3 ms·
Is the Centennial Light actually superior to the classic light bulb? The article states that the filament is 8 times thicker -- using 64 times more material --
by saalweachter 12y ago
Is the Centennial Light actually superior to the classic light bulb?
The article states that the filament is 8 times thicker -- using 64 times more material -- and only runs at 4 Watts. So to match the standard 100 Watt bulb, you'd need 25 Centennial Lights, for a total of 1600 times more material.
Meanwhile, it's burned for 113 years, about 990 times the standard bulb's 1000 hour lifespan. 990 times better using 1600 times more material; should I be impressed?
- techrat 12y ago>should I be impressed? Not really. Run a 100 watt lightbulb dimmed down to the brightness of a 1 watt bulb and it will also likely run for 100 years.
- smoyer 12y agoEspecially if you don't switch it on and off ... they've got that bulb on a UPS now so that it doesn't experience cooling/heating cycles which are what kill (or at least finally kill) most incandescent bulbs. As an aside, it's my experience that what kills most LED bulbs is transients that fry their control circuits. Has anyone else noticed this?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoWhat tends to kill incandescents is the non-uniform thinning of the tungsten wire due to tungsten evaporating, which causes the thinner parts to heat up more, combined with tungsten's positive temperature coefficient, which causes a current rush on power-up when the filament is cold, which causes the weak spots to heat up particularly rapidly and potentially higher that they would if the surrounding wire was hot and thus had higher resistance (a cold tungsten filament has about 1/15th the resistance compared to when it's glowing hot). Transients certainly are one problem for LEDs if the power filtering is bad, another is (lack of) cooling - while LEDs produce much less heat, they also need to stay much, much cooler: A tungsten filament is fine at 2400 °C, an LED die should not get much hotter than 100 °C, preferably less than that, and most fixtures are not particularly good at getting rid of heat.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 12y agoThe power consumption of a bulb is not a measure of its brightness - due to its low temperature, this bulb's black body spectrum is shifted much further towards the red end of the optical range than a common 100 W bulb, which means that a larger proportion of its output is in the infrared, which is invisible, and much less of it is in the green, which is where human eyes are most sensitive. So, you'd need a lot more than 25 of those to achieve the same brightness (which still would not give you the same light color, though). The only reason why you can somewhat compare modern incandescent bulbs by power is because the manufacturers have standardized on specific operating temperatures (the "cartel") - however, that only works for a given type of bulb, not between a "normal" one and a halogen one, for example, much less for the centennial light. Still, all that indeed makes for even less reason to be impressed ...