4 ms·
One recent model estimated that eating a mere 30 calories a day more than you use is enough to lead to serious weight gain. The article here is being a bit mis
by yummyfajitas 12y ago
One recent model estimated that eating a mere 30 calories a day more than you use is enough to lead to serious weight gain.
The article here is being a bit misleading. The calories in/calories out model says that if you add 30 calories/day to your diet, you will get a little fatter and stop.
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/weight_stability.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/weight_stability.html
If you actually experience serious weight gain, it's because you first added 30 calories/day to your diet, then added 30 more, and continued for a long time.
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/inanity_of_overeating.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2011/inanity_of_overeating...
This is nonsense that Gary Taubes was pushing a few years back - it's sad to see that it's become a mainstream meme, particularly when simple arithmetic shows it's misleading.
The article goes further off the rails: Why, if body weight is a matter of individual decisions about what to eat, should it be affected by differences in wealth or by relations between the sexes?
Clearly, a woman living in India will make the exact same choices as a woman in Sweden - her environment will never lead to different choices.
This idea that gaining/losing weight is hard is nonsense. I do it regularly. About 7 months ago I was finishing up a bulk - I weighed 240lb, and added an extra 45lb for chinups. After my cut I was 196 and rocking a 6 pack.
I ate 5 meals a day plus a snack while bulking, little more than rice and dal and some eggs while cutting. It's called self control.
- 7Figures2Commas 12y ago> This idea that gaining/losing weight is hard is nonsense. This isn't necessarily true. Everyone is different. Extreme ectomorphs, for instance, can have a very difficult time gaining weight, even with professional assistance and much effort. > I ate 5 meals a day plus a snack while bulking, little more than rice and dal and some eggs while cutting. It's called self control. It's also called unhealthy. Bulking and cutting may be appropriate for competitive bodybuilders, but repeatedly gaining significant amounts of weight and then cutting to body fat percentages not much above essential levels is almost certainly no better a model for overall health and wellness than a lifestyle that results in obesity.
- aianus 12y ago> This idea that gaining/losing weight is hard is nonsense. Fat people have it easy, they only have to deal with the discomfort of eating too little. Gaining weight is on a whole different level. I can try to play through the pain and eat more when I'm already full but it doesn't do me any good if I throw it back up or have diarrhea. Both of which happen frequently as soon as I start trying to bulk.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoYeah, I should have been clearer that a bulk can be difficult - I was mainly focusing on the cut, which is what most people claim is hard. Certainly there are people who gain a lot more muscle from a bulk than I do. I'm on the wrong side of 30...