8 ms·
The invasion of corporate news
- mark_l_watson 12y agoWow. Scary trend in corporate control of the local news. I have been concerned for a long time about corporate control of the few large news outlets like MSNBC, Fox, CNN, etc. I think that they all filter the news and enforce a slanted version of the news not in the public interest. There are some organizations like Democracy Now that do a much better job.
- krakensden 12y ago> Scary trend in corporate control of the local news. Local news has been in a death spiral since the early 1990s, and no longer exists in most places that aren't big enough to have skyscrapers. I think there's a strong case that this is better than nothing, and that the honesty of its patronage limits the damage (and will encourage competition). This is not theoretical to me. I grew up in the area, and do not feel that McClatchy (who basically has a monopoly) has managed its East Bay mastheads in an effective or useful manner.
- narrator 12y agoThere used to be good independent radio in the early 90s too but it all got bought up by clear channel. I used to listen to the radio but the music stopped changing in the early 90s after grunge came out.
- Varcht 12y agoFor music I like to think that Gen X nailed it. My 18 year old bought a record player and collects 80's and 90's records while keeping up with the new stuff, but maybe it's just the man keeping her down.
- bostik 12y agoThe single most depressing quote from the article, understandably lifted even on the page itself: > "For every working journalist in America there, are now 4.6 PR people, up from 3.2 a decade ago" We can respin (pun intended) that in slightly different way: journalists in US are outnumbered by spin doctors more than 4 to 1. That's a sad figure for anyone who cares about finding out the truth.
- evgen 12y agoNot sure what makes me more sad, the idea that you think journalists are in some way involved in the task of "finding out the truth" or that you are surprised by the ratios. Journalism has been on its death bed for at least a decade with the number of people working in that field dropping every year, while marketing and advertising have continued to grow in a world where the standard user expectation is to not pay for online content and where they instead expect to be surrounded by advertising as the price of admission.
- bostik 12y agoIt is subtler than that, but I am surprised by the ratios. Journalists do not themselves uncover truths. They uncover material and details that can point to a truth. And the core of the problem is that journalism is slow. In the time it takes to fact-check an investigative article, the spinmeisters have had ample time to do what they do best. Namely, set up smoke and mirrors. The power asymmetry is painful, and I have no doubt about this being even a recent thing. There's a quote attributed to Mark Twain on the subject: “A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes.”
- Spooky23 12y agoPersonally, I think this is a good thing, because the more blatant aspect of the propaganda coming out of these outlets will inspire and frighten the people on the other side -- inspiring competitive voices. We've operated in a world where influence is more subtle and it was easy to pretend that the news was unbiased. It wasn't, especially at the local level. The reporting wasn't propaganda, but the editorial board directs the reporters -- and the juiciest news is always the stuff that isn't in the paper, or is buried in section Z somewhere. One of my relatives was a cabinet-level official in a mid-sized city in the 80s and 90s, when a hotshot reporter drove a Porsche. Unless it was a personal scandal affecting the Mayor, or people were marching in the streets, my relative could either make a phone call or have his boss make a phone call and kill/neuter a story. If you look at news in the American Revolutionary era through the Civil War, it was big mess of different news outlets with very well defined biases. It's different than the late 20th century model of Woodward and Bernstein in the paper and a fatherly figure with good hair on TV, but it worked and will work again.
- lotharbot 12y ago> "the editorial board directs the reporters" ... and both the editorial board and reporters select how to cover the news. Some of my relatives were active on a significant political issue in the 80s and 90s, holding state-level positions in a well-known organization. As a teen, I would occasionally attend rallies, protests, etc. (sometimes with counter-rallies/protests across the street) and watch from a distance, and then I'd watch the news coverage that evening. The camera always seemed to fall on awkwardly dressed senior citizens from our side, ignoring our speakers who were often young professional women who were excellent public speakers, and ignoring the large and diverse crowd. And the camera never showed the guys on the other side making threatening remarks (though I know they got those remarks on film); they'd instead seek comment from a lawyer in their office to give a calm presentation of that side. So even though they covered the event, the coverage gave the impression that one side was professional and well-spoken while the other was out of touch and weird, which was exactly the opposite of the impression I got from being there.
- foobarqux 12y ago
- alecco 12y agoBernays would be jealous. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays http://vimeo.com/85948693 http://vimeo.com/85948693 The Century of the Self - Part 1
- ozmbie 12y agoAs Marshall Mcluhan said: The medium is the message. When television came to dominate the media landscape in the 60s, it also redefined news and media. Now social media and the internet is starting to do the same, in its own way. Inherent properties and biases of this new medium are distorting the types of content that fit in it.
- asaramis 12y agoI found this article to embody every problem with the attitude of journalists from traditional media institutions. The author effectively is lamenting his loss of role as the gatekeeper of all information. Apparently, all journalism was 'pure' and devoid of any conflicts of interest and the only way to receive the 'truth' for a reader. You can see this near arrogance flow through much of the anecdotes. "Ugh, more and more PR people trying to get my attention all the time. It's sooo annoying." "Ugh, PR girls are even trying to sleep with me, but you can't compromise my editorial integrity." It's perfectly represents the entitlement of the gatekeeper role that must've been built into that last generation of journalists. Sorry for the mild rant but sites like Hacker News and Reddit have shown that readers are plenty smart, and capable of sifting through the bullshit, whether produced by a corporation, a newspaper, or an individual. When news media held a monopoly on distribution and there were few sources of info, I understand the danger of a corporation holding the sole lifeline of info. That's no longer the case.
- walterbell 12y ago> readers are plenty smart, and capable of sifting through the bullshit This has an opportunity cost.
- ionwake 12y agoThis is way I built sagebump over a weekend as a side project for myself. It applies merging aswell as custom filtering using open source algorithms I came across on HN and elsewhere. I only wish more people gave it a go, I seem to be the only user at the moment unfortunately. Feedback is totally welcome if anyone wants to take a quick gander. Use this link for a "Technical filtering pass" http://www.sagebump.com/?view=technocrat&info http://www.sagebump.com/?view=technocrat&info
- SnacksOnAPlane 12y agoI think you really need a clearer explanation of your goals for the project. I mean, it looks like it could be a neat time-saver, but I don't think I can customize it (I've picked my subscribed reddits carefully already), and it doesn't have the niceties of Reddit Enhancement Suite.
- zobzu 12y agoI'm not sure how that's really new tho. Its stronger than ever before if anything, but ive seen non-sponsored news and news that were factual since i dont know.
- tudorconstantin 12y agoWhat's the difference between corporate influence and political influence regarding news? Politicians influence the news from their beginning, the only difference being that they pay reporters and media outlets with tax money. Given the small revenues that a news article generates, I fully understand the temptation to write for a check. Hey, at least the journalist doesnt have to blackmail any company/individual with disclosures they want to remain secret.
- msrpotus 12y agoNot sure where you're from but the US government doesn't fund any news organizations in the US. In developed countries with taxpayer-funded news (like the BBC), there are several layers in between the funding and reporters to protect their independence.
- narrator 12y agoReminds me of this Conan O'Brein piece. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM8L7bdwVaA#t=26 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM8L7bdwVaA#t=26 Basically, 100s of local newscasts are all using the exact same script, even on trivial human interest stories where they could improvise.
- transfire 12y agoNever believe anything.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoIn case you haven't seen it yet, I highly recommend taking the next 11 minutes to watch John Oliver talk about native advertising: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc
- typpo 12y agoI noticed a recent increase in the amount of native advertising, especially poorly labeled "sponsored content," and built a chrome/firefox extension to flag these articles [1]. It includes rules for the sites mentioned - Buzzfeed, Mashable, Quartz, and Vice - as well as about 100 others. Reactions from publishers and native ad companies were surprisingly positive - some even reached out asking to me add their sites. In general I think a lot of people in publishing are very conflicted about the problem because it gets into journalistic ethics, which are deeply ingrained. Currently an organization called the IAB provides the standard for the industry, but it's vague and lags behind innovation in native ads [2]. Native ads aren't necessarily bad, but their inconsistency that makes them very deceptive to users. I think publishers would benefit from an updated set of standards that enforce consistent messaging. [1] http://ianww.com/ad-detector http://ianww.com/ad-detector [2] http://www.iab.net/nativeadvertising http://www.iab.net/nativeadvertising
- hackuser 12y agoA great idea, thanks. A suggestion: If you could post it someplace that allows user reviews, I'd be much more likely to download it. It's hard to tell if it will cause performance problems, installs/uninstalls well, false-positive/negative rates, identifies advertorials that I wouldn't find on my own, etc. I could try it, but there are many, many add-ons to try! That said, I hope it works well and becomes widely used. The publishers should be putting that alert on their pages themselves.
- typpo 12y agoThanks for the feedback. The chrome/firefox pages have user reviews but there aren't many of them. I was sensitive to performance when I wrote it - in most cases detection rules are single selectors. It won't run anything on sites not in the db. No library dependencies. There's a phantomjs test suite that flags false positives and negatives. Of course, I can't personally compile a list of every site with sponsored content, so if it's not on the list the addon won't display anything. If you're interested, the code is open source at http://github.com/typpo/ad-detector http://github.com/typpo/ad-detector. Hard for me to say whether it can spot ads that you can't. Many people think they aren't susceptible to ads like these, and I'm one of them, but I built this for peace of mind. Sponsored content can be easy to miss. My favorite examples are this Yahoo news article on climate change (written by an oil company), and a Newsweek article on personal injury lawyers: [1] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/global-cooling-real-inconvenient-truth-140500879.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/global-cooling-real-inconveni... [2] http://www.newsweek.com/10-best-personal-injury-attorneys http://www.newsweek.com/10-best-personal-injury-attorneys
- WalterBright 12y agoI wonder when the golden age of unbiased news reporting was. I'm 55 and my whole life everyone complained about the biased media. Heck, even the reporting on the Boston Massacre is a classic of bias.
- hackuser 12y ago>I wonder when the golden age of unbiased news reporting was. I'm 55 and my whole life everyone complained about the biased media. Agreed; people naturally exaggerate the good old days and forget how advertisers and other interests often owned [EDIT: figuratively and literally] many media outlets. Maybe it's better that those powers publish their own stories; at least they generally own up to it rather than hiding behind journalists for legitimacy. But I also disagree strongly: It's a matter of degree, of course. No journalism ever was written, edited and published by wise saints, but some is much better than others. There is Fox News and there is the Financial Times; neither is purely bad or good, but one is far better than the other. The problems discussed in the article make journalism significantly less valuable and reliable, and there is no good substitute for it. The public simply will lack good information and will believe more false information.
- WalterBright 12y agoI still doubt anything has changed. I remember the hatchet jobs "60 Minutes" was infamous for 40 years ago. "If it bleeds it leads" is a very old saying. So is "history is written by the victors". And it's normal for news to run hysterical stories, because those sell. But there's a more general problem. There are some fields I know a great deal about. Whenever I see a news story about one of those fields, they're almost always pathetically wrong. This is because the journalists are reporting on something they have no understanding of. I've also seen them report on events I have personal knowledge of, again, they get it all wrong, usually because they're in a hurry to get the story "in the can" and simply don't care to fact check. My father was a historian, and in our discussions we'd often wonder how much of conventionally accepted historical truth is utterly wrong.
- 12y ago
- hackuser 12y agoHere is why the integrity of journalism is so important: In my experience, most people form opinions by effectively shopping among the various narratives offered by the many forms of media, including those described in the article, and picking the one they like most -- as if they were shopping for a sweater to wear. Then they base their opinion on the chosen narrative, but of course once the questions are framed and facts established, their 'opinion' is preordained. That is no accident. The narratives often are created by interests whose goal is to manipulate public opinion, and their stories are repeated widely, wittingly by their agents and unwittingly by everyone else. This isn't conspiracy theory; you can read plenty of legitimate research where this process is openly described; even the vocabulary you probably use to discuss public issues often is carefully constructed by someone. Public opinion can be manipulated to vary widely from the facts (consider climate change, Saddam Hussein's connection to 9/11, etc. etc.) and also it is an extremely valuable asset. Manipulating it can change history, and create and destroy political and personal fortunes -- and nations, as well as start/end wars, kill/save hundreds of millions of people, and make/lose trillions of dollars ('regulation is choking the experts on Wall Street'). So of course there are many, many people who will manipulate it. There is a game being played and most people don't know it is happening, much less that they are its objects. How does this happen? I think many people are swayed by the big lies -- they can't believe so much is so deceitful. Also, in my experience the best educated, smartest people I know are often the most easily led; perhaps they are hamstrung by their intellectual confidence, because I often hear them repeating one side or another's talking points and underlying propaganda. Finally, it's hard to educate anyone on this issue; there is no nice way to say, 'you've been fooled' and 'most of what you say is someone else's propaganda'. But how does it happen? It's not true that society can rely on citizens to sort truth from falsehood; the reality is that people are easily led. It is up to the elites in our society, including journalists, to ensure they are getting something closer to the truth. I doubt there is a solution for corrupt elites.
- narrator 12y agoIf you come up with a different understanding from the mainstream it will take an hour of your time to explain it to the average person, if and only if they are extremely open minded, and then they will forget it. The mainstream media gets to talk to hundreds of millions for a couple of hours every week. At least it's a bit better now that there's the internet.
- iuguy 12y agoThis is a serious issue in the UK, particularly where local governments use taxpayer money to put free 'newspapers' in everyone's doors. It's actually reached a point where the national government has had to look into what one MP has called, "propaganda masquerading as independent newspapers"[1] [1] - http://www.editorsweblog.org/2010/01/21/uk-government-to-investigate-local-council-papers http://www.editorsweblog.org/2010/01/21/uk-government-to-inv...
- jonifico 12y agoThis issue comes from the increasingly shameless attitude from corporations toward what is, plain and simple, getting money. Now there are news about multibillion dollar businesses coming up, start-ups that become successful, etc, etc. Big companies are realizing this and are starting to take action. Ugly action.
- VLM 12y agoThere is another oddity about the article "emerge in the age of hyper-local digital news brands such as Patch" Patch is closing down and firing people. Ours closed. It does not appear to be a survivable business model, although they gave it a good try and it was interesting reading while it lasted.
- andyzweb 12y agorelated pg essay: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- dleibovic 12y agoCardiff University researchers estimated in 2006 that 41 per cent of UK press articles were driven by PR, a phenomenon known as “churnalism”. Wow.