3 ms·
I always assumed that the personal-agent style work (ie a bot that is there to help you wade through the morass of information) would be a personal computation
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
I always assumed that the personal-agent style work (ie a bot that is there to help you wade through the morass of information) would be a personal computation - local to you, probably configured and augmented by you.
Yet Google is trying to do it for everyone - and honestly does not seem to be doing a bad job.
So what is the advantages of the old idea of an almost-AI assisstant working for me when BFG (Big Friendly Google) does it?
- walterbell 12y ago> honestly does not seem to be doing a bad job. Is there any difference between the goals of an individual (person, company) vs. the average? Is information a competitive advantage? Today we provide unpaid feedback to improve private algorithms, tomorrow ..? Edit: downvoters, what is a rhetorical question?
- ihsw 12y agoOne is derived from algorithmic matching, the other is explicit opt-in by the user. > local to you, probably configured and augmented by you.
- walterbell 12y agoEven if you opt-in to a centralized black box algo, it's not easy to audit the resulting advice. There is a big difference between explicit goals and the reverse-engineering of intent, e.g. from search history. We need both explicit goals and auditable algos.
- hrjet 12y ago> So what is the advantages of the old idea of an almost-AI assisstant working for me when BFG (Big Friendly Google) does it? Privacy. Yacy[1] looks like a good start but it has miles to go before it can reach the same usability as popular services. [1] http://yacy.net/en/ http://yacy.net/en/