3 ms·
So how do you determine whether something was a 'reason' for something, without considering a counterfactual? The very nature of a 'reason' is, it's something w
by jameshart 12y ago
So how do you determine whether something was a 'reason' for something, without considering a counterfactual? The very nature of a 'reason' is, it's something which had to happen in order for the consequence to follow. If the consequence would have happened anyway, then it's not a reason.
The impact an event has can only be determined by imagining what would have happened if the event didn't take place, surely?
Did America's use of the atomic bomb cause Japan to surrender? Can you answer that question without considering how Japan's leadership would have behaved if the bombs hadn't been dropped?