3 ms·
Most developers don't care about the platforms with the most reach and most invested gamers. Sure. Must be why every indie developer I know would sell their eye
by eropple 12y ago
Most developers don't care about the platforms with the most reach and most invested gamers. Sure. Must be why every indie developer I know would sell their eyeteeth to get even a mid level promo package on PSN.
You're taking your ideology and trying to retrofit the world to accomodate it. Doesn't work that way. In the world of what is, rather than the world of what one might like it to be, nobody really cares. Tough.
- shmerl 12y ago> You're taking your ideology You are talking about Apple's spin of Metal (which is lock-in ideology). In practice it's easier for developers to use one toolkit instead of using 20 locked-in incompatible APIs. If developers use ready engines it becomes easier for them, but that burden is shifted to engine developers then. Someone will have to deal with that major mess. There is clear pragmatic benefit in cross platform APIs for gaming, and claiming that it's just ideology is nonsense.
- eropple 12y ago> In practice it's easier for developers to use one toolkit instead of using 20 locked-in incompatible APIs. Not when that "one toolkit" is worse. You are conflating "lock-in" with "optimal suitability for a platform". Hardware matters. Your continual handwaving can't ignore that.
- shmerl 12y ago> Not when that "one toolkit" is worse. Here it's the case of "worse because it wasn't made better", not because it can't be better. That's my point. So difference in approaches with this subject like between AMD and Apple shows who cares about making it better and who cares about locking developers into their platform.
- EpicEng 12y agoSo, your "point", in everything that I have read from you thus far, is that, if the world only worked the way you think it should work, then OpenGL would reign supreme as king. We can just ignore the many ways in which it sucks because, hey, you're talking hypotheticals! Right. Of course, the real world works nothing like the world that you have described, but ok, good luck with that.
- eropple 12y agoThere's a lot of Linux-on-the-desktop-style wishcasting in this thread.
- shmerl 12y agoOr rather Apple-style lock-in cheerleading.
- eropple 12y agoNobody's advocating lock-in. What is being advocated is using the right tool for the job. What has been brought up--by you--is the completely laughable notion that "abstractions don't fail" when the overwhelming majority of people involved with high-performance graphics are pretty sure that the abstractions have failed. Which is why they're going exactly the other way from your ideological wishcasting and building libraries and frameworks that are tailored to the hardware rather than using a driver to overcome the impedance mismatch at the cost of performance. You don't know what you don't know but it isn't stopping you from talking shit. Stop.
- shmerl 12y ago> when the overwhelming majority of people involved with high-performance graphics are pretty sure that the abstractions have failed. Poor abstractions. I'm not convinced that there can't be a well designed cross platform graphics API that is sufficient for the majority of cases. Prove that it's impossible or stop, because otherwise your claim that you don't advocate lock-in doesn't sound sincere.