3 ms·
I'm not sure if I'm even debating you here regarding their current legal obligations? I was refuting the OPs comment claimed they got fat off of purposeful negl
by dmix 12y ago
I'm not sure if I'm even debating you here regarding their current legal obligations? I was refuting the OPs comment claimed they got fat off of purposeful negligence of the law which is a false claim.
So yes In 2012, two years ago, did the state start caring about the business. Not the 4 years prior during growth, as the OP comment tried to paint the picture. They were a well established by 2012.
Civil lawsuits in 2010 have nothing to do with tax obligations. There is significant risk of running a business without proper insurance. These are lessons and failures new businesses learn. Whether you're a homeowner or an SV startup.
What happens if AirBnB becomes decentralized? The distribution of hotels rooms to homeowners is the new reality. It is now convenient that a big company like AirBnB is here to take the hit but the legal system is in no better shape to tax or better enforce property rights or deal with externalities, when hotels are no longer simply hotels. Which is why it's important to reevaluate laws instead of trying to hammer existing ones onto new markets and pretending its fixed.
- rgbrenner 12y ago> I was refuting the OPs comment claimed they got fat off of purposeful negligence of the law which is a false claim. It's not a false claim. Look, in July 2011, they closed a funding round that valued them at $1B. Today, it's $10B. You're saying 90% of their value is irrelevant to this debate. It's not irrelevant, and neither is what they've been doing for the past 2.5 years. It's is absolutely true that they've gotten fat off of purposely violating the law. http://www.forbes.com/sites/nicoleperlroth/2011/07/24/its-official-airbnb-joins-the-billion-dollar-valuation-club/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/nicoleperlroth/2011/07/24/its-of...
- dmix 12y agoEveryone here is claiming that the AirBnB is and was a hotel by definition of tax law... and this has always has been a fact. This is false. It has been very much up in the air. AirBnB operates globally in thousands of cities where they have no clear tax obligation. It still is in most places except SF. SF only made an official statement in 2012. Even in SF - at this moment - it still hasn't been revealed whether or not they have any obligation to pay backtaxes.... as would be the case if they did indeed blatantly break the law. Even the state hasn't fully confirmed the position on their past activity, yet you and the downvoting-because-I-disagree brigade knows better? I miss the old HN :( btw, your Forbes article only confirms my point that the lawmakers only cared about them after they got wealthy. They are slow moving and reactionary, period.