18 ms·
Against Sharing
- ameister14 12y agoI spoke with my UberX driver about unionization the other day; it's honestly the only way forward for the drivers. Without unionizing, the prices will continue to be cut and they will continue to lose out. Going even further, lots of people are talking about the job creation boom associated with the sharing economy. However, in the case of Uber and Lyft, that's short term. In 10-15 years, does anyone actually think people will be driving cars for Uber in San Francisco? With the way things are going, auto-driving cars will take their place. Unions could lobby the state legislature to make for auto-driving cab or ride services illegal without a driver in the car. Right now, they could make a serious case for that as a safety thing, since the technology is unproven. In 5-10 years, that won't be the case. So yes, from the driver perspective, they have to unionize. If they don't they're finished sooner or later.
- vdaniuk 12y agoIn cases like this, unions would be creating negative externalities for the society, while supporting outdated technology. It is not sustainable, the cause is lost. The best way forward would be reeducation and training of professional drivers. One way to fund it would be recognizing the imminent future and creating a special tax on Uber-like businesses to channel funds toward driver training programs.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ebiester 12y agoSo, what are they going to do? We're automating faster than we can create new jobs. In the long run, we'll figure something out. In the long run, however, we'll all be dead.
- jwr 12y agoIn the long term, I would rather start thinking about whether we really want to keep driver-type jobs around. I think people have to start to accept that certain types of mindless jobs will be gone sooner or later, and that (as hard as it might seem) everyone needs to educate themselves and work towards jobs that cannot be automated.
- smacktoward 12y agoThis is the sort of thing you generally hear from people who assume their job is not among those that can be automated. Many of those people are going to be unpleasantly surprised.
- vdaniuk 12y agoAnd that changes exactly what? Yes, most people whose jobs will be automated think they are safe. However, it is very likely that automation of jobs is a Nash equilibrium outcome and fighting against it without global consensus is useless. We should channel our efforts to other ventures that would provide food, housing and health security for those losing their jobs due to automation.
- Ygg2 12y agoThat was grandparent's point. As long as software keeps automating tasks, there are very few jobs that are safe and most of them are in developing or maintaining software that automates the jobs. Software can automate a really huge swath of jobs. From research (performing experiments) to art to physical checkup, it's a list that keeps growing. While I essentially agree that such programs should lead to extremely high taxes followed by redistribution of tax money to people, right now it's not the model most western countries are moving towards.
- ewzimm 12y agoOn the contrary, I think anyone who is thinking seriously about automation acknowledges that their job is on the list, especially for a lot of software work like debugging, updating libraries, refactoring code, etc. There's nothing wrong with that. Automation means more free time to do things people actually enjoy, but only if we properly distribute the benefits. The challenge is not to prevent automation of any kind of work but rather to ensure that people are fairly compensated for that automation and all the benefits don't go to the people at the top.
- tolmasky 12y agoThat sounds pretty ethically terrifying. Car related death and injury is something we put up with today because it is a "necessity" for the way we run our society. With the advent of driverless cars, politically keeping humans in the driving seat will mean keeping around these unneeded deaths solely for the sake of a special interest group. Even if they aren't driving but merely sitting there (when the argument is purely job based and not safety based), the result would be that the cost of running a driverless car will be similar to a car with a driver, thus making the transition less economically obvious and slower, in turn slowing down the reduction of accidents.
- zanny 12y agoAnd it is a near-infinite performance multiplier. Every driverless car is very useful work being done without anyone having to do work, besides maintain the thing. And Tesla is leading the way with repair facilities that are almost completely automated themselves, and when you have autonomous vehicles capable of driving around other defective goods to automated factories for repair, it becomes even more profound. Every worker replaced by a robot is tremendous productivity gains for the economy. Or, moreso, for their boss. The sooner we accept that many people will soon be unemployable, and that is a good thing, the sooner we can move on with our society and not need to try forming unions to prevent progress out of fear of jobs that have no reason to exist and thus are a drain on everything.
- zzzeek 12y agoyou have to solve the "unemployable people" problem first, before you take away unions. Unions at the very least serve to slow the process of worker replacement so that technological changes don't thrust large masses at once into instant poverty, which has its own negative effects on the economy.
- darkmighty 12y agoI don't think giving people useless jobs is superior to letting more efficient tech replace them. Instead of just wasting a potential efficiency gain, the government could use a part of the gains to either give the resources to workers directly or spend on training and education. Anyway, there are plently of useful things you could do with workers besides just wasting the efficiency gain.
- waylandsmithers 12y ago> Going even further, lots of people are talking about the job creation boom associated with the sharing economy. Is there any evidence of this? My assumption was that people are using Uber in situations where they otherwise would have called a regular taxi.
- mateo411 12y agoI think the demand for taxi services has gone up since Uber entered the marketplace. Uber made it easier to call a cab and see when the cab would show up. Since the product was easier and better, more people wanted to use it. I don't have any hard data to support my claim. I can provide some anecdata about waiting for a Yellow Cab in SF in the mid 2000s. Sometimes they would arrive and other times they wouldn't.
- tehabe 12y agoI actually think, that auto-driving cabs would be bad for Uber's business model. There model is to shift all risks and hard assets (car) to contractors. With auto-driven cab the contractors could run a lot of cars or even for several companies or Uber had to run them on their own. With the necessity to carry the risks and all the costs. But I agree, without a union the drivers won't get anything done. I think also the state should see those drivers as what they are, Uber employees. It shouldn't matter what Uber calls them. If someone works full time for one company they are employees of that company.
- golemotron 12y agoI just want to know who owns the cars. To me, it is beyond belief that each of the Uber and Lyft drivers I've had ponied up and bought a fresh new car to participate in "sharing." There's more polish on an Uber vehicle than any car or cab in my neighborhood. It seems odd to use the word "sharing" for something that seems like ultra professional service - even on the low UberX end. Is Uber offering financing?
- vdaniuk 12y agoI have an intuitive understanding that these "socialist" publications about the danger and perils of sharing economy are absolutely useless. Either developed countries implement some variation of basic income or the social order will go down in flames. Unskilled labour, such as taxi drivers, will be commoditized and become interchangable. If anti-Uber initiatives and quasi-unions will get more power it will only increase the incentives to getting self-controlled cars on the roads. The automation-worker conflict can't be won by humans and can't be wished away. Socialists (an outdated term for the society to come) should choose their battles much more wisely and concentrate efforts on developing and implementing of sustainable models of creating and redistributing wealth geared towards 90% of population. Anti-Uber sentiment and the likes aren't sustainable and will fail.
- Zigurd 12y ago> Either developed countries implement some variation of basic income or the social order will go down in flames. And they better start soon. Unless there is a path to obtaining material comfort outside of a free-market economy, the only people with comfortable lives will be those who start their lives with capital, those who win the genetic lottery, and those who have a strong guild-like organization putting a thumb on the scales on their behalf. This will become evident in Europe when QE-like measures fail to do anything about unemployment. > Anti-Uber sentiment and the likes aren't sustainable and will fail. Obviously. Uber will evolve into a marketplace for renting out privately owned self-driving vehicles. The humans are not needed.
- vdaniuk 12y ago>And they better start soon. Unless there is a path to obtaining material comfort outside of a free-market economy, the only people with comfortable lives will be those who start their lives with capital, those who win the genetic lottery, and those who have a strong guild-like organization putting a thumb on the scales on their behalf. Absoltely. However, developing countries will be hit sooner and much harder. Factories and large industries will be brought back to developed countries and automated with extreme efficiency. China, India, Southeast Asia, any country where economies are reliant on cheap labour and export of manufuctured goods to developed countries will be ravaged with rapid increase of unemployment. Governments are clueless, social safety nets are nearly absent, educational facilities are subpar. There is currently very little that can be done by individual countries to even mitigate the fallout, forget about fixing it. The storm is coming. Only really cheap energy and resources can literally save the world. That's why I am hopeful for asteroid mining and nuclear/fusion energy. However, the fair distribution of the newly created wealth is extremely important too. But humanity as a collective is really bad at that.
- tptacek 12y agoAt some point in the next 10-15 years, there's going to be some kind of reckoning over the "sourcing and allocating independent contractors" model of business. Right now, companies can insulate themselves from labor laws almost entirely by (a) not providing employees with equipment and (b) using structured customer feedback and expectations in lieu of training and supervision. There are instances where this model can be fair to all parties, but there are also obviously instances where it's abusive. My intuition, which is probably wrong, is that the model fails most straightforwardly when there are monopsonies playing the "source and allocate" role. The trouble is that many of these companies work on a "winner take all" go-to-market plan, which almost dictates that they end up controlling the market. There have already been low-grade rumblings over this in the past. For instance, the Microsoft "Permatemp" scandal. But we can see the model taking hold across the economy --- see: drivers, housecleaning. My guess is that the long-term resolution for this is going to be legislative, and it's not going to make companies like Uber happy.
- jacquesm 12y agoJustEat and their companions are a nice example of that. Essentially these are all simply lead generators with a feedback loop that have found a way to insert themselves directly into the billing process so merchants / suppliers become dependent on them. They can be a very hard habit to kick. For instance, in NL we have 'thuisbezorgd' which started out very reasonable and is now positively extorting the restaurants they book their deliveries with.
- tptacek 12y agoIn labor sourcing and allocation markets and under US law, these companies are essentially gaming the employment classification test: they're doing everything they can to appear to customers like a simple, monolithic, one-stop-shop (often with amusing disclaimers buried somewhere in their fine print) while adhering to the letter of the FLSA's classification scheme. It probably won't take that many more items in FLSA's classification list to fix the situation.
- 12y ago
- eykanal 12y agoThe article argues pretty strongly that Uber is a horrible company, which isn't really news to anyone. I'm missing, though, the leap from that argument to the idea that (quoting the article tagline) "Sharing economy companies like Uber shift risk from corporations to workers, weaken labor protections, and drive down wages." There are numerous other examples (Lyft, TaskRabbit, JobRunners, even Amazon's Mechanical Turk) where this model seems to work pretty well.
- pessimizer 12y ago>There are numerous other examples (Lyft, TaskRabbit, JobRunners, even Amazon's Mechanical Turk) where this model seems to work pretty well. ...by shifting risk from corporations to workers, weakening labor protections, and driving down wages. This article isn't about how to maximize profit, it's about how profit is being maximized.
- crazypyro 12y agoThe problem is when one technology company that uses this model reaches critical mass stage, they create a chicken-and-egg problem for anyone that wants to attempt to disrupt their market. You can't get contractors without clients and if you don't have contractors, clients won't want to wait. The problem has been getting worse with the rise of the internet and global connectivity as these companies can more easily expand into an entire industry and quickly dominate the technology side. This domination of the tech side of old industries makes it especially hard for tech companies that want to disrupt the "old" companies because the market often assumes there is only room for one technological provider/disruptor per market service. This is similar to the first to market principle. If you get your service out there and generating new users before your competitor, you have an innate advantage over all the competition AND a great advantage over future companies using a similar model to yours. In the process of shutting out new, small tech companies, the competition is narrowed down to the "old" companies/interests in which the tech company has a clear new, tech-inspired advantage over, else why would they be called a disrupting tech startup? So you have situations where 1 tech company, slowly morphing into a giant, effectively shuts out both the entrenched interests who cannot adapt fast enough to stem the hemorrhage of customers and the new interests who can't compete on either price or availability without a long ramp up and generally necessary venture capital. This creates a situation in which the contractors are taken advantage of, due to the lack of competition and complete monopoly that is slowly being acquired by the tech company.
- Retric 12y agoSeveral über drivers are also lyft drivers. Über is trying to prevent this by requiring drivers to accept a minimum percent of rides, but a company could get critical mass in a large city using 5% time from a large number of drivers. Growing from there would easily enable full time drivers. Which means über can only maintain a monopoly with thin margins which is generally considered ok.
- auggierose 12y agoSounds a lot like another sharing economy: prostitution.
- ef4 12y agoUber is not a monopoly and the barriers to entry are lower than people think. Now that the idea is proven, there's nothing stopping more competitors from building local app driven services to compete with them. If you can organize thousands of drivers, you shouldn't bother with a union. You should just have them collectively fund their own driver owned app and compete with uber instead of asking for crumbs.
- nateparrott 12y agoCreating a driver-owned replacement for Uber's service could certainly work to give drivers a better deal, but unionizing existing drivers is a better means to that end. Uber certainly adds value—they've got a good app, and it's great that I can land in a new city and know the same service will work the same way.
- rch 12y agoIf the drivers had an effective app, then they could provide an api for Uber, Lyft, or whatever brand to route rides into. The rate paid to the driver, possibly combined with convenience and other qualitative factors, would naturally determine placement. There would still be value in building a brand that customers recognize, but the overall system might be more sustainable.
- phkahler 12y ago>> Uber is not a monopoly and the barriers to entry are lower than people think. That is actually a large part of the problem. Competition from Lyft will force Uber to lower fares. Competition from a driver-union-app would force them to be even lower. At some point, lowering fares will directly hurt uber. Prior to that point, it's hurting the drivers because uber doesn't care at all about drivers costs, and drivers are either not good at taking that into account, or have been screwed by falling fares.
- kazagistar 12y agoPresumably, if prices are driven down enough by competition, then price vs quality differentiation. Cheaper prices vs better/nicer drivers.
- remoteone 12y agoThe original Jacobins were mostly libertarians and would presumably like Uber's model. The idea that they were anti-capitalists is wrong. In the US, "Jacobin" was used as a pejorative to describe Jefferson. It's unfortunate people associate the Jacobins and the Revolution with Robespierre, when it was much more Thomas Paine-esque.
- coldcode 12y agoI'm no marxist, but this is exactly what Karl Marx railed against: exploitation of the masses by capitalists. Of course a market economist sees this as an optimization of a market. If people suffer enough what usually happens is change, sometimes violent change.
- johnrob 12y agoPart of the blame needs to be on the drivers, who are likely bad at estimating the true cost of operating a vehicle. Uber could probably do better at making this clear, but it's not really in their interest. Long story short: traditional taxi pricing seems expensive but is actually pretty fair once you account for costs and a decent wage. Airbnb has given the sharing economy an inflated reputation, because they feed off a great business model: renting a scarce asset (land) with minimal marginal cost.
- jorde 12y agoIt's easy to put blame on the drivers who have no visibility to Uber's pricing and potential revenue. It hasn't been talked much in public but Uber is also providing financing for drivers.
- erroneousfunk 12y ago> traditional taxi pricing seems expensive but is actually pretty fair once you account for costs and a decent wage. This isn't true in some cities, such as Boston, where weird politics have driven the cost of a medallions, required to operate a taxi, up to ridiculous levels (The Boston Globe did an excellent article series on this http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/03/30/spotlight/9eVWW7Y6RaOIqII62n2XlI/story.html)Anyway http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/03/30/spotlight/9eVWW7..., there are a lot of factors that go into cab fares, and some of them genuinely are stupid and antiquated.
- graeme 12y agoHow is Uber considered "sharing economy"? If the term is to have any meaning, then it refers to people having spare capacity in an asset and allowing others to use it. Airbnb: Have a room in your home or can leave your home, and allow others to rent it. Taskrabbit: Have extra time you can sell Say what you want about the ethics of either company, but users are free to negotiate prices. A "sharing economy" car company would monetize spare capacity in cars and allows drivers/passengers post rates. But that would be complicated. So Uber has adopted a fixed rate model. Whatever it's virtues, it's not sharing. It's just service for hire at a fixed rate.
- dwg 12y agoI agree. If you're doing Uber full-time it's not sharing at all. It's just business.
- zo1 12y agoNot even a business. From the sounds of it in the article, it seems that these drivers think that they are employees. They even "bought and rented cars in order to..." do this activity. Well, the examples cited anyways, not all of them. I can totally see why people are giving Uber and Lyft a bad rap now. Because the drivers are treating it like a job. And no wonder that they're now using employee-like terms such as "minimum wage" and "living wage". Not to mention that so many people are probably desperate for an easy (to get and to hold) job like this that they've flooded the market. No wonder that Uber/Lyft is able to command their prices.
- rmc 12y agoThere are pleanty of people using a property fulltime for AirBnB.
- dwg 12y agoAgree, but there's a difference between renting out an investment property full-time, renting out a spare room, and renting your place while away vacation. The later two are what I define as "sharing economy", while the former is more of a business transaction. AirBnB and Uber facilitate both sharing and business type transactions, but the article seems to mixing these up to me in terms of the problem being expressed.
- herbig 12y agoA simple Google search and I was able to find the Facebook profile of the guy whose last name was not included "out of fear of retribution".
- driverdan 12y agoI would love to see a system like Uber or Lyft that used variable pricing and a bid system for drivers. Drivers could enter the minimum fare they're willing to work for and users could take it or leave it.
- dnautics 12y agoSidecar basically has this, but the biggest problem with sidecar: It has too many bells and whistles. Sometimes simpler is better. Moreover, you are simply shifting the pricewar to a finer granularity. I'm not sure what drivers are grumbling about. As a driver, I have to say, I knew what I was getting in to, and I have a plan to get out of it. I'm still ok, though, since I drive a very fuel-efficient car that seems to have had zero mechanical issues (cross fingers) in the 60,000 miles I have driven for the two services.
- dwg 12y agoThe subject of this article frames the argument incorrectly. Some drivers on Uber may have full-time jobs and are just driving for Uber to get a little extra in their spare time. Those people who treat Uber itself as a job, however, have little to do with the "sharing economy". IMO this is just another labor dispute, not really an issue with a sharing. On a side note, it's too bad a company so young and apparently game changing should be risking a labor dispute so early in its life.
- hywel 12y agoI think the root of the problem is that the drivers are contractors not employees, so have fewer rights. And that's at the heart of the idea behind the sharing economy, that independent individuals with a resource can offer that resource to the marketplace at ad hoc times. Whether or not the article is right is another matter, obviously.
- dwg 12y agoI guess I have a different view of "sharing economy". There are many other businesses which facilitate the connection of contractor to customer, but we don't call them part of the sharing economy. This is true even when they provide the tools (e.g. car) in addition to their services (e.g. driving). The fundamental difference for me comes down to whether they are providing this service as their primary means of livelihood (in which case it's a job), or are they simply looking to make better use of a resource (e.g. car) that they already own but do not fully utilize. Uber seems to be used for both "job" and "share," but the problems seem to be with the former.
- hywel 12y agoUber must have a lot of drivers if "Arman, an Uber driver in LA" isn't specific enough to be identified. It would be tragically ironic if this article resulted in his being 'deactivated'.
- Ryanmf 12y agoElsewhere in the comments someone claims to have found his Facebook profile, and perhaps they did. But as a counterpoint, my hometown of Glendale (Northeast LA-adjacent) has the largest population of Armenians anywhere in the Western Hemisphere. Lots of Armenians == Lots of guys named Armon/Armen/Arman. We can safely assume at least two of them drive for Uber.
- bbd 12y agoAccording to wiki: sharing economy is socio-economic system built around the sharing of human and physical resources. For ridesharing industry, the resources are drivers and their personal resources. Uber/Lyft/... are intent to become the gateway or dispatch or distribution layer to some extent. They are competing to "own" these resources and become monopoly. But for the drivers and the customers, it will always be in their interest to keep it a more "perfect competition" situation. Some third party shall come in to facilitate the conflict of interest -- maybe government, union or others.
- mahyarm 12y agoThe biggest unmentioned thing I'm noticing, is when are these car hailing apps going to start competing in how much of a cut they take? The marginal cost of their software is near %0. When will amazon-uber come up and say to uber: "Your [20% profit] margin is my opportunity".
- saryant 12y agoRockefeller recognized that potential weakness in Standard Oil, that's why he focused on volume over margins. He knew that if Standard ran with high margins, he would be provided an opening for a competitor to best him.
- BillinghamJ 12y agoThe vast majority of that 20% goes into overheads associated with operating the service - e.g. insurance, background checks, etc. What's left to cover engineering & profit is probably only 2-3%.
- ThisIBereave 12y agoThe drivers have to pay for their own insurance, so it's not that. Hard to see how a background check requires 20% of all revenue.
- BillinghamJ 12y agoUber has their own insurance as well, in case a driver isn't insured. And the "etc." part of what I said is probably no less than 100 major things, so seems pretty silly to to make that statement.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y agoDo you have a source for that?
- BillinghamJ 12y agoYes - http://blog.uber.com/dynamicpricing http://blog.uber.com/dynamicpricing
- maceo 12y agoLabor organizers ought to use the same tactics to reach Uber drivers as Uber used to reach Lyft drivers.
- edgyswingset 12y agoIt seems like this article is about Uber, not the sharing economy as whole. We don't have enough data to say if a "sharing" economy is viable or ethical. Companies skirting around laws and exploiting their employees (or whatever they choose to call them) such as Uber don't reflect well on this, though.
- elwin 12y ago> Uber is just capitalism, in its most naked form. Considering that the workers own the means of production, this is a curious thing to say.
- xorcist 12y agoThey don't, as the app is the magic sauce. It's where all the bookings will be, if things turn out the way Uber and Lyft valutations are based on.
- humanrebar 12y agoOwning your own time, money, resources, and equipment is very capitalist. There's nothing about capitalism that requires centralized control of anything. It's just classical liberal philosophy applied to economics... individual rights should include property rights.
- elwin 12y agoThat's true, but my point was that it's odd for the article to portray Uber as the exploitative capitalist when Uber does not own the capital.
- humanrebar 12y agoAh. I just find "means of production" to be an anachronistic term that presumes something like a Marxist worldview, but I guess that was your intention.
- rmc 12y agoThe workers very much do not control production.
- avn2109 12y agoThe article's essential claim is that the workers do not own the means of production in any meaningful sense, despite the careful legal fictions to the contrary. The claim is that Uber et al have developed a way to own the upsides (aka positive cash flows) associated with the means of production, while externalizing the downsides (repair bills, depreciation, insurance, bodily harm from accidents, etc) onto the workers. And even in a strictly limited literal sense, the cars are bought on credit, so the bank owns them.
- sebst 12y agoNot sure if that article is really about shifting risks from corporates to workers and weakening their protections. It is more like a kind of gatekeeper discussion. Digitalization has moved the gate keeper role from media dinosaurs to agile startups and companies. Uber can de-activate their users as well as Facebook can reduce organic visibility of fan pages or Google may kick you out of their index. The open internet that we have is still built upon the gate keeper behavior. In the Uber case that clearly affects individuals, like taxi drivers, but in the case of Facebook, Twitter and Uber that can affect large companies, too. So, may I read this article also as a manifest against "attention" monopolists?
- ngpio 12y ago> Not sure if that article is really about shifting risks from corporates to workers and weakening their protections. Jacobin articles are rarely 'about' anything. Their primary mode of reasoning is like folk etymology on a discourse level. There's usually a fair amount of factual evidence included, but it's forced through a narrative -- that's there for the sake of appearing novel -- into a conclusion that doesn't logically follow from anything presented. (I haven't read this one yet, but if it's anything like Against Chairs[1], my criticism should apply. Admittedly I'm doing the same thing in this comment that I'm criticizing Jacobin for doing.) [1] https://www.jacobinmag.com/2012/04/against-chairs/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/2012/04/against-chairs/
- golemotron 12y agoWhen I first saw Uber it seemed obvious to me that drivers would be squeezed. In the regulated hodge-podge of companies that Uber and Lyft are replacing, drivers didn't make very much. Uber and Lyft drivers got a "raise" when they signed up, but that came from Uber and Lyft's cash-on-hand and their rally to sign up drivers. The fact is that there is no scarcity of people who can drive, so prices will be driven down to the point where a consumer can make a choice between a college student who is part-timing with a ten year old car and a full time driver with a brand new Prius. You might pay a small premium for the latter, but the former will be dirt cheap and they'll be paid next to nothing. AirBnb is a sharing company that won't have this squeeze because the supply of properties is more bounded than the supply of drivers.
- swang 12y agoTo clarify, neither Uber nor Lyft would allow someone to drive a 10 year old car... And I would think a lot of people using those services wouldn't get into a 10 year old car. So even if there was a service that allowed old cars, there would probably be some segmentation.
- golemotron 12y agoThat's my point. In this model it's a race to the bottom. If Uber or Lyft don't take advantage of the supply of drivers with 10 year old cars someone else will. So Uber and Lyft can either take that low-cost market under a different name and hope that they can maintain income at a quality point that doesn't pollute their brand, or someone else steps in and Uber/Lyft become merely services for people who would take limos.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- laughtiger 12y agoBoth Lyft and Uber vary their requirements by city, so they may have such allowances somewhere. When Lyft and Sidecar started in SF all they required was year 2000 or newer. Also, neither Lyft or Uber has much control over drivers signing up one car, then using a different one. It happens all the time. Finally, many limousines are actually this old or older.
- sagevann 12y agoAgainst 'Sharing Economy'. Maybe I'm splitting hairs, but does it bother anyone else that the 'Sharing Economy' is not sharing at all? Renting your assets out for use when you're not using them is entirely different than giving them to someone else to use and expecting nothing in return.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y agoYes. I think that this type of employer-employee relationship described is just being rebranded as "sharing economy" and "disruptor."
- golemotron 12y agoSpeaking of the sharing economy, why isn't AirBnB setting price and using surge pricing?
- shkkmo 12y agoIt seems to me that Uber and Lift are working hard to poach eachother's partner drivers. Perhaps one of them will actually make the leap to make a partner driver union with a seat on the board and a say in policy and pricing changes? Wouldn't that help them poach the other companies employees? Maybe I'm being overly optimistic here...
- lnanek2 12y agoDoesn't seem like a very fair or intelligent article. It basically says Uber is doing nothing good and just exploiting workers, but if I wrote an Uber clone app, no one would download it, or even hear about it. Then if someone did download it there would be only one or two drivers. Then if they traveled to another city and opened the app there would be no drivers at all. We developers can often write an app that is technically competent, but then it never pulls in the users. In the case of Uber, they not just have a successful app and brand that people know and download, but the app also needs to have a large network of drivers in it to provide good service. The vast majority of drivers I've ever had gave me their personal business card, but I never use them since I'd have to call and negotiate a time and a price - and the price they start at is often more than just booking them through Uber or SuperShuttle or whatever. So these guys aren't getting the fares on their own, Uber is clearly providing some benefit.
- plorg 12y agoIt's not clear, though, that this benefit is positive. The article seems pretty clear on the fact that Uber has pulled a bait-and-switch, offering drivers a living wage only to drop their rates (and thus their wage payout) substantially once they had garnered the network effects you describe. It is precisely these network effects which are both benefiting Uber and working against the drivers. By training users to go to Uber for their ride-sharing needs, the drivers now have to also use Uber if they want to get passengers. Sure, you have a bunch of individual drivers' business cards, but you're probably _less_ likely to get a ride from any of those drivers than if Uber had never wrangled them in the first place. Meanwhile, the drivers have invested a good deal of money and effort into an industry in which they may not have chosen to participate if Uber hadn't recruited them.
- pasbesoin 12y agoEconomists could do some solid and useful work by researching historical as well as current cost/benefit scenarios. So much at least of general public knowledge and reporting in the realm is focused upon "prediction". How about painting some clear pictures of what has happened; why; and who paid and who benefited? And as our knowledge, e.g. of long-term health effects, continues to grow, such topics remain open for further analysis and refinement. Perhaps Ken Burns could put together a series on the economic history of the U.S., for example. (Perhaps those spreadsheets are more interesting when subjected to a slow pan... ;-) Seriously, though. Last year I got sucked into yet another discussion of recent politics, and I suggested putting the whole situation under a comprehensive cost accounting analysis. For the other parties in the discussion, it -- a bit surprisingly, to me -- seemed to be something of a "lightbulb moment".
- abakker 12y agoFrom a recent Oxford Economics study sponsored by SAP/SuccessFactors: "As the economy evolves to a state where nearly everything can be delivered as a service, companies are increasingly tapping external expertise and resources they need — and on an as-needed basis — to fill skills and resource gaps and to accommodate rapidly changing business and customer demands. That means more temporary staff, more consultants and contract workers, and even “crowd-sourced” projects. In fact, of those companies surveyed as part of Workforce 2020, 83 percent of executives say they will be increasing the use of contingent, intermittent or consultant employees. " (Source, Workforce 2020 study, Oxford Economics, SAP)(http://www.successfactors.com/en_us/lp/workforce-2020-insights.html http://www.successfactors.com/en_us/lp/workforce-2020-insigh... - need to register to download) I laughed when I first heard the term "contingent labor". We all know that companies like Uber, and a whole host of companies that rely on contractor drivers/deliverydrivers will be the first to buy self-driving cars. That Uber would tout their job-creating function is pretty low. They would love to cut out the drivers and run 24/7. The sad part is, engineers could probably figure out optimizing algorithms that would make the service better if it didn't have human drivers, and maybe even cheaper. I haven't reached the point yet where I give up on these kind of services, but its close. I feel badly that we aren't coming up with jobs as fast as we are coming up with ways to get rid of them.
- cheald 12y agoMaybe it's just my lack of understanding of the subtleties of the situation, but I'm not quite sure why people are surprised that this is happening. Without the constraint of regulatory restrictions on the number of people who can drive, there is more supply than demand for drivers. Additionally, apart from that, when multiple companies start competing in the same market, their prices will drop. Given the supply of drivers and the need for companies to compete on fares, why would anyone expect expect pricing to not reach an equilibrium where margins are as low as drivers will tolerate?
- chrismcb 12y agoIf any other company did what uber does, they would be branded as evil, and the mob would have pitchforks out, and calling for boycotts. They exploit their employees, they skirt and out right break laws, they appear to commit fraud to disrupt competitors. Yet because they perform a service that many here like, many sing the praises... And keep using the service.
- sharer 12y agothis sounds like a criticism of Uber's practices not sharing in general.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]