4 ms·
> If large companies have to provide various insurance and benefits... > The fundamental cause is that this is what capitalism does in markets... I'd argue th
by humanrebar 12y ago
> If large companies have to provide various insurance and benefits...
> The fundamental cause is that this is what capitalism does in markets...
I'd argue that the current employer-provided insurance scheme in the U.S. is not an inevitability of capitalism but a historical accident resulting in nonsense-but-untouchable tax code. Health insurance should be taxed as income or should be deductible on personal income taxes. Employers-provided healthcare shouldn't be discounted.
> the supply of labor outstrips demand
This is a good point, though. And if the surplus of unskilled labor is a problem, why hasn't relaxed immigration enforcement come up in this discussion yet? If labor doesn't have enough leverage, wouldn't flooding the market with unskilled laborers be a much more important factor than employment status and business models?
- araes 12y agoIMO, immigration has very little to do with the problem, and is more of a political whip. We as a country are simply eroding our own need for (or at least focus on) unskilled labor. In fact, we're eroding "almost" all of our labor, unskilled, skilled, artistic, etc... Engineers, software devs/coders, and machinists are some of the only ones that have really escaped the purge, and even they're being eaten by foreign labor and technology. By its nature, entrepreneurs who want to make money try to find areas of the market where there is a cost/supply, productivity, or other form of inefficiency, and then fix it. And they're doing a good job. Whole ranges of American labor have been automated, crowd-sourced, or offshored right out of existence in the US (and world). See this chart by the MIT Tech Review that talks about it. [1] In particular, note the effect of changes in the service industries, such as Uber, which already make up a ridiculously large portion of our economy. Purely speculation, but I'm generally on the side of folks that think "first world problems" is very shortly going to represent having tons of productivity and no actual jobs. [1] http://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/destroying.jobs_.chart1x910_0.jpg http://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/d...
- humanrebar 12y agoI just said that, especially in an immigrant-heavy industry like driving, it's odd that the subject isn't even broached. I'm actually pro-immigration, but I do think wages and working conditions for native-born Americans would be better if large swaths of the economy weren't dominated by imported labor. It just seems like we're trying to have our cake and eat it to with respect to open borders and labor. I do suspect that longer-term trends point to less demand for "unskilled" labor, but I believe that people have an unquenchable appetite for new things (artisanal carbon-neutral Bolivian gherkins) that can't be easily invented, sold, and managed by computers, even if certain tasks are performed entirely or partially be robots.
- abakker 12y ago>Health insurance should be taxed as income or should be deductible on personal income taxes. What about other startup benefits? Laundry, parking,air hockey tables, free food etc? Isn't the whole point of these benefits to increase effective salaries without increasing taxable wages? I've heard talk of looking at total employee compensation from an HR perspective, but the government doesn't see those as earnings.
- bmm6o 12y agoBenefits like those would be very difficult to tax in a practical way, and would definitely have undesired consequences. The better your work environment the more the company withholds from your check? No thanks. Health insurance is entirely different, as it's fundamentally monetary in nature (in the form of premiums and underwriting other expenses). Not only should it be treated as (or more like) income, but having it funded so much by employers mean that a lot of people don't even know what they are paying for health care. It keeps them uninformed, which is yet another way it's not a "free market".
- abakker 12y agoThey wouldn't be very difficult to tax, you could easily tax them by looking at how much they cost to provide, divided by the number of employees receiving them. Services all have a price tag. Health Care, like most services, is something we pay for. I agree that it would be better if it were less byzantine and it would be much more practical if healthcare were in priced independent of employment status. As it stands though, practically it is quite similar to any other benefit, except that sometimes, the cost is split between the employer and the employee. If you applied this logic to free startup food, it would be akin to allowing you to opt-in to the free food if you wanted it, with the company covering some percentage of the cost. _ Its not a practical matter of whether or not we want to be taxed more, its how much we value the society our government enables and how much more we want to enable it. Our government could use a great deal of work to become more efficient, but that is not to say that the projects facing it don't also have a nearly infinite price tag (things could always be better)