3 ms·
That’s different from keeping a promise to his wife, but it’s also different from being “whipped” (i.e. under the complete control of his wife). That’s just lyi
by jacobolus 12y ago
That’s different from keeping a promise to his wife, but it’s also different from being “whipped” (i.e. under the complete control of his wife). That’s just lying to his friends and blaming his wife for it. (Which is also pretty dysfunctional, but clearly not what the essay’s author was talking about.)
I think it’s pretty weird that the only real discussions of gender relations in this essay are (a) husband and wife can be naked with each other, when they wouldn’t go naked in public, and (b) this cheap throwaway stereotype about the controlling wife not letting the hapless guy have fun with his buddies.
The essay would be stronger with the section about the “whipped” guy removed altogether.
- teddyh 12y agoIt’s not weird to not discuss gender issues in an article not about gender issues. > The essay would be stronger with the section about the “whipped” guy removed altogether. I agree — these kinds of examples very much serve as triggers for people with gender-related issues or other axes to grind, and are therefore not very effective as examples.
- mcphage 12y ago> That’s different from keeping a promise to his wife, but it’s also different from being “whipped” (i.e. under the complete control of his wife). That’s just lying to his friends and blaming his wife for it. You may be right. I know more of the "deflecting my decisions" people than the "whipped" people, so I had assumed the author meant the former. But you're probably right that he didn't. > The essay would be stronger with the section about the “whipped” guy removed altogether. Agreed. It was out of place, and at best a sitcom stereotype, rather than how real people interact.