6 ms·
The only one here who is talking about the definition of "freedom" is you, and I find it lacking in both insight and meaning. Freedom has a long history of phi
by belorn 12y ago
The only one here who is talking about the definition of "freedom" is you, and I find it lacking in both insight and meaning.
Freedom has a long history of philosophical thoughts from the last two centuries. Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius wrote over 2000 years ago that freedom is "a polity administered with regard to equal rights and equal freedom of speech", from which we can derive that equal rights is an aspect of freedom. As teddyh wrote above, copyright do not give equal rights to whomever has the work, but GPL changes this and preserves the rights which without copyright we would all equally share.
John Stuart Mill published in 1859 a book called "On Liberty", in which he recognized the difference between liberty as the freedom to act and liberty as the absence of coercion. This concept of positive liberty and negative liberty can be distilled into two different concepts of "freedom". One can have the freedom of speech (a positive liberty), and the freedom of not getting enslaved (a negative liberty).
GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion which copyright law provides.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion which copyright law provides. GPL is an instance of the coercion which copyright law provides, not a prevention of it: you can use the thing to which I have been granted exclusive rights under copyright, so long as you act as I have directed based on my perception of what serves my interests. And, compared to other free software licenses, the GPL -- especially the GPLv3 -- is a fairly heavy handed instance of that coercion.
- belorn 12y agoIn order to enforce any liberty, coercion is the only way available to do so. Its an paradoxical aspect of liberty which exist when ever one try to enable liberty. A typical example is how the police is allowed to use physical violence, fines and imprisonment in order to enable liberty from violence, theft and enslavement. When someone is given freedom of speach, it means restricting those who would want to stop your speach. When someone is talking about freedom from slavery, it means the restrictions of those who want to enslave others. Liberty as a concept thus do not address those who want to act onto others, but those who would be acted onto. GPL prevent distributors from using copyright law to coerce a third party. Those distributors who want to use copyright for coercion is prevented, and the police will enforce it.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In order to enforce any liberty, coercion is the only way available to do so. Sure, "enforce" implies "coercion". That doesn't imply that coercion is the only way to acheive liberty.
- belorn 12y agoPlease try define a freedom which do not need coercion of someone in order to enforce it. I defy that any such thing could exist. If you want freedom of speech, you have to prevent those who would seek out to squelch it. Freedom of the press is only possible by preventing those who would otherwise burn down the printing press. Freedom of person prevents assassins and rapists from doing their ill deeds, and has to be prevented with coercion that employ violence, theft (fines), imprisonment, or social pressure. The later is simply violence that is psychological rather than of physical. If you read up on the history of liberty, the definition of freedom, you will find that all this has been thought about a long time ago. The paradoxical nature of using coercion (laws) in order to have liberty is not a new insight.
- bane 12y agoWell that's disingenuous. You specifically brought up that the GPL is a non-coercive agent for freedom. Now that we've demonstrated that it is coercive, you moved your fence posts. You're really tied up in the the history of liberty and freedom, and act like it the matter is all tied up and resolved. But very little could be further from the truth! Even more important, you keep attempting to draw parallels to enlightenment thought on freedom, when the modern thought on the matter has come a long way since then and to anybody who seriously studies all of the eras of liberal thinking, the GPL is not a particularly interesting or conforming philosophy. It parallels totalitarian philosophies far more easily than any democratic of liberal thinking on the matter. A country based around the kind of self-perpetuation at all costs kind of philosophy the GPL is built around would be a dystopia.
- belorn 12y ago
- bane 12y ago> GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion > as the absence of coercion That's incorrect on all points. GPL is exists purely as a coercive license. It's up to you to decide if the coercion it's employing is a good thing or a bad thing (or somewhere in the middle), but it's one of the most highly coercive legal concepts in existence. What exactly do you think the GPL is about? It explicitly denies many exercises of freedom while using a coercive license to enforce community contribution and attribution. I'm specifically not saying that other legal agreements provide more freedom or even different freedoms, only that the GPL doesn't provide the maximal sort of freedom it ideologically espouses. It's so obvious that the purpose of the GPLv3 was specifically to remove freedoms that people had been enjoying when using the GPLv2. To cement the point, I'm going to show you what an actual, objective, maximally free license might look like: "Do whatever you want with this software." Now go through the thought experiment and start enumerating the ways in which any of the GPL licenses erode an objectively maximally free license. Each one of those things that you can't do under the GPL is a specific freedom that is removed. This is probably a good place to mention that the GPL licenses are specifically protected by copyright held and enforced by the FSF. You aren't even free to copy the license itself! I'm specifically not saying this is a bad thing or a good thing. But I am saying that this is a reality that is not ideologically recognized by the FSF and ideologically aligned people. The GPL licenses are very clever hacks on the legal system. But they are not the standards of freedom people should probably be following. This isn't something that's hard to understand, but downvotes above show that this is something that's hard to digest by ideologically driven HN members. If the GPL has had one success over all others, it has been turning copyright law and legal licensing schemes into a religion promulgated by uncritically thinking followers.
- __david__ 12y ago> To cement the point, I'm going to show you what an actual, objective, maximally free license might look like: > "Do whatever you want with this software." So here's the perspective shift you need to understand it: that's not "maximally free". Because software is rarely a simple one layer system like: programmer -> user Instead it passes through many hands: programmer -> derivative work programmer -> packager -> user Your "maximally free" license is only maximal at the first exchange. But it gives anyone in the chain the "freedom" to remove the end user's ability to change the code (or incorporate it into a derivative work) as they see fit. The GPL, on the other hand, tries to preserve the freedom all the way to the end user. There are way more users than there are middle-men, so I'd say the GPL gives more freedom to the world, even though it ties the hands of the people along the way to the end user ("forcing" them to pass the freedoms they enjoyed on to the next guy in the chain). It really comes down to whether you believe that you (the end-user) should have the fundamental right to tinker with the source code of any piece of software you buy/acquire/run. The FSF believes in that right. Everything they do falls out from that belief. > This is probably a good place to mention that the GPL licenses are specifically protected by copyright held and enforced by the FSF. No, not really—it's not applicable to the situation at all. (A) The GPL isn't itself software, and (B) it's tightly controlled for practical reasons—if everyone and their dog changed little bits of the license you'd have a million incompatible licenses out there. That can only do harm to the ecosystem.