3 ms·
Please try define a freedom which do not need coercion of someone in order to enforce it. I defy that any such thing could exist. If you want freedom of speech
by belorn 12y ago
Please try define a freedom which do not need coercion of someone in order to enforce it. I defy that any such thing could exist.
If you want freedom of speech, you have to prevent those who would seek out to squelch it. Freedom of the press is only possible by preventing those who would otherwise burn down the printing press. Freedom of person prevents assassins and rapists from doing their ill deeds, and has to be prevented with coercion that employ violence, theft (fines), imprisonment, or social pressure. The later is simply violence that is psychological rather than of physical.
If you read up on the history of liberty, the definition of freedom, you will find that all this has been thought about a long time ago. The paradoxical nature of using coercion (laws) in order to have liberty is not a new insight.
- bane 12y agoWell that's disingenuous. You specifically brought up that the GPL is a non-coercive agent for freedom. Now that we've demonstrated that it is coercive, you moved your fence posts. You're really tied up in the the history of liberty and freedom, and act like it the matter is all tied up and resolved. But very little could be further from the truth! Even more important, you keep attempting to draw parallels to enlightenment thought on freedom, when the modern thought on the matter has come a long way since then and to anybody who seriously studies all of the eras of liberal thinking, the GPL is not a particularly interesting or conforming philosophy. It parallels totalitarian philosophies far more easily than any democratic of liberal thinking on the matter. A country based around the kind of self-perpetuation at all costs kind of philosophy the GPL is built around would be a dystopia.
- belorn 12y agoWhen its been demostrated that your arguments has dismissed in 17th century, you start to lash out agressively. If you had proof of "the truth", you would have written it. Like a ideologically driven and uncritical thinker, You Know The Truth! You are the modern thought of today. Not that you have to mention what that modern thought is, since obviously, you already possess it. I could sit here and explain to you how none of the above post says GPL is a non-coercive agent. Liberty can never be non-coercive, and despite claims of otherwhise in this discussion, none has provided an example of a liberty that can be enforced non-coercivly. Liberty has to employ coercion, or liberty is just empty word with no meaning.