3 ms·
To be honest, our answer was pretty vague. We do believe that somewhere down the road we may come up with some new tool or way of doing things that is patentabl
by xinroman 20y ago
To be honest, our answer was pretty vague. We do believe that somewhere down the road we may come up with some new tool or way of doing things that is patentable (heck, if Amazon can do it with "1-click"...) and will pursue that as it comes up.
In the larger picture, though, I don't think that this is going to make or break anybody. I went to a workshop a few weeks ago that was hosted by the Stern School of Business - they had a panel of VCs and one Angel Investor, a startup business pitching to them, and an audience full of people able to ask questions. What was interesting was that one of the first questions the VCs asked after the pitch was "do you have any patents?" The answer was a pretty straight-forward "no." BUT, when asked about it later by someone in the audience, all of the VCs agreed that they didn't really care that the team didn't have anything patented - that they'd rather see a startup spending their time and energy on implementation than on developing a patent portfolio. Really, they just asked the question because they HAVE to ask the question.
I think the larger question here is "why can't someone else do what you're doing?" and the "do you have any patents?" question is the first logical step in answering that. But it's not the end-all be-all. I'm pretty sure Amazon's success really has very little to do with "1-click" and that this wan't even patented until a couple of years ago. (I should check some sources on that...)
- xinroman 20y agoYep, I knew I should've looked that up before shooting my mouth off: http://cse.stanford.edu/class/cs201/projects-99-00/software-patents/amazon.html http://cse.stanford.edu/class/cs201/projects-99-00/software-patents/amazon.html Regardless, I still stand by my point. I also believe that most software patents are ludicrous, so maybe I'm not the person to listen to here.
- volida 20y agopatents is mostly something that big companies make use of between each other, so that they exchange between them rights of use of different pantents. Microsoft has a patent on showing a message to user X when "john doe is typing..." for communication systems! Microsoft would never use that patent if it couldn't actually make money from you, and if it could you'd probably pay or just give them rights to some other patent you may have...