4 ms·
I wonder how much is this causation vs selection. If someone is willing to pass an extreme rite of passage (like trial by fire) to be accepted, isn't (s)he alr
by nine_k 12y ago
I wonder how much is this causation vs selection.
If someone is willing to pass an extreme rite of passage (like trial by fire) to be accepted, isn't (s)he already primed to form a stronger social bond, compared to someone who would only be willing to pass through a simple, non-straining ritual (like hand-shaking)? I suspect that most of the "hand-shaking" crowd would simply shun an extreme ritual, instead of being transformed by it.
- andrewstuart2 12y agoI'd put my money on a bit of both, but I'd put more of that money on the causation side. As a thought experiment, imagine going through situations where you had no choice with somebody who becomes the only person you can count on. Not only can you expect to be able to count on that person in the future, but you have an exclusively shared experience. Both of those happen regardless of whether either of you had a choice.
- maxxxxx 12y agoIn boxing or other martial arts there is this phenomenon that you often like or respect your opponent after a fight. And that despite trying to knock him out. You certainly weren't planning on creating a social bond. I think there something that makes going through difficulties together a bonding experience.
- Havoc 12y ago>If someone is willing to pass an extreme rite of passage From experience I can tell you that these things tend to sneak up on you. You don't sign up for one unit of "extreme rite of passage"...it just kinda happens. Just roll with the punches - absorb, learn, adapt...you'll emerge 10x stronger. I certainly did.
- RangerScience 12y agoYou can aim for them, definitely. Mostly by aiming higher than you can reach.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoBonding happens even when the trial by fire is unexpected and unwanted. All you need is to survive it. :)