3 ms·
"seems to annoy a lot of people - for reasons I've never quite understood." Because it's a cheat. In novels, you can build up whatever society you like, no mat
by jerf 12y ago
"seems to annoy a lot of people - for reasons I've never quite understood."
Because it's a cheat. In novels, you can build up whatever society you like, no matter how implausible, but it doesn't mean anything in the real world. Sure, the Culture world is among my #1 fictional places I'd like to live, but it probably can't exist because there's no path from here to there that looks anything like the books. It's a fun place to put stories, but as an argument, it's disingenuous, which is what bothers people.
Gene Roddenberry's Star Trek TNG run was another example of a cheat... the idea that humans would grow, get to space, build a star-system-spanning Federation, and that the crew of its flagship starship wouldn't so much as slightly disagree about anything, ever, let alone squabble, is just an absurd cheat of an argument, as arguments go. Things got more realistic, if not necessarily "better", when at least small amounts of internal conflict were let in.
To which my solution is to simply stop allowing works of fiction to make normative arguments in my head. It's too easy to cheat. Arguably it's impossible not to cheat.
- arethuza 12y agoEven Banks thought that humans weren't really nice enough to form something like the Culture. On the other hand, he also makes it clear the organic inhabitants are as engineered as the drones and Minds - everything from the way their bodies work through the language they speak has been had thousands of years of engineering. Of course, all SF "cheats" in some respects - and clearly a lot of aspects of the Culture technology are effectively unexplained magic - but that doesn't bother me. Having always been fascinated by strong artificial intelligence (real artificial minds) and I think the Culture novels do a very entertaining and optimistic job of raising questions about what a society made up of artificial intelligences and organic inhabitants might be like. As he said to an interview about the Minds: Is this what gods would actually be like?” Banks answered, “If we’re lucky.”