3 ms·
So much of school is based on blindly doing what you're told and I think young boys have trouble doing what they're told. I know I personally wanted to know th
by donatj 12y ago
So much of school is based on blindly doing what you're told and I think young boys have trouble doing what they're told. I know I personally wanted to know the reasoning behind things. In the army they have to break young men down before they blindly follow orders.
Even as a nearly 30 something I don't like being told what to do. Ask, don't tell.
I know I could see this was pointless charade and would rather do something of actual value, whereas most of what you do in school is pointless busy work with no real educational value at all.
- tptacek 12y agoLet me take a wild guess here: You're male. It seems like according to your premise, if we could just get over our prejudices, we could drastically streamline military training by simply selecting docile, compliant females instead of petulant, inquisitive males.
- donatj 12y agoI just know these to be the reasons I and my friends didn't do well in school.
- kevingadd 12y agoWhether or not it's meant in 'sexist terms' doesn't make a sexist statement not sexist. Assigning such fundamental traits to an entire gender without a factual basis is pretty ridiculous.
- tptacek 12y agoThe psychological attraction towards retrofitting a formative experience of failure into an indicator of innate unique value does indeed seem irresistible. Which is a good reason to be suspicious of it; it's a meme that has evolved countermeasures to all of reason's defenses. I did terribly in school, by the way.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoPublic school and military training are (or were) intimately related, actually. The former, as we know it today, has its origins in 19th century Prussian militarism. That said, one cannot fairly compare the two. The military has an express purpose of national security, and is well suited to obedience and susceptibility. Public schools, on the other hand, are little more than industrialized daycare at best, and harmful propaganda centers at worst. That and joining the military comes with benefits that extend beyond the artificial void inside a public school... it's supposed to, anyway.
- tptacek 12y agoIt sounds like your implied argument is that boys do worse than girls in school because school is derived from 19th century military training. That doesn't sound right. (I'm reading more into your comment than you actually said, I know; maybe you're just making a tangential point).
- wosos 12y agoYeah, but they are generally much weaker physically and don't tend to be as aggressive and competitive.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I know I personally wanted to know the reasoning behind things. In the army they have to break young men down before they blindly follow orders. And young women, too. > I think boys can largely see this is a pointless charade and would rather do something of actual value I don't think there's a lot of evidence in the behavior of school age boys vs. girls, either in school or in any other context, to support this. OTOH, I do think your explanation may reflect (though in a distorted way) something that may be a real issue that may explain part of the difference: I suspect that boys have a lower tolerance for activities with a delayed payoff, where conventional school curriculum mostly has a very delayed payoff.
- rotw 12y agoI read somewhere (forgotten the book title sorry, I'll try and get back to you on that!) that our patriarchal society's gender roles (and thus the games children play at a young age to educate them about these) differ for men and women in terms of how they relate to people: For men, competition is emphasised, meaning that independence and dominance is the prime goal, while for women, connection and bonding is the overarching ideal. To this end, having stereotypes and games like girls playing with dolls while boys build things and play more combative games instills different behaviours in children, which fundamentally change how they relate to others. You can still see it reflected in stupid things like "Be a man", which is essentially a shaming shorthand for "assert independence and dominance, thus showing less vulnerability to those able to dominate you in a competitive social hierarchy". This obviously also reflects on the way people relate to obedience; independence being a supposed virtue, obedience can be intepreted from this masculine framework as an attempt by someone else to dominate. Emphasising co-operation and connection, though, means a greater willingness to engage. These are obviously only broad trends, but they are noticeable.
- tomp 12y ago> our patriarchal society's Sorry to be anal about it, but (assuming you're from a Western country) the society is anything but patriarchal. "Patriarchy is a social system in which males [...] occupy roles of political leadership, moral authority and control of property, and where fathers hold authority over women and children" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriarchy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriarchy