3 ms·
This actually isn't entirely settled law. Some argue that the 5th ammendment protection from self-incrimination would give someone the right not to give up thei
by jrochkind1 12y ago
This actually isn't entirely settled law. Some argue that the 5th ammendment protection from self-incrimination would give someone the right not to give up their passcode. But different courts have ruled differently in differnet situations/jurisdictions, so far.
- brigade 12y agoAs mentioned in the article, the current (and consistent across existing rulings) legal theory is that the 5th amendment doesn't apply if it's already been "proven" that you know the passcode, since the self-incrimination is divulging the fact that you know the passcode to incriminating files (therefore, by implication you're responsible for the existence of said files) And since you're not proving this to a jury, but rather a judge, the standard of proof is going to be pretty low for a smartphone. Orin Kerr thinks possession of a phone at time of arrest will be enough to prove to a judge that you know the passcode, and given how low-level judges operate in the real world I'm inclined to agree (in practice, not legal theory or what's just.) Anyway, iCloud backups are still fair game, so it's not like LEOs can't typically get the information they want anyway even without the passcode.