3 ms·
It does, so the reasoning would be that if an asset is actively traded that provides an incentive to invest in it because you know there's a place to sell it if
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
It does, so the reasoning would be that if an asset is actively traded that provides an incentive to invest in it because you know there's a place to sell it if you want to.
This seems plausible, but of course, it comes at a cost. Part of that cost is that for smart people it can be more lucrative to trade something than to make something.
- eru 17y agoBut if they can provide more value by trading than by making, why should you value making above trading?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI don't. I just questioned whether they actually do provide more value by trading or if it just appears that way during a financial bubble. Don't forget that the sole purpose of trading is to finance making. Trading has no intrinsic value. It's the bureaucracy of capitalism ;-)
- eru 17y agoThat sounds an awful lot like the greek philosophers who did not hold merchants in high regard. Making is ultimatively just pushing atoms (or ideas), too.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI'm just making a difference between the goals and the means to achieve those goals. The goal is to produce the goods and services we want. Trading is a means to do that efficiently, similar to computing. Computing, just as trading, has no intrinsic value. It has value only insofar as it achieves its goals. I doubt that trading has been achieving its goals in the most efficient and effective way possible recently. In 2007 the financial industry in the US made 70% of all corporate profits. Obviously, something was out of balance and it's rebalancing now. Part of that rebalancing will no doubt be a shift of labor away from that bloated financial services sector. I don't think this critique should be taken as offensive or disparaging at all.
- eru 17y agoYes, I agree it was out of balance. No offense taken.