3 ms·
Australia is proposing something similar: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/julie-bishop-rejects-un-request-to-strengthen-australian-climat
by threeseed 12y ago
Australia is proposing something similar:
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/julie-bishop-rejects-un-request-to-strengthen-australian-climate-targets-20140919-10j5kk.html http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/julie-...
It never ceases to amaze me that political parties who fundamentally believe in the importance of "the market" don't trust it for reducing emissions. Hypocrisy at it's worst.
- Retric 12y agoCap and trade's first step is to hand out billions of dollars worth of emissions credits to major polluters which they can then resell. After that it's similar to a strait tax if more costly and less efficient, but you can see the appeal.
- Alex3917 12y agoCap and trade is more efficient than a tax, that's the whole point of it -- allowing the market to find the least costly way of reducing total emissions below the cap, as opposed to forcing everyone to reduce emissions by the same percentage regardless of the cost. As for handing out billions of dollars of emissions credits to current polluters that they can then sell, this is completely false. The way the initial allocation works under most proposals is to give current polluters credits to cover part of their current emissions upfront. Then if they reduce their emissions beyond their allocated emissions they can sell the excess credits. This is what makes cap and trade so efficient, there are huge profits to be made by companies that can create technologies to reduce emissions the most efficiently. Then over time the total cap decreases, and the amount of credits allocated to existing polluters also decreases, so that all companies will have to buy whatever credits they need at a yearly auction or whatever.
- Retric 12y agoA carbon tax is hardly going to cause an equal cut in emissions across all sectors. Sectors with cheap alternatives will switch and those without will not. Consider there are few alternatives for aircraft, but a coal power plant has lot's of clean alternatives at competitive prices. A heavy carbon tax might add 1 cents a gallon to gas prices, which would basically be ignored by most people / companies, but the same tax would make new coal power plants unprofitable. In the end it let's the markets decide the most efficient approach even if that's to do nothing.
- bradleyjg 12y ago>> Cap and trade is more efficient than a tax, that's the whole point of it -- allowing the market to find the least costly way of reducing total emissions below the cap, as opposed to forcing everyone to reduce emissions by the same percentage regardless of the cost. A tax doesn't force everyone to reduce emissions by the same amount. If cutting emissions is less profitable than paying the tax, you pay the tax, otherwise you cut emissions. >> As for handing out billions of dollars of emissions credits to current polluters that they can then sell, this is completely false. The way the initial allocation works under most proposals is to give current polluters credits to cover part of their current emissions upfront. Then if they reduce their emissions beyond their allocated emissions they can sell the excess credits. This is what makes cap and trade so efficient, there are huge profits to be made by companies that can create technologies to reduce emissions the most efficiently. How about if they just shut down their production and sell the credits? Giving the credits to incumbents is a large barrier to entry for competitors and a give away. If you are going to have credits rather than a tax, the credits should be auctioned.
- icebraining 12y agoHow about if they just shut down their production and sell the credits? Giving the credits to incumbents is a large barrier to entry for competitors and a give away. If you are going to have credits rather than a tax, the credits should be auctioned. How would the auction solve the problem?
- bradleyjg 12y agoI guess it wasn't entirely clear, but I was referring to repeated auctions for limited time permits (e.g. annual). That puts new entrants on an equal footing after a relatively short period of time.
- Alex3917 12y ago> Giving the credits to incumbents is a large barrier to entry for competitors and a give away. If you are going to have credits rather than a tax, the credits should be auctioned. Sure, but that's not an inherent feature of cap and trade. The only reason why most current proposals include this is because it's the only way the legislation has a realistic chance of passing. And there is at least a decent justification for it, in that it reduces any initial financial impacts, and then still transitions into a full auction over a few years.
- schwabacher 12y agoYeah - I know this is how it has been proposed in the US, it is absurd and corrupt to hand out credits for free.. but I think cap and trade would be great if it were implemented by setting a cap that shrinks over time, and then auctioning tradable permits to emit. The revenues from these auctions could be used to cut income tax to make up for the increase in prices to consumers.
- icebraining 12y agoit is absurd and corrupt to hand out credits for free Why? The revenues from these auctions could be used to cut income tax to make up for the increase in prices to consumers. The income tax is progressive (affects the rich more than the poor), while a tax that raises prices isn't. Why do you favor a regressive tax policy?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- adrianN 12y agoWe already hand out billions of dollars worth of pollution credits to polluters. The only difference is that right now these manifest as externalized costs. The polluters pollute and everybody has to pay the price of climate change.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]