2 ms·
The blog "Unqualified Reservations" (a defunct blog you should probably be familiar with, although not necessarily read or agree with) offered an interesting th
by nkurz 12y ago
The blog "Unqualified Reservations" (a defunct blog you should probably be familiar with, although not necessarily read or agree with) offered an interesting thought extension to the counterfactual:
If we want to get really imaginative, we can imagine what I
call a "reverse counterfactual." First, imagine that the
military dice had fallen otherwise and the American
Rebellion was suppressed. Second, perform the standard
counterfactual exercise of imagining what an intact British
Empire would look like in 2009. Third, imagine the
counterfactual universe invents some device that can send
invisible observers into our 2009, and make a documentary
for the edification of the Imperial audience - showing this
awful alternate 2009, in which the Massachusetts
disturbances of the 1770s were not quashed with firm, manly
vigour.
What's neat is that such a documentary could be made, with
existing technology, in the real 2009.
As a means of changing helping the reader see another perspective, I think it's a brilliant extension: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-introduction-to-unqualified_22.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-...
- Apocryphon 12y agoLess wordily: http://wiki.alternatehistory.com/doku.php/alternate_history/double_blind_what_if http://wiki.alternatehistory.com/doku.php/alternate_history/...
- nkurz 12y agoNice link. I'm not familiar with that community, although I think they might be describing something slightly different. Moldbug is asking how an audience from the ATL would interpret the actual fixed events of today ("a documentary"). But I think this link is more about how the ATL group would imagine OTL, without actually being constrained to it. Less wordy, but I think it's different exercise?
- Apocryphon 12y agoAh, I see. Moldbug's second point is what DBWI's are about- speculating on real world events from the point of view of an alternate history inhabitant. His third point takes it into the realm of further fantasy, of having those inhabitants actually cross into our world to see their reactions. Cross-timeline adventures are not exactly unknown in alternate history sci-fi, and they're quite fun as well, to see the very different cultures interact. Cheap irony is the lifeblood of althist.