3 ms·
isn't the solution to that metamoderation a-la amazon? i.e. "was this review useful?" gets "no" for both the above reviews. Seems to work IMO.
by riffraff 12y ago
isn't the solution to that metamoderation a-la amazon?
i.e. "was this review useful?" gets "no" for both the above reviews.
Seems to work IMO.
- misaelm 12y agoI don't know how it works for Amazon, but my guess is that only for the products that get a lot of traffic (e.g. kindle) you have enough "honest" opinions to get rid of the bias.
- svantana 12y agoCombine that with a karma system à la HN and you should have something...
- maroonblazer 12y agoThe problem with Amazon's system is that unless you know to look to see if the review is helpful, you may think it legit. StackExchange solved this problem. I don't know why more sites use that approach to reviews.
- eevilspock 12y agoYes, that's part of the solution. But it has to be much more robust than "This review was useful". The meta-moderation needs to be recusive, e.g. like PageRank. The other part of the solution is a review system designed around the fact that people have different tastes. Netflix at least tries to do that. On Yelp, a great hole-in-the-wall will average three stars because those that don't like them will vote the opposite of those that love them. Three stars doesn't help either type of person.
- kps 12y agoThe best part of Amazon's review system is the graph. Normal near the top, fine. Bimodal (controversial books excepted) is a red flag.