let them know what information led to that decision.) [Edit:] Oh yes, and I forgot one of the more important reasons why you can't get one of our accounts. Because you are an "illegal alien" (anyone without a legitimate tax id). That constraint will also affect Walmart's new offering. Solving the problem of the "unbanked" in the US is much harder than you might think. But this new offering by Walmart will help.
- warfangle 12y ago> I don't really understand why current accounts in the US cost $12-8/month. It isn't like "checking accounts" in the US have much better interest rates. So they're likely double-dipping (getting $ off of the spread AND fees). That 12-8/mo is typically a fee for not having an average minimum balance, or not having direct deposits in a given month. I think it's their attempt to recoup the management overhead of having the account vs. the interest they earn on it.
- ensignavenger 12y agoThere are still plenty of US financial institutions that offer free checking accounts. They often charge ridiculous fees for things like overdrafts. But Credit Unions tend to be slightly better than banks. I have been using Simple.com in addition to my local Credit Union account for over a year now and I'm very satisfied.
- jedc 12y agoUK current accounts are free, but I don't think they're accessible to all. Like the US, I think if you don't have enough credit history (or poor history) it's difficult to get an account.
- Someone1234 12y agoWith all due respect did you read my post at all? I literally cover this topic on the first line, second sentence. TL;DR: That's what basic current accounts are for.
- jedc 12y agoI _did_ read your post. But it was still my understanding that not everyone can get an account as easily as you describe. If you show up to the UK (as I did >10yrs ago) from the US with NO credit history, no lease (b/c of company rental), only US financial info, etc, it's NOT quite so straightforward to even get those "basic" accounts. I always assumed this was because of the specifics of the anti-money-laundering laws that are on the books in the UK. (I've been working with a startup here in the UK that's trying to solve this and some other similar problems, which is why I even brought it up.) Not entirely sure why I got downvoted for my original comment, but c'est la vie.
- boling11 12y agoThe reason is bigger banks basically don't make any money off low balance accounts. Interest spread earnings are minimal and the Durbin Amendment (2010) basically killed debit card interchange as a revenue stream for banks with over $10b on the balance sheet. Smaller banks and credit unions can still make a good amount of money off uncapped debit card interchange, so they do offer free accounts.