3 ms·
>>> What if case information was updated as per part of the legal process, aka person X is now innocent. You seem to be confusing two questions here: access to
by smsm42 12y ago
>>> What if case information was updated as per part of the legal process, aka person X is now innocent.
You seem to be confusing two questions here: access to data and reliability of data. Let's take the example of opens source software, specifically linux kernel you mentioned. Anybody can create a mirror of linux kernel sources. Would that mirror be up-to-date? Who knows. How we solve this problem? We have a network of authoritative mirrors, we have signatures, we have places where new persons can discover which mirrors are recommended to be used. Does this mean if you want to open a new mirror you'd be banned from doing so until you prove you're worthy? No. But in order for your mirror to be useful by more than yourself, you'd have to convince others you are.
Same can work with legal and scientific information. Let's even say federal government, with all its trillions of dollars, can not afford hosting a free information site. Removing merely legal hurdles, while keeping paid access, would allow volunteers with cooperation of trustworthy organizations - like universities, major NGOs, etc. - to raise private funds to keep free mirrors alive and up-to-date.
This is a solved problem, the only thing preventing its deployment is the legal prohibition. Quality is not a problem, we know how to solve quality issue. Swartz tried to use technology to go around legal hurdles - unfortunately, in current environment this no longer works, law has caught with technology enough to resist attempts to work around it with technology. Now one can only hope it would soon advance enough to actually enable technology to help, not only disable it.