3 ms·
Kerr's first post claims that #2 is the current state of the law now with respect to passcodes. In general, 5th Amendment protections do not give people the po
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Kerr's first post claims that #2 is the current state of the law now with respect to passcodes.
In general, 5th Amendment protections do not give people the power to resist warrants for evidence. The law makes a distinction between evidence (which can be compelled via warrant) and testimony (which cannot due to the 5th Amendment). If digital information stored on a phone is evidence covered by the 4th amendment[1], then the court can compel a person to provide it, including compelling them to use their passcode.
Kerr's argument in his first post was that high-profile efforts to actively resist such warrants might lead the courts or Congress to "up the ante" by increasing the possible punishments. For example, imagine if Congress passed a law that failure to enter your passcode in a federal case results in a mandatory 10 year federal sentence (my invented example, not Kerr's). This is the legal equivalent of the "rubber hose" approach to defeating cryptography.
[1] Generally I think we probably do want it to be so treated, because it would be a strong basis for limiting the NSA's power to collect such information.