4 ms·
You act as if the 20th century never existed. Your description why unions don't work is in fact the explanation why unions organize workers across different em
by xorcist 12y ago
You act as if the 20th century never existed.
Your description why unions don't work is in fact the explanation why unions organize workers across different employers.
Your description why cheap labor will skip out on the unions is in fact the explanations why unions make economic sense for its members. You earn more in them than out of them.
Organized labor creates a level playing field across markets, simply because they have a shared interest with the unionized companies that they thrive and provide work for its members. It is a natural part of a healthy free market.
I don't think the problem described in the article is particularly unique or interesting. We've seen it before and we know the solution. What is new is that workers are called contractors and not workers, but the markets dynamics is largely the same.
- tptacek 12y agoOT: He writes as if the 20th century never happened. We have no idea how he acts. The distinction is important for civil debate. Among other things: we may be miscontruing, or he may be expressing his idea imprecisely.
- xorcist 12y agoI think it should be fairly clear from the context that it is the act of self expression that is alluded to, in this particular case the act of writing. It is similar to the use of the word act in "you act surprised". This is something you can say, even in writing, and people will generally understand what is meant. What is important for a civil debate is not to pick on words, but to try to understand one another. If someone you are responding to writes something that can be understood in several ways, choose the one that is more flattering to their side of the argument.
- tptacek 12y agoSure. The last sentence you wrote is a restatement of the principle of charity, which is something HN is supposed to embrace but manifestly does not.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Your description why unions don't work is in fact the explanation why unions organize workers across different employers. That doesn't work when the employer's market has low entry barriers and the employees have low skills. As soon as you unionize all the existing employers you get a new employer hiring non-union employees and putting all the union employers out of business by charging lower prices. > Your description why cheap labor will skip out on the unions is in fact the explanations why unions make economic sense for its members. You earn more in them than out of them. It's not the union employees who go to work for the non-union employers. It's the unemployed. Until the non-union employers charging lower prices cause the union employers to lay off workers or go out of business, at which point the previously union employees become the unemployed and go work for the non-union employer since they can no longer work for the union employer. > Organized labor creates a level playing field across markets, simply because they have a shared interest with the unionized companies that they thrive and provide work for its members. It is a natural part of a healthy free market. Organized labor is an attempt to create a cartel of workers to balance a cartel of employers. The problem is it turns into a mess unless the balance is even and there is nothing to ensure that it is.