3 ms·
> It is herds and movements that are disempowering. As an absolute statement - condemning all movements and all ideology without distinguishing between their i
by justin66 12y ago
> It is herds and movements that are disempowering.
As an absolute statement - condemning all movements and all ideology without distinguishing between their intrinsic merits - this is extremely odd. Without "herds and movements" we'd still be clever mammals without the power of speech. Something below even tribal societies, without the ability to even teach one another how to use tools or to act ethically.
The recognition that some ideals are false does not preclude having them.
> People should organize on concrete issues and leave the ideology (levers for mass manipulation) at the door
What do you think motivates people to "organize on concrete issues" and pick a side on those issues? Ideology does, 100% of the time. How is this even controversial?
More concretely, the notion that we cannot engage in an ideological movement - a party voting bloc, for example - without being subsumed by that ideology or engaging in self-defeating behavior is demonstrably false. People form coalitions because coalitions work. It's a pretty basic thing in voting theory and political science that you win more for your side if you are willing to form coalitions with differing parties and compromise.