4 ms·
The only way to have maximum freedom as you define it, is by having no liberty. To give someone else liberty, someone must be coerced into giving it. This is s
by belorn 12y ago
The only way to have maximum freedom as you define it, is by having no liberty.
To give someone else liberty, someone must be coerced into giving it. This is simply a logical fact. In order for the maximum freedom you are talking about, the only thing said must be "do whatever you want". Kill who ever, steal what ever, enslave whom ever. If someone speak, someone else must be allowed to prevent them from speaking.
But this is simply a confusion that defines freedom as "no rules". Freedom has a much broader definition, which is why I brought up how philosophers during the ages has defined it. To quote John Locke: "Thus, freedom is not as Sir Robert Filmer defines it: ‘A liberty for everyone to do what he likes, to live as he pleases, and not to be tied by any laws.’ Freedom is constrained by laws in both the state of nature and political society."
The argument you are making was discarded in the 17th century by the Father of Classical Liberalism. Calling those who disagree with you as ideologically driven and uncritical thinkers really do show who is right here, doesn't it?
- bane 12y agoI think if you want to parallel Locke with the philosophy of the GPL, you need to reread your Locke. You keep talking about freedom like it's a settled topic, but the debate on what is freedom and how to maximize is robust and vigorous, and Locke has not been the leader in liberal thought for a very long time and RMS is not taken very seriously in those circles either.