4 ms·
How is Uber considered "sharing economy"? If the term is to have any meaning, then it refers to people having spare capacity in an asset and allowing others to
by graeme 12y ago
How is Uber considered "sharing economy"? If the term is to have any meaning, then it refers to people having spare capacity in an asset and allowing others to use it.
Airbnb: Have a room in your home or can leave your home, and allow others to rent it.
Taskrabbit: Have extra time you can sell
Say what you want about the ethics of either company, but users are free to negotiate prices.
A "sharing economy" car company would monetize spare capacity in cars and allows drivers/passengers post rates.
But that would be complicated. So Uber has adopted a fixed rate model. Whatever it's virtues, it's not sharing. It's just service for hire at a fixed rate.
- dwg 12y agoI agree. If you're doing Uber full-time it's not sharing at all. It's just business.
- zo1 12y agoNot even a business. From the sounds of it in the article, it seems that these drivers think that they are employees. They even "bought and rented cars in order to..." do this activity. Well, the examples cited anyways, not all of them. I can totally see why people are giving Uber and Lyft a bad rap now. Because the drivers are treating it like a job. And no wonder that they're now using employee-like terms such as "minimum wage" and "living wage". Not to mention that so many people are probably desperate for an easy (to get and to hold) job like this that they've flooded the market. No wonder that Uber/Lyft is able to command their prices.
- rmc 12y agoThere are pleanty of people using a property fulltime for AirBnB.
- dwg 12y agoAgree, but there's a difference between renting out an investment property full-time, renting out a spare room, and renting your place while away vacation. The later two are what I define as "sharing economy", while the former is more of a business transaction. AirBnB and Uber facilitate both sharing and business type transactions, but the article seems to mixing these up to me in terms of the problem being expressed.
- serve_yay 12y agoI don't like the phrase either, for this reason.
- alexqgb 12y agoOutside of split ownership, the word "sharing" becomes a bit of a misnomer. What Airbnb or Uber does is not sharing in any generally accepted sense of the term. That is to say, these are not co-ops in which the owners and the users are one and the same. Rather, they are creating a market for very short-term sublets. There is precisely zero sharing involved. And that's just fine. In terms of producing greater efficiencies from a fixed stock of privately held material resources, this approach can be a very good thing. However, you have to be careful when dealing with people who are too nervous or deluded to be honest about what they're actually doing, and who opt for a thick slathering of bullshit instead. It would be wise to ditch the dishonesty a.s.a.p. Sticking with it runs the risk of being disrupted by organizations that can deal with regulation more effectively thanks to greater comfort with general transparency and basic integrity.