2 ms·
> I'm going to mostly point out that although this is an appealing idea: that we only get out of ourselves what we put in/etc./etc. there's no reason for it to
by curtis3389 12y ago
> I'm going to mostly point out that although this is an appealing idea: that we only get out of ourselves what we put in/etc./etc. there's no reason for it to be true.
A) Meditation takes concerted effort (by definition).
B) Meditaiton has been shown to increase empathy: http://nccam.nih.gov/research/results/spotlight/060608.htm http://nccam.nih.gov/research/results/spotlight/060608.htm
Conclusion) You can put effort into improving yourself and improve yourself (in this case: become more empathetic toward others).
> They're compounds which have debatable (and unresearched) longer term effects on those who imbibe them,
25 years is pretty long: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment#Doblin.27s_follow-up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_Chapel_Experiment#Doblin...
But we do need more.
> and which have fairly established negative impact on people who take them and are at risk for developing a serious mental illness. (family history, etc.)
Yes. If you have a family history of schizophrenia (or other severe mental illnesses), you shouldn't try psychedelic drugs. They can precipitate schizophrenic episodes, psychotic breaks, and the like.
Other than that, I totally agree. I was just trying to clearly and succinctly discount the enlightenment-in-a-pill attitude.
- theworst 12y agoAllow me to preface this by saying I think we are in agreement, but I want to make sure we understand each other. GP was just pointing out there is no law of nature that says the things worth having require effort. Your meditation anecdote is correct, but does not address the comment. There are things which are very good for us, but take little personal effort to attain (antibiotics are a good example, to continue with the drug theme...) I believe meditation is an important, effortful aspect to understanding myself and how I relate to the world. I also believe that the psychedelic experiences I have had have worked in a similar, complementary manner. In either case, the amount of effort it took is not necessarily connected with the value received. (Also, FWIW, not all meditation is concerted effort. Do you mean mindfulness? I believe Zen meditation advises that you let go of everything and do not focus; the blank slate principle and all that.) Thank you for your polite comment.