3 ms·
Ok thanks. So this basically makes it easier and more secure to get set up with cloudflare? So why couldn't Cloudflare set up what I'm suggesting? Are there
by mrfusion 12y ago
Ok thanks. So this basically makes it easier and more secure to get set up with cloudflare?
So why couldn't Cloudflare set up what I'm suggesting? Are there technical reasons, or just lack of demand?
- peterwaller 12y agoCloudflare probably is easier than running your own servers and configuring them correctly - I don't know since I haven't used them myself. But it sounds like you're not very familiar with the importance of the private key. If anyone else other than the bank obtains the bank's private key, the bank would consider that a serious failure, since it means others could impersonate them. The whole point is that you shouldn't give your private key to anyone else, and that without that key, others can't impersonate you. This "keyless SSL" scheme allows the bank to set up an entity it controls which knows the key. This entity delegates to cloudflare the ability to pretend to be the bank on a request-by-request basis, without divulging the key to anyone. If cloudflare gets compromised, the bank can stop that delegation on demand, the compromise is closed and the key is kept safe.
- icebraining 12y agoTo serve SSL for your domain, Cloudflare needs a certificate for your domain issued by an accepted CA, which someone needs to buy. The only way for them to set that up would be to become a CA, get browsers to accept their master certificate and then issue their own certs for their clients.
- ianlevesque 12y agoThey actually do offer a service where they proxy your plain-text HTTP to end users as HTTPS and provide a certificate. It's extremely convenient.
- icebraining 12y agoYes, but you still need to buy and give them a certificate, right? The question included "can offer SSL for free without buying certs", which is not possible, AFAIK.
- ianlevesque 12y agoNo, they essentially add your domain to a list of domain names in their own certificate.
- icebraining 12y agoReally? And their CA allows that? That's amazing.