5 ms·
Hey Apple/Google - add a new feature that allows me to set a second 'wipe phone code'.
by evo_9 12y ago
Hey Apple/Google - add a new feature that allows me to set a second 'wipe phone code'.
- DannyBee 12y agoIf you did this, a court would usually sanction you. In cases like this, the sanction is often "whatever they thought they could prove with the phone, is assumed to be proved".
- ufmace 12y agoIf only the same rule applied for Government agencies conveniently losing evidence. See IRS emails, dashcam videos, etc.
- mdm_ 12y agoAdd a feature where you can select what to wipe, e.g. you could choose to have it wipe only your SMS messages, so the phone still looks lived-in and not factory-fresh and make it impossible to tell whether the normal unlock code or wipe code was used.
- wyager 12y agoA better alternative is to have a second decryption code that allows you to unlock the phone, but to a completely unrelated set of files. This would be along the lines of a Truecrypt hidden volume. That way, the court can't get pissed at you for deleting evidence.
- Bud 12y agoExcept this would be easily detected as false data, via timestamps.
- aetherson 12y agoAnd, you know, they can tell that there remains an encrypted volume on your storage device.
- wyager 12y agoNo, you can't. At least, not generally. Look up truecrypt's hidden volumes. That is just one method of keeping plausibly deniable hidden files.
- wyager 12y agoThat's not conclusive. Look up how truecrypt's hidden volumes work. That is at least cryptographically sound. Then, you employ obfuscation techniques like occasionally using your "decoy" files.
- DannyBee 12y agoSo you think that hiding evidence is okay, but deleting evidence is not? Can i start with a simple question, actually? What is wrong with the authorities asking you to unlock your phone with a court order?
- npsimons 12y agoOh, I dunno, what have you got to hide? And before you say "nothing" realize that there's a hell of a lot more laws on the books than you think. You don't even have to dig very far for laws against things that shouldn't be illegal. What if you were living during prohibition, and the court ordered you to unlock your safe that had photos of you drinking in it? The biggest problems with how warrants are handled these days is that many are "fishing expeditions" where even when they are written for something specific, they can get you for something completely unrelated (eg, found a joint in your house while searching for stolen goods).
- DannyBee 12y agoThis isn't "NSA surveillance when you've done nothing wrong". This is a proper legal process initiated against you, with a proper court order. What greater process do you want? Do you believe the answer is "you should never be forced to disclose this?". If so, the answer is to expand the fifth amendment. It doesn't say that :) "What if you were living during prohibition, and the court ordered you to unlock your safe that had photos of you drinking in it? " Don't do illegal things? "The biggest problems with how warrants are handled these days is that many are "fishing expeditions" where even when they are written for something specific, they can get you for something completely unrelated (eg, found a joint in your house while searching for stolen goods)." So then your problem is essentially "you don't liek what is illegal", and "you don't like that warrants enable the police to investigate"? Seriously, i'm not trying to make light of your concerns, i'm just trying to see what you see as the solution, and i can't see how "not having to unlock your phone" is the solution to any of the concerns you raise.
- wyager 12y ago>Don't do illegal things? Wow, you're right. The Jews in Nazi Germany should have just not been Jewish. Legality is not the same as morality.
- ytjohn 12y agoI too would love to see a plausible deniability like Truecrypt provided. Entering a passcode unlocks the phone, but only files stored under that passcode is visible. There is no way to tell how many hidden volumes there are. This does fall apart however. If I took an encrypted laptop or external drive somewhere and was required to unlock it, I would most likely be opening a filesystem that is out of date. During normal operation, you have to pay attention and ensure both volumes get files updated to make it appear current. For an external drive, you do this by mounting both volumes and storing your files accordingly. On a computer, you have to be concerned about traces left within the OS itself. So you have to be really careful about cleaning up after yourself. Or, you setup two copies of your OS and occasionally boot into your "clean" one and load files onto it. On a phone though.. the important stuff like call logs, sms messages, chat history.. that's what the authorities are after. If they know your phone is capable of "hidden volumes" and find that you have minimal/old history on your phones, they'll get suspicious. If messages or calls known to be sent to your phone don't appear, that is a pretty good indicator that you're not complying with the order. I think the only thing that could really work is a built in "kill switch". This would be a time sensitive in-memory program that requires a periodic check-in by you to keep it from nulling out all the application data and factory reseting the phone. Essentially, this has to work with no action on your part. If it can happen without you ever touching the phone once it's in custody, that's ideal.