10 ms·
FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz
- jdong 12y agoWhat makes this case such a big deal? Swartz did something that was obviously illegal and got caught.
- McDoku 12y agoBecause our law is made by the hands of ultimately fallible beings. We are inevitably going to make mistakes. This is the reason we have legislative bodies. They are a guard against our own lack of omnipotence.
- jdong 12y agoSure, but there really doesn't seem to be anything wrong with the law here. Aaron wasn't even convicted of anything.
- McDoku 12y agoI think it was highlighting the gaps in legislation and prosecution brought about by technological illiteracy. This has been a crucial ongoing debate.
- jdong 12y agoI don't think technological illiteracy plays a large part here, Aaron exploited a flaw in JSTORs ratelimiting system and continued doing so after being blocked several times by JSTOR administration. After that didn't work out he broke into a server cabinet at MIT. Does that sound 100% OK to you?
- DanBC 12y agoIt doesn't sound like something I'd send someone to jail for.
- jdong 12y agoThing is, you have to draw a line somewhere. Essentially he was exploiting a vulnerability in JSTOR to mass download court documents, what if he was downloading credit cards instead? Or some sort of corporate secrets? (Sure, credit cards and court documents are very very different. But the act here is the crime, not what he gains from it)
- ScottBurson 12y agoWow. You claim to know a lot about the case, but you don't even realize that JSTOR holds scientific papers, not court documents. Swartz had previously downloaded court documents from a service called PACER. An FBI investigation was opened, but closed with no charges being filed; he was not prosecuted for that.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> what if he was downloading credit cards instead? Or some sort of corporate secrets? What if he was raping women? Or committing genocide? > But the act here is the crime, not what he gains from it Downloading scientific journals is not the same "act" as committing credit card fraud. It is an outrageous defect in the law that it doesn't adequately distinguish them.
- nemo 12y ago> Essentially he was exploiting a vulnerability in JSTOR to mass download court documents He was downloading academic articles, not court documents. You're mixing up the JSTOR download and the time he pulled down PACER documents. He did have legitimate access to the JSTOR documents, but was bypassing rate limiting. In the process, he did do some things that were illegal, but nothing that honestly justified the Feds charging him with CFAA or wire fraud charges filed, nor anything that justified a felony conviction. What he was doing wasn't the sort of crime those laws were written to address and that they were intended to stop. The Feds. abused the ambiguities in poorly written laws to charge him.
- McDoku 12y agoMy issue is not the crime but the intention of the individual and whether or not his behaviour was fundamentally prosocial and/or in the national interest. We have constitutions and laws specifically to product/advance those interests. If that is the standard by which we judge actions, then it change how we should view the case. This debate has fueled technological literacy among the general population/legislative/judicial. Much like the fappening is doing for crypto/personal_security (Re: Android/Apple announcements). It further underlines the critical role that technology plays in our civil life.
- smsm42 12y agoThe choice between "100% OK" and 30 years in jail is a false dichotomy. Nobody says Aaron Swartz was a saint without any flaw, and one can easily find many ways in which in hindsight one could suggest better action, especially if one doesn't actually have to act on their own advice. But that he was a fallible human being is not the same as accepting the treatment he's got from the US government. He was trying to fix an injustice and he was not harming anyone. Prosecutors have enough power and discretion to accommodate that if they wanted. They didn't want.
- res0nat0r 12y ago30 years in jail is a false dichotomy and people need to quit parroting that in relation to this case, it was never ever in any way going to be close to that.
- smsm42 12y agoWell, 30 years maybe a bit exaggerated, but multiple years in jail were well on the agenda if Swartz would not take the plea agreement, as the facts of the case were against him and the jury probably would not (and would be instructed not to) relate to his motives and why he did it. Then it would come to the sentencing and as the feds were determined to make an example of him... it would be hard to expect much leniency, especially given the fact that Swartz probably didn't think what he did was wrong (even if how he did it may be against he law) so he would not get the "regret" leniency too. So maybe not 30 years, but multiple years still, which is very harsh and can ruin one's life. P.S. btw, please look up what "dichotomy" is. You can not have dichotomy of one thing, at least in the meaning of the word we're dealing with here.
- res0nat0r 12y agoHe was given 6 months and should have taken it. Many people who violate the law think what they did wasn't wrong, but this has no bearing in the matter when it comes to sentencing.
- 12y ago
- hluska 12y agoHave you actually read anything about this case? Some facts include: a) He was threatened with 35 years in prison for downloading journal articles from MIT. Both MIT and JStor (the wronged parties) were against this heavy handed prosecution. b) Aaron was not convicted because he chose to kill himself while the prosecution was ongoing. The prosecution wanted him to serve six months in a federal prison; Swartz refused this plea deal. Aaron killed himself shortly after the prosecution declined his offer. c) This style of prosecution (ie - go to court and risk 35 years in prison vs plead guilty and spend six months) goes against justice.
- jdong 12y agoAaron was a good friend of mine, I know quite a bit about this case. a) No he wasn't, this is a common misconception by people who don't understand how the US court system works. b) Aaron had a good deal, the indisputable breaking-and-entering charge would probably have gotten him more than 6 months. (Clarification: Aarons state charges were dropped to make way for the more serious federal charges, so in the end he didn't even get charged for the breaking-and-entering.) c) Again, read up on the US court system. You're disrespecting his memory by using him as a weapon for your misguided crusade. Here's a good article written by Orin Kerr regarding Aarons charges http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/14/aaron-swartz-charges/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/14/aaron-swartz-charges/
- mindslight 12y agoa) Even if we want to bicker about the exact time, can we agree that he was facing a possible 5 years? That's ten times longer than what the prosecutors thought an appropriate punishment (the 6 month offered plea). b) Not for a college-class first time offender into an unlocked network closet, especially given the institution. That would have been handled at the local level, and would have most likely ended up in probation. c) Yes, this case was business as usual for the US "justice" system. That doesn't make it right. If Aaron was a good friend of yours, then you probably do have some different insight. Please share it here instead of repeating the same tired he-got-what-he-deserved FUD.
- scarmig 12y agoThe law was going to give him prison time and mark him as a felon for life for the crime of downloading academic papers with the intent of making them available to the public. It continued to pursue this even after JSTOR had asked the attorneys to back down, hounding him incessantly even after informed that he was psychologically ill.
- jdong 12y agoYou're ignoring the other charges he had, the prosecution offered him an AMAZING deal. You can't just not prosecute people because they're depressed.
- vdaniuk 12y agoWow, I am extremely surprised to see such attitude from a friend of Aaron. Amazing deal? Really? Do you think that serving 6 months or more for his "crimes" is justice?
- jdong 12y agoYou probably mean 6 months or less, because that was the prosecution offer. And yeah, I think that was actually a pretty good deal. Although I would agree that in a perfect world the material he took would already have been public.
- shiven 12y agoI think you are grossly underplaying the consequences of that plea deal. Six months (or less) in federal prison would still have him labeled as a "convict" and he would have lost numerous civil rights (voting being one) as a result. Needless to say, he would have to carry that label for the rest of his days as a US citizen. From what I understand, Aaron did not want to carry that cross, more so since he considered himself innocent. Hence, in protest, he took his own life. I am neither condoning nor criticizing his action and his final decision, as I am in no position to do that. However, I strongly doubt it was as simple or straightforward as you'd like it to appear. If you are a friend of Aaron's and you have come out publicly (on HN) as one, perhaps you could explain the reasoning and motivations better than most of us. Why not do that, instead of oversimplifying the whole situation?
- nemo 12y agoThere are some serious problems with the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, which was seriously abused in this case. Members of Congress have recognized this and tried to reform the law because of the abuse.
- drivers99 12y agoYour question made me want to find out more for myself. I ended watching The Internet's Own Boy[1]. I'm glad I did and I recommend it for anyone who hasn't seen it yet. It will answer your question of why people care. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXr-2hwTk58 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXr-2hwTk58
- ScottBurson 12y agoIt's famous for several reasons, which you are surely aware of. The most obvious is that the suicide of a well-known, brilliant, and promising young activist gets people's attention. It's natural for people to mourn, to some extent, and to wonder what he could have done with the rest of his life had he not ended it. It is a very sad thing. Also, it brought to a lot of people's attention, including mine, some of the problems with both the CFAA specifically and with the way that federal prosecutors routinely abuse their discretion generally. Orin Kerr discusses both of these points in the second part of the piece you linked to [0]. I'll quote one passage: On the third question, the issue of who was to blame if the prosecution was too severe, I think it’s important to realize that what happened in the Swartz case happens it lots and lots of federal criminal cases. Yes, the prosecutors tried to force a plea deal by scaring the defendant with arguments that he would be locked away for a long time if he was convicted at trial. Yes, the prosecutors filed a superseding indictment designed to scare Swartz evem more in to pleading guilty (it actually had no effect on the likely sentence, but it’s a powerful scare tactic). Yes, the prosecutors insisted on jail time and a felony conviction as part of a plea. But it is not particularly surprising for federal prosecutors to use those tactics. What’s unusual about the Swartz case is that it involved a highly charismatic defendant with very powerful friends in a position to object to these common practices. That’s not to excuse what happened, but rather to direct the energy that is angry about what happened. If you want to end these tactics, don’t just complain about the Swartz case. Don’t just complain when the defendant happens to be a brilliant guy who went to Stanford and hangs out with Larry Lessig. Instead, complain that this is business as usual in federal criminal cases around the country — mostly with defendants who no one has ever heard of and who get locked up for years without anyone else much caring. I agree wholeheartedly. But for many of us, it was the Swartz case that brought this issue to our attention in a big way. I think it is natural for us to associate the issue with Swartz even if we agree with Kerr that the problem is hardly confined to this one instance. As for the CFAA itself, Kerr argues, and I again agree, that the provision triggering felony liability is much too broad. Had the statute been reformed as Kerr suggests, Swartz might not have been looking at a felony charge. I agree that Swartz should have faced some punishment, even if just a misdemeanor conviction and probation. It's really the looming felony conviction that Swartz was unable to swallow, and I am too. It highlights how the federal criminal law has grown into a monster. If you want another case that shows the same thing and should also be famous, the George Norris felony orchid smuggling case [1] would be a great choice. [0] http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aaron-swartz-part-2-prosecutorial-discretion/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-agains... [1] http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2009/07/the-unlikely-orchid-smuggler-a-case-study-in-overcriminalization http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2009/07/the-unlikel...
- manifesto 12y agoA reminder: the petition https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/remove-united-states-district-attorney-carmen-ortiz-office-overreach-case-aaron-swartz/RQNrG1Ck https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/remove-united-stat... has not been responded yet, after more than one and a half years.
- joering2 12y agoWhy are you reminding about this? Isn't it obvious, 6 years later, that entire Obama Administration is a charade?? Why would it be any different when it comes to petitions.whitehouse? Don't mind the case of obvious abuse of power and long arm of the gov that destroyed the life of a young and basically innocent man.... here look at this one, nice and thoroughly answered: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/release-recipe-honey-ale-home-brewed-white-house/XkpkYwc0 https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/release-recipe-hon...
- ivanca 12y agoI'm afraid you are right. "After 911 we tortured some folks but lets not be sanctimonious about the tough job the tortures had" is by far the worst thing any president (or dictator) has ever say in a public speech.
- idlewords 12y agoBetter start a petition to fix that!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- neverminder 12y agoIndeed, I remember signing this back then. White House seems to be dodging responses to certain petitions that have received enough signatures: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/08/13/here-are-the-30-questions-the-white-house-doesnt-want-to-answer/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-switch/wp/2013/08/13...
- herge 12y agoWait, were the case files for Aaron Swartz classified or just never made public? What would be the reasoning for classifying his case? How was he a threat to national security?
- GabrielF00 12y agoI think classified is the wrong word. These are investigative documents released after a FOIA request, but I don't see any indication that they were ever classified.
- nhstanley 12y agoYea, unsealed or released would be better words (depending on the situation).
- pocketheyman 12y agoKind of interesting, according to the case file, the PACER records were being pulled en masse during normal court hours (typically when courts are also accessing the PACER database). A user noticed that PACER was going slow and notified PACER of the apparent slowness. Looks like they investigated, shut the PACER system down and were able to detect the requests were coming from an Amazon Web Hosting account linked to Swartz. I find this interesting because it wasn't some flag on the PACER system screaming "HEY SOMEONE IS DOWNLOADING THESE EVERY TWO SECONDS" but instead was noticed because some law clerk was irritated at how slow the server was at responding.
- meowface 12y agoThis is similar to how many breaches and DDoS attacks are discovered. Lots of companies have absolutely no controls to detect the most basic of flooding or spidering behavior.
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoFirst off: Totally true. Secondly: Devil's advocate, but it is a "hard problem." It is easy to look for behaviour on the system, it is very hard to look for patterns of behaviour. I mean let's say that some of your users are normal court clerks, it wouldn't be unusual to see them sit around and pull tons of records all day every day. So how do you pick up normal requests on-mass and unusual requests on-mass? If I was in charge of protecting such a system I wouldn't even attempt to detect this (too hard). Instead what I would do is make it impossible to get records sequentially (e.g. 1, 2, 3...9999999) instead each record had a unique randomly generated token associated with it (a UUID/GUID). So in order for someone to gain every single record they would either need to conduct a "real" break in and steal the files, or search for every possible criteria (which, for them, becomes a huge hassle/problem). PS - Most DDoS are, these days, against layer 3 (network). Since it is far harder to defeat a layer 3 attack (as it can literally crash a lot of network hardware). While layer 7 (software) DDoS attacks still exist, they're often conducted by less formidable adversaries and they're much easier to stop (e.g. return a JavaScript redirect instead of the normal page, most browser-users won't notice, but it will defeat a targeted attack until they re-target (and you could rename it every 10 minutes)).
- vajorie 12y agoHow come no one even bothered to remove his full address and ssn from the records?.. On the other hand, even the very names of people who approved and drafted the documents are removed.
- adestefan 12y agoAfter someone dies these are no longer protected.
- saalweachter 12y agoRelated question: Do the deceased have any (legal notion of a) right to privacy?
- gnaritas 12y agoWhy would they? Privacy means nothing to the non-existent.
- saalweachter 12y agoIf it pleases living people to think that they will have a right to privacy after they die, or to force other people to not pry into their dead relatives secrets, living people could easily craft a right to privacy for the deceased.
- gnaritas 12y agoSure they could, but those are rights for the living relatives; the dead don't exist to have rights.
- ajkjk 12y agoThat's your opinion and doesn't answer the question at all. At least for health records, you do have privacy after you die, apparently for 50 years: http://www.hhs.gov/ocr/privacy/hipaa/understanding/coveredentities/decedents.html http://www.hhs.gov/ocr/privacy/hipaa/understanding/covereden...
- nutate 12y agoWas there ever an argument beyond 'information wants to be free' to this? Let's say PACER docs were being pulled and hosted elsewhere. What if case information was updated as per part of the legal process, aka person X is now innocent. How does this change to past case documents get propagated to the 'illegal' mirror? This is interesting because I think we do want an authoritative document store and that, yes, we hence need to pay for its upkeep. So if he had mirrored and hosted all of these cases, they would've been merely snapshots of past history, not the curated corpus that PACER has. The same could be said of scientific papers where large retractions are handled by the journals, but may be lost by some mirrors. Information quality, provenance and current validity is more important than the trope of 'wanting to be free.' Once information passes into the 'historical' realm, perhaps it should/must be free, but when we are in the malleable phase it's irresponsible to 'mirror once' without knowing how to get pushed (or pull) updates. Look at how the Linux kernel mirror system works, push mirroring, etc. The scrape method doesn't pass the smell test if you really want to provide a service beyond point in time archiving (aka archive.org). Regarding depression, suicide and unfair persecution I'll withhold comment.
- pmorici 12y agoI've been following a legal case using pacer for the past year and if you something is added or updated on a case an email notice gets sent out to the people who have registered as interested parties with a link to the document and you get one free download. A pretty simple way to bridge pacer to a system that doesn't suck would be to register some kind of bot to get the email notices from each case and download and file each document as it becomes available.
- hackuser 12y ago> Was there ever an argument beyond 'information wants to be free' to this? I can think of four: 1) The information is vital to government and to justice, both personally (if you are party to or have a stake in the case) and as a public affairs issue; its availability should not be restricted in any way, and especially not restricted to those who can afford to pay. 2) In principle, access to the courts should not discriminate based on any factor, especially wealth. 3) The information is a product of taxpayer-funded activities and therefore should be public and free. 4) 8 cents/page for downloaded data is ridiculous; what if HN charged us 8 cents/page? Does anyone know what Swartz' actual arguments were?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 12y agoOn PACER fees, IMO a good compromise is to only charge for the actual court documents retrieved. No charging for search results, docket listings etc, and there is already a $3 cap on documents.
- discardorama 12y agoThere should be no charge at all for access and retrieval. These court documents affect our lives; they are the law of the land. Some will say: but it costs money to provide this access!!1!! To them: it costs money for police & fire too. Where does that come from? That's right: taxes. So taxes should pay for the upkeep of PACER too.
- RickHull 12y agoFrankly there are plenty of private organizations desperate to take over Internet distribution of these documents, at no charge to anyone. If PACER can't match or compete with this, then they should step aside as far as distribution goes. Lead, follow, or get out of the way.