4 ms·
So just to be clear, if he wins he makes 22.22~% profit (200K), if he loses then he's out 900K (100% loss). While that is a great ROV (relative to both interest
by Someone1234 12y ago
So just to be clear, if he wins he makes 22.22~% profit (200K), if he loses then he's out 900K (100% loss). While that is a great ROV (relative to both interest and or the stock market), it does seem like the stake was too high relative to the reward.
Could they not have taken that money, purchased a couple of homes (e.g. 2x 275k), renovated them up to modern standards (e.g. 2x 60-85K), and then resold them? A lot of people do that and it has a very high ROV also (as people get into bidding wars more easily on "ready to move into" property Vs. ones in need of renovation).
Plus with the property thing you always ultimately have the property/land which can be sold. So the risk isn't really 100% of the properties' value, it is at most the difference between purchase price and raw land value. Even in the 2008 recession a lot of people in the property game did "alright."
- TheBiv 12y agoCompletely valid points, and I have to imagine that the author would agree with you. I can't help but to imagine the novelty of the wager and the amount he was willing to risk, played a large part in him ultimately following through.
- idlewords 12y agoYou're assuming they have the money in hand long enough to invest it in real estate, and the time, masochism and expertise to do two renovations.
- easytiger 12y agoI think the analysis was a cover. Some m months ago in the polls a yes vote was universally preposterous. In reality it was quite close.
- bshimmin 12y agoWell, one option involves the hassle of renovating two homes (have you ever watched Grand Designs? The windows never fit...), the other involves walking into your nearest bookies. Perhaps if you have that sort of money to throw around you might like to take the quick and easy option.
- Tycho 12y agoYou could definitively answer how much he should have bet using what's known as the 'Kelly criterion.' Basically you need to consider the total wealth of the individual and the edge they believe they have (ie. bookies offer odds at 4/1 while the gambler reckons it's longer). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_criterion Whether this was a rational bet depends on how good he thought is edge was (perhaps allowing for some margin of error) and how rich he already is.
- eru 12y agoThe Kelly criterion applies for repeated bets. It optimizes the logarithmic expected winnings. I am not sure how it applies for a single bet. I guess it depends on one's like or dislike of risk.
- Tycho 12y agoI was wondering about that but I don't see how it wouldn't apply. In a series of bets it guarantees you wont go bust and will maximise your long term winnings (I'm probably missing some subtleties here so corrections welcome). But the whole concept can be traced back to a letter/essay by one of the Bernoulli family, in which the example was a one off bet. One other thing: it has always bothered me that people should have a 'like or dislike of risk.' Something about the concept doesn't sit right with me, unless we're talking about having an adrenaline rush. That's why I liked the Kelly criterion - it takes all notion of personal preference out of the picture and gives you a universal formula.
- eru 12y agoThe Kelly criterion is actually pretty simple. So it can actually be derived from a few different optimization criteria. Risk aversion is just something we see in practice. (And sometimes risk loving; like when people play the lottery and even take a negative expected value in exchange for a very small probability of a huge win.)
- thanatropism 12y agoIt's not that there's a like or dislike of risk. Preference orderings are either (locally) convex or concave. Risk aversion is just that, a preference ordering over mean/variance bundles. There was an econ textbook that gave a memorable example of a (qualified) exception to convexity: ice-cream and olives. Usually I'll want to have ice cream and olives in my fridge, but I don't want them at once! - so pure ice-cream would be prefered to a mix of them at my plate, right now. Risk aversion does not imply, on its own, that you don't want risk at all. It implies that you want some mix of risky and non-risky assets; while concavity towards risk would imply you want either one or the other. The problem with making risk aversion/convexity work with lotteries and such is that the price you're supposed to pay for lotteries is off your utility surface. But: since lottery tickets and small bets are relatively small in the context of your budget, one can figure that the mispricing in your overall mean/variance bundle is small, and that the emotion of betting may be the case of not wanting to optimize for a grey wall, an optimal mixture. Finally, re: universal formulae, I think you'd profit from reading Elie Ayache's _The Blank Swan_.
- notahacker 12y agoHe wouldn't have made 22% profit in a matter of days investing in property (and would have paid stamp duty and capital gains tax even if he could). He could make 22% in a few years with no effort whatsoever investing in a relatively low risk bond. Short term speculation with high returns always carries a very high degree of risk; that's why the very high returns exist. And yeah, bookmakers take a wider spread than most markets.
- eru 12y agoFlipping property like that is more like a job (with a big risk component). This was pure speculation.