3 ms·
You're quite right to point out that favorable tax treatment of capital gains over dividends encourages retaining earnings but replacing both with a massive new
by notahacker 12y ago
You're quite right to point out that favorable tax treatment of capital gains over dividends encourages retaining earnings but replacing both with a massive new consumption tax is hardly likely to stimulate either a desire on the part of management to reinvest revenues or on the part of the shareholders to fund more consumption
And for all its outspoken advocates like Kotlikoff, consumption tax is a long way from being "the most favored tax among a consensus of tax economists". If there's one thing you could get a majority of tax economists to agree on it's that tax on land ownership and various other forms of economic rent distort incentives less than most other taxes, but ironically that's more or less the complete opposite; a tax primarily on wealth.
Trying to solve the regressive nature of pure consumption taxes with a Basic Income is basically squaring a circle: you lose vast amounts of tax revenue from point-one-percenters that spend very little of their taxable income, and pass that burden on to the general public. (Warren Buffett once commented that the percentage of tax he paid was less than some of his junior employees. Given his notoriously miserly spending habits, it's conceivable that the absolute amount of tax he paid would be lower than many of his employees under a pure consumption tax). It also overlooks arguably the most important benefit of higher income is not the ability to consume more in the future but the ability to work less.
And to cap it all, it makes the tax free gains from speculative housing bubbles look very attractive, especially relative to investing in firms that make taxable goods.