4 ms·
There are a lot of really interesting things happening that this article looks at from exactly one angle -- the billing. What I want from NYT is an article whic
by zaroth 12y ago
There are a lot of really interesting things happening that this article looks at from exactly one angle -- the billing. What I want from NYT is an article which really examines the situation, and not just sensationalizing numbers.
For example, Medicare would have paid only 1% for the assistant's work; that's the market rate that they set. This has all sorts of implications... I assume doctors must have some reason to accept those rates, other than out of some ethical responsibility. It sounds like private insurers are hugely subsidizing Medicare by paying 100x the price. If everyone paid the same rate, Medicare would have to pay a lot more, or there would be a lot less of these procedures.
On the other hand, anyone who actually pays that list price is giving the doctor a gift. If they explained the median price patients pay the doctor out-of-pocket, I wonder if the examples would line up.
It is interesting to read about some patients who went to extraordinary means to discover ahead of time what their costs would be, only to be basically assaulted with an outrageous bill in the end. For a planned procedure and even for an emergency, I think the doctor performing the work should find a way to work with their patient's insurance plan. And insurance plans should have reasonable coverage and customary payment terms which are accepted. The doctors shouldn't get to fleece the insurance companies either.
The level of price discrimination is completely out of control, but I think the legal framework is in place, right now, to protect patients and insurers both from these bills. It's a tax on the rich and middle class, since the doctors collect some small fraction of total billings. It's like a lose-lose double lottery.
- oh_sigh 12y ago> It sounds like private insurers are hugely subsidizing Medicare by paying 100x the price More like they are billed 100x the price, negotiate down to 10x the price in general, and otherwise default to a point where the business collects .85x the price.
- zaroth 12y agoIn the example in the article, the private insurance DID pay the full amount. I don't understand why the private insurer would ever do that, but in this case that's what was reported.
- nols 12y agoYou're mistaken on the Medicare only paying 1% for the assistant's work. They only pay 16% of the primary physician for the assistant, which in this case was 1% of Dr Mu's fee.
- guiambros 12y ago> What I want from NYT is an article which really examines the situation, and not just sensationalizing numbers. ... > For example, Medicare would have paid only 1% for the assistant's work... It sounds like private insurers are hugely subsidizing Medicare by paying 100x the price. I don't think they're sensationalizing the numbers. Private insurers are not paying 100x Medicare. They pay negotiated rates to in-network professionals, which is typically 20-100x lower than the list price. But doctors and companies are being creative, and using out-of-network services as a cover-up, so the private insurances can't enforce their negotiated rates. In some cases it's better to just settle with doctors, to avoid lawsuits and problems with patients' employers. But this rewards the bad behavior. With layers and more layers of companies, hospitals, consultants and lawyers, all trying to maximize their revenue targets, it's not a surprise that we're seeing six-digit bills for an assistant surgeon. The system is completely broken. Until we have a complete reform, and more strict laws like New York's Surprise Bill Law [1], I'm afraid we'll see more cases like this. The only solution is to (try to) stay healthy. If you can. [1] http://www.nyacp.org/files/public/169463_Health_Alert_3JUNE2014.pdf http://www.nyacp.org/files/public/169463_Health_Alert_3JUNE2...
- ThomPete 12y agoIf you have the means already yes the legal system is in place if not you are out of luck. I was at one point presented with the option of either paying between 30-150.000USD for having a stage one melanoma removed or wait a year until the pre-existing condition clause was canceled out. Luckily I found another way but I have the resources to do so and I almost got screwed both financially and literally. What I don't understand is why the US doesn't adopt something like in Switzerland which have universal healthcare but it's privately insured. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Switzerland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Switzerland
- dalke 12y ago"What I want from NYT is an article which really examines the situation, and not just sensationalizing numbers." Steven Brill, in Time, wrote an excellent article on just that topic. The subscriber access is at http://time.com/198/bitter-pill-why-medical-bills-are-killing-us/ http://time.com/198/bitter-pill-why-medical-bills-are-killin... while a no cost version is at http://www.uta.edu/faculty/story/2311/Misc/2013,2,26,MedicalCostsDemandAndGreed.pdf http://www.uta.edu/faculty/story/2311/Misc/2013,2,26,Medical... . See also an interview with him at http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health-jan-june13-healthcare_02-25/ http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health-jan-june13-healthcare_... . Brill's thesis is that with most medical care it is impossible to do the comparison shopping that you emphasize should be possible "even in an emergency." You hypothesize that "private insurers are hugely subsidizing Medicare by paying 100x the price." As http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/521175_2 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/521175_2 comments, "U.S. hospitals now receive abut [sic] 31 percent of their net revenues from Medicare." Moreover, if you start to read about the US system you would realize that Medicare is prevented, by US law, from negotiating drug prices. Private insurers, on the other hand, can do so. The Brill piece covers that detail. Since your hypothesis doesn't match reality, it must be incorrect. I am not well informed of this topic, and my knowledge is mostly limited to the popular press. I cannot therefore point to any critical research. There was a recent posting here on HN, at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8304019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8304019 , concerning "The Cost of My Mother’s Cardiac Care in the United States and India." The actual article is at http://www.annfammed.org/content/12/5/470.long http://www.annfammed.org/content/12/5/470.long , which starts "When my mother fell ill while visiting me in the United States, I had the opportunity to compare costs of surgical cardiac care in the United States and India. I faced challenges in making well-informed decisions in the United States due to the lack of cost transparency and the minimal flexibility offered in choice of care, whereas in India costs are readily available and allow most people to freely choose their preferred type of care." It sounds like you are saying that NYT should, in every piece about a topic, give the full details to justify its arguments. That's not how newspapers work. They often give many different pieces; some of which examine the situation, and others which help flesh out details. This is one of the latter. You are supposed to read the newspaper over time to get a better sense of the whole. Otherwise, you need to look towards the specialist literature, like review papers on the economics of the US health system, to get the answers you're looking for. BTW, you like the word "should" - you used it three times. The many observations show that the US health care system isn't the way you think it should be. There is no legal framework like what you asserted. This suggests you are basing your opinions more on wishful thinking, rather than trying to understand what is actually a quite complex and well-discussed issue. I hope those links I gave help provide a beginning for you.