4 ms·
It seems strange to see all the historians' objections to the exploration of counterfactuals. Much as they may protest that they are only interested in catalogu
by jameshart 12y ago
It seems strange to see all the historians' objections to the exploration of counterfactuals. Much as they may protest that they are only interested in cataloguing what actually happened, to make a jusgement over whether or not a particular event is significant, one has surely to consider what the world might have been like if it hadn't happened. If you can't explore the counterfactual realm at all, then you're unable to make any judgement at all about how important a particular event was, and so as a historian you might as well study what Al Gore had for breakfast the morning of the 2000 election as what led the supreme court to its decision on the Florida recount. We take interest in the Supreme Court decision because history would be very different if it had gone another way. Exploring that counterfactual lets you figure out just how different: it is a worthy question for historians to determine how significant the choice of president was in 2000. Would it even have mattered, since politics for the next decade and beyond would be changed, within a year, by 9/11 anyway?
- tedks 12y agoIt seems simple why historians would object to speculative fictional counterfactionals. Historians are concerned with the real effects of real events. People do very badly separating fictional evidence from true evidence (bring up AI and see how long it takes your conversational partner to bring up Terminator). As a result, it seems likely that people would discount certain things, or overvalue certain things, based on fictional historical counterfactual evidence. It's also quite possible to consider the impact of an event without fantasizing about what would have happened if it didn't happen; you can see the actual events that it caused and look at their magnitude and effects.
- onion2k 12y agoto make a jusgement over whether or not a particular event is significant, one has surely to consider what the world might have been like if it hadn't happened I don't see why that would be the case. If you can't explore the counterfactual realm at all, then you're unable to make any judgement at all about how important a particular event was, and so as a historian you might as well study what Al Gore had for breakfast the morning of the 2000 election as what led the supreme court to its decision on the Florida recount. Yes you can. You can see what impact each event actually had, and determine the more important one from that. You don't need to explore things that didn't happen. We take interest in the Supreme Court decision because history would be very different if it had gone another way. We do, but I'm not sure that's true of professional historians. They try to determine the actual reasons for things that happen that are based in fact. Speculation is more the realm of politicians and philosophers.
- jameshart 12y agoSo how do you determine whether something was a 'reason' for something, without considering a counterfactual? The very nature of a 'reason' is, it's something which had to happen in order for the consequence to follow. If the consequence would have happened anyway, then it's not a reason. The impact an event has can only be determined by imagining what would have happened if the event didn't take place, surely? Did America's use of the atomic bomb cause Japan to surrender? Can you answer that question without considering how Japan's leadership would have behaved if the bombs hadn't been dropped?
- the_af 12y ago> You can see what impact each event actually had, and determine the more important one from that. You don't need to explore things that didn't happen. I'm not sure. Suppose event X happens, followed by Y. How do you even know X caused Y? Probably you cannot ever know for sure, but the thought experiment "if X had never happened, then it's very unlikely Y would have happened" is relevant. If you cannot even formulate that thought experiment, then the link between X and Y starts to look weaker. This seems analogous to the scientific method to me, at least as much as can be done with history. So I must agree with the parent post. A historical event is significant if we can see it made a vast difference by happening. In other words, if we can see the world would have been very different had the event not happened.