7 ms·
Don't get me wrong I love Sam Altman I love y-combinator but a small part of me is thinking that a good first step to start a startup is to not watch that video
by ThomPete 12y ago
Don't get me wrong I love Sam Altman I love y-combinator but a small part of me is thinking that a good first step to start a startup is to not watch that video and find your own way. Not because it's probably not great but because a startup is not a formula.
Your path is your own.
- PublicEnemy111 12y agoI would imagine this class is not a cookie cutter business plan but rather "here's the challenges startups face and how to approach them." So likely a MOOC form of YC
- rdl 12y agoIronically that's what the first 15 minutes is..."don't start a startup unless it's the best way to accomplish something you want". "don't start a startup unless it feels like an important mission" etc.
- mladenkovacevic 12y agoI agree. It strikes me as a very inefficient use of an enterpeneur's time who wants to launch a business to first watch a series of 20 lectures about all aspects of starting a business. Just start doing it, and whenever you get stuck or need feedback ask someone whose expertise you trust for advice on a particular issue you're dealing with at that moment.
- scobar 12y agoPerhaps it's not the most efficient use of an entrepreneur's time, and I agree that it definitely doesn't have to be the first step. Working on an idea helps you learn fast, but there was so much I didn't know at first (I still have a lot to learn). I am so grateful that resources like this exist, and I expect this one by YC to have a higher density of quality info in the time spent watching lectures.
- McDoku 12y ago“Principles and rules are intended to provide a thinking man with a frame of reference.” -- Karl von Clausewitz
- ThomPete 12y agoRunning a company is not about neither principles nor rules. To the extent it does it's doesn't require a thinking man.
- McDoku 12y agoPlease elaborate.
- ThomPete 12y agoRunning a startup is not an intellectual exercise which is the context for that quote. Running a startup is more like improvising in a jazz band. There is some theory behind it but if you think you stink.
- McDoku 12y ago...talent and genius operate outside the rules, and theory conflicts with practice - Carl von Clausewitz I would argue that he agrees. However... The general who wins the battle makes many calculations in his temple before the battle is fought. The general who loses makes but few calculations beforehand. - Sun Tzu Both intellectualism and the ability to improvise are necessary. Arguably, if you have to adapt then a calculation has failed. Hearing the sound of thunder is not the mark of a keen ear, neither is entering battle and winning the mark of a great general. There is no point reinventing the wheel. Many have come before and it seems wise to assimilate their experience with a critical mind. Instinct ultimately rises from your existing body of knowledge. And even in jazz it emerges from a bass line.
- tim333 12y agoMaybe a bit of both is the answer. Just watch lectures and read and nothing gets done. Rush ahead and do stuff without studying and you risk dumb errors that you could have avoided.
- mpg33 12y agoI agree, however since he has seen and dealt with so many startups he gets to notice a lot of patterns about what makes startups more likely to be successful than the average person. There was definitely some valuable info in the lecture.
- ThomPete 12y agoI am pretty sure you are right. Whether that value is intellectual or actionable is what I am not so sure about :)
- TimPC 12y agoDisagree strongly. These lectures are about 40 minutes and seem jam packed with good advice. A start-up isn't a formula but it does follow certain trends. Doing it wrong is a disaster and if you're taking on what can be a 10 year commitment without spending less than 20h exploring advice from some of the best data and people in start-ups you probably have misaligned your priorities. I suspect heeding the advice in the first lecture of this course would save most start-ups more time and money than 20h of the "CEO" co-founder.
- ThomPete 12y agoDoing it wrong might actually sometimes mean doing it right. Ycombinator companies have access to this advice yet most of these companies fail. Thats just how it is. You can get structural advice from a laywer the rest is up to you to explore.
- TimPC 12y agoYCombinator companies have a far higher success percentage than the general start-up population. Most fail is hardly a criticism when the default environment is 90% of start-ups fail. Moving 90% to 60% for example means your chance of success quadruples, but it still meets your criticism of "most fail".
- ThomPete 12y agoThe reason they don't fail is most likely more to do with the fact that yCombinator is already a powerhouse more than with the advice.
- TimPC 12y agoCan't nest comments any further, but one of my previous companies got rejected at YC before becoming the most recent example of how not to apply to YC, and having a successful exit. I recognize the lines from the application, we're literally the example of what not to do according to YC, had a decent outcome and I'm still convinced this lecture had lots of great advice and if I were to start myself I'd follow more of it. Take what you will from that.
- pbreit 12y agoThere's still going to plenty of "finding your own way". I suspect most founders and early employees could find a lot of useful information in the material.
- ThomPete 12y agoNot disagreeing. But whether it's actionable is what I would question.
- TimPC 12y agoNot spending on PR or going to conferences pre-product is highly actionable for a large number of start-ups who do the opposite. Balancing the early team to be able to execute a product people love before scaling a marketing organization is highly actionable as well. The advice on doing a start-up for the right reasons is the most actionable of all.
- ThomPete 12y agoAnd yet the reality is that this worked for some. There is no meta advice, no big secret besides find out how to make it work for you.
- TimPC 12y agoYes. This works for some. If I ask you to choose between winning a bet where you roll 1,2,3,4,5 on a d6 or winning a bet where you roll 6, I think the fact that sometimes you win with 6 is true but almost useless.
- ThomPete 12y agoProblem is that you haven't shown that to be the case. You are just making up your own premises to prove a point you haven't proven.