2 ms·
> GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion > as the absence of coercion That's incorrect on all points. GPL is exists purely as a coercive li
by bane 12y ago
> GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion
> as the absence of coercion
That's incorrect on all points. GPL is exists purely as a coercive license. It's up to you to decide if the coercion it's employing is a good thing or a bad thing (or somewhere in the middle), but it's one of the most highly coercive legal concepts in existence.
What exactly do you think the GPL is about?
It explicitly denies many exercises of freedom while using a coercive license to enforce community contribution and attribution.
I'm specifically not saying that other legal agreements provide more freedom or even different freedoms, only that the GPL doesn't provide the maximal sort of freedom it ideologically espouses. It's so obvious that the purpose of the GPLv3 was specifically to remove freedoms that people had been enjoying when using the GPLv2.
To cement the point, I'm going to show you what an actual, objective, maximally free license might look like:
"Do whatever you want with this software."
Now go through the thought experiment and start enumerating the ways in which any of the GPL licenses erode an objectively maximally free license. Each one of those things that you can't do under the GPL is a specific freedom that is removed.
This is probably a good place to mention that the GPL licenses are specifically protected by copyright held and enforced by the FSF. You aren't even free to copy the license itself!
I'm specifically not saying this is a bad thing or a good thing. But I am saying that this is a reality that is not ideologically recognized by the FSF and ideologically aligned people. The GPL licenses are very clever hacks on the legal system. But they are not the standards of freedom people should probably be following.
This isn't something that's hard to understand, but downvotes above show that this is something that's hard to digest by ideologically driven HN members.
If the GPL has had one success over all others, it has been turning copyright law and legal licensing schemes into a religion promulgated by uncritically thinking followers.
- __david__ 12y ago> To cement the point, I'm going to show you what an actual, objective, maximally free license might look like: > "Do whatever you want with this software." So here's the perspective shift you need to understand it: that's not "maximally free". Because software is rarely a simple one layer system like: programmer -> user Instead it passes through many hands: programmer -> derivative work programmer -> packager -> user Your "maximally free" license is only maximal at the first exchange. But it gives anyone in the chain the "freedom" to remove the end user's ability to change the code (or incorporate it into a derivative work) as they see fit. The GPL, on the other hand, tries to preserve the freedom all the way to the end user. There are way more users than there are middle-men, so I'd say the GPL gives more freedom to the world, even though it ties the hands of the people along the way to the end user ("forcing" them to pass the freedoms they enjoyed on to the next guy in the chain). It really comes down to whether you believe that you (the end-user) should have the fundamental right to tinker with the source code of any piece of software you buy/acquire/run. The FSF believes in that right. Everything they do falls out from that belief. > This is probably a good place to mention that the GPL licenses are specifically protected by copyright held and enforced by the FSF. No, not really—it's not applicable to the situation at all. (A) The GPL isn't itself software, and (B) it's tightly controlled for practical reasons—if everyone and their dog changed little bits of the license you'd have a million incompatible licenses out there. That can only do harm to the ecosystem.
- bane 12y agoI don't materially disagree with most of what your saying. You seem to be providing an appropriately nuanced view of how the GPL works and the goals. And I agree completely with this statement > Your "maximally free" license is only maximal at the first exchange. But it gives anyone in the chain the "freedom" to remove the end user's ability to change the code (or incorporate it into a derivative work) as they see fit. That is entirely correct. What I disagree with (a little bit) is this > The GPL, on the other hand, tries to preserve the freedom all the way to the end user. The GPL tries to preserve a particular kind of freedom through the chain -- and that kind of freedom is rather narrow, even if it does try to guarantee self-perpetuity. But it completely tramples all others -- especially v3, which does so with prejudice. This is consistently what my point is in this thread. I'm not sure I understand where any disagreement on this definition lies. You even agree that the GPL is not maximal and only guarantees a subset of the freedoms a notional maximal license grants "it gives anyone in the chain the 'freedom' to...<do whatever>". But you'll see by all the downvotes here that a discussion of the merits and drawbacks of the GPL is virtually impossible -- because "freedom". > It really comes down to whether you believe that you (the end-user) should have the fundamental right to tinker with... The notional maximal license also believes in this. But it does not guarantee it. The notional maximal license believes all freedoms are equally valid and does not enforce one particular freedom at the expense of others. And to be clear, I'm not advocating for the notional maximal license. It has obvious shortcomings and also protects many kinds of objectively negative freedoms (the right to profit from other people's labor without their consent, etc.). But I'm using it as a trivial tool to demonstrate that the GPL does not ensure the greatest possible freedom. It merely ensures the greatest possible expression of one particular kind of freedom, and it does so at the expense of others. I'm also not saying the GPL is bad, it is what it is. It's resulted in a lot of good in the world and some bad. But again, it is what it is, it's not a tool for ensuring the most possible freedom. > No, not really—it's not applicable to the situation at all. (A) The GPL isn't itself software... Actually it is. The GPL can be used on non-software items. Not GPLing the license itself does nothing to prevent the proliferation of licenses. There are already hundreds of incompatible licenses. Not GPLing the GPL I think is shortsighted. If the original vanilla GPL licenses are the best, people will use them regardless of the derivatives and alternatives, if they aren't then they'll use something else, even if it's an incompatible derivative.
- belorn 12y agoThe only way to have maximum freedom as you define it, is by having no liberty. To give someone else liberty, someone must be coerced into giving it. This is simply a logical fact. In order for the maximum freedom you are talking about, the only thing said must be "do whatever you want". Kill who ever, steal what ever, enslave whom ever. If someone speak, someone else must be allowed to prevent them from speaking. But this is simply a confusion that defines freedom as "no rules". Freedom has a much broader definition, which is why I brought up how philosophers during the ages has defined it. To quote John Locke: "Thus, freedom is not as Sir Robert Filmer defines it: ‘A liberty for everyone to do what he likes, to live as he pleases, and not to be tied by any laws.’ Freedom is constrained by laws in both the state of nature and political society." The argument you are making was discarded in the 17th century by the Father of Classical Liberalism. Calling those who disagree with you as ideologically driven and uncritical thinkers really do show who is right here, doesn't it?
- bane 12y agoI think if you want to parallel Locke with the philosophy of the GPL, you need to reread your Locke. You keep talking about freedom like it's a settled topic, but the debate on what is freedom and how to maximize is robust and vigorous, and Locke has not been the leader in liberal thought for a very long time and RMS is not taken very seriously in those circles either.