5 ms·
Remind me again how the GPL preserves my freedom.
by bane 12y ago
Remind me again how the GPL preserves my freedom.
- teddyh 12y ago> Remind me again how the GPL preserves my freedom. Very well. The governments and states of the world has agreed that any written or creative works shall have owners, called “copyright holders”, who can decide who, if any, other persons shall have the right to make further copies and/or make modifications of those works. This legal arrangement is made with a few specific business models in mind, but those business models originate from the age of printing presses, and this legal arrangement is not conducive to free collaboration and improvements of the works in question, as is the expected norm in, for example, science. Some people who are, for this reason, opposed to this arrangement, noted that this arrangement is, incidentally but necessarily, giving the authors quite a lot of power, and so they constructed the GPL. The GPL is a specific use to which authors can, if they wish, put these powers they have been granted. The GPL is meant to enable the above-mentioned collaborations and improvements without having any other deleterious effects, like making the authors feel like they are being (or could be) exploited. It is quite ingenious, since if you deny the right of authors to apply the GPL, you deny the rights given them by the legal arrangement of copyright. The specific way in which the GPL preserves your freedom depends on the work in question and your role in the situation. As a recipient of a work to which the author(s) have given you a license to use the freedoms granted by the GPL, you are permitted to do many things which would otherwise have been forbidden by copyright law. An an author, the GPL does not make you any more free (since copyright law already gives you absolute power), but the GPL is a tool which you can use to ensure that all users of your works are permitted to collaborate on and improve the work further, which might give you the incentive to produce and release more works.
- bane 12y ago> without having any other deleterious effects And I guess that's the problem isn't it? It does have deleterious effects, but within the narrow definition of "freedom" the GPL uses, those effects are unimportant/ignored. The long-term vision of the GPL does provide a kind of "freedom" along it's specific definition, but strongly denies all other kinds along the way. It's like saying "drinking alcohol is unhealthy" and citing cases of drunk driving and alcoholism as examples of this. And then narrowly defining "healthy" narrowly to include only lifestyles where no alcohol is consumed. Then completely ignoring and even actively working against all the ways in which alcohol can be healthy (and even healthier than no alcohol at all) because it doesn't fit into the narrow definition of "healthy". So when somebody says "remind me how the GNU Public Health Handbook keeps me healthy", when it's brought up that moderate alcohol consumption can increase various health factors and longevity...in other words that alcohol consumption can be "compatible" with health...it's the same kind of scenario here. The GPL's fixation with its specific ideological pure and completely arbitrary definition of "freedom" does not represent all kinds of freedom and that it purports to represent some kind of maximal freedom state is highly disingenuous at best and outright lying at worst. There are certain exercises of freedom that provide for better outcomes within certain criteria than anything the GPL offers and without certain deleterious effects that come from the GPL. But the GPL philosophy either acts like those shouldn't exist or are evil. And I find that highly spurious. There is no such thing as consequence-free freedom. There's always a trade-off of some kind. The GPL is a fiction that comes from a fantasy that this isn't the case and just like any philosophy that relies on ideological purity conveniently ignores the cases where the ideology has negative consequences.
- belorn 12y agoThe only one here who is talking about the definition of "freedom" is you, and I find it lacking in both insight and meaning. Freedom has a long history of philosophical thoughts from the last two centuries. Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius wrote over 2000 years ago that freedom is "a polity administered with regard to equal rights and equal freedom of speech", from which we can derive that equal rights is an aspect of freedom. As teddyh wrote above, copyright do not give equal rights to whomever has the work, but GPL changes this and preserves the rights which without copyright we would all equally share. John Stuart Mill published in 1859 a book called "On Liberty", in which he recognized the difference between liberty as the freedom to act and liberty as the absence of coercion. This concept of positive liberty and negative liberty can be distilled into two different concepts of "freedom". One can have the freedom of speech (a positive liberty), and the freedom of not getting enslaved (a negative liberty). GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion which copyright law provides.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> GPL provides the latter, in that it prevents the coercion which copyright law provides. GPL is an instance of the coercion which copyright law provides, not a prevention of it: you can use the thing to which I have been granted exclusive rights under copyright, so long as you act as I have directed based on my perception of what serves my interests. And, compared to other free software licenses, the GPL -- especially the GPLv3 -- is a fairly heavy handed instance of that coercion.
- belorn 12y agoIn order to enforce any liberty, coercion is the only way available to do so. Its an paradoxical aspect of liberty which exist when ever one try to enable liberty. A typical example is how the police is allowed to use physical violence, fines and imprisonment in order to enable liberty from violence, theft and enslavement. When someone is given freedom of speach, it means restricting those who would want to stop your speach. When someone is talking about freedom from slavery, it means the restrictions of those who want to enslave others. Liberty as a concept thus do not address those who want to act onto others, but those who would be acted onto. GPL prevent distributors from using copyright law to coerce a third party. Those distributors who want to use copyright for coercion is prevented, and the police will enforce it.