6 ms·
Instead of just trying to remove themselves from the process for legal reasons, surely they're at the size where they could entertain providing project managers
by prawn 12y ago
Instead of just trying to remove themselves from the process for legal reasons, surely they're at the size where they could entertain providing project managers to help coach entrepreneurs through their venture? It's not like YC steps back and abandons each batch to see who survive, they coach them through to maximise success.
If a Kickstarted project is tackling manufacturing of a physical product for the first time, they risk making the same mistakes as others before them. YC in a case like that would put entrepreneurs in touch with advisers or others who've gone before them who learnt from their experience.
Or is this something they already do? Kickstarter hasn't been opened up to Australian projects until recently, so I'm not sure.
- delecti 12y agoAs far as I've heard, projects have the option to receive coaching/review of their campaign before it goes live. Essentially you can click a box that says "don't worry, I've got this", and just go live with what you've got, or you can opt to receive coaching similar to what you've described. In that case, someone from Kickstarter will review your campaign, and offer suggestions to get the best results. I don't believe there's any post-campaign coaching though, and in that regard you're right that it might be in their best interest to do so.
- subdane 12y agoKS currently is just a platform to match backers to projects - more like Ebay than YC. But, you're onto something here. Maybe they start a guidebook? Or a certification program? Or a community (like HN)? Or a school?
- janetic 12y agoKickstarter does a quick review of projects to make sure they meet their project guidelines/rules, and provides a Creator Handbook, but is otherwise pretty hands-off. I think from Kickstarter’s perspective, it doesn’t make a ton of sense to move into what would effectively be the management consulting space with projects - it would represent a huge expense on their end for no real reward (YC operates by investing in their companies and then giving them various tools to succeed; Kickstarter is a platform with no investment in whether or not projects are ultimately successful). Obviously they have some interest in projects being successful to maintain the credibility of the platform, but that seems to have largely self-regulated (a few bad apples get lots of press, but a foray into the unsuccessful projects reveals the power of group vetting). IMO, expanding post-campaign creator support is something that would greatly enhance the ‘Kickstarter community,’ and somewhere they currently fall down, especially for tech and gaming projects that tend to be some of their highest earners, and also most susceptible to problems in delivery. That sort of service might find a home at Indiegogo, which is far more company/startup-friendly. The new guidelines are definitely a step in the right direction, and represent a clearer understanding on the part of KS with regard to what’s possible for creators who truly try, and simply fail. Shifting the focus to reparative measures like providing expense breakdowns, alternate plans, explanations, etc. seems more inline with the idea(l) that creators and backers are all part of the project, sharing in the risk and reward.