3 ms·
I listened to the post-briefing audio feed where reporters called in and asked additional questions. A very common question people have is about why the money
by geuis 12y ago
I listened to the post-briefing audio feed where reporters called in and asked additional questions.
A very common question people have is about why the money is broken up between Boeing and SpaceX as it is. Why does SpaceX get a smaller amount?
The awards were based specifically on the estimates that each company submitted in their proposals. In other words, Boeing said they need $4.2 billion and SpaceX said they need $2.6 billion.
This is very telling because the proposals are for the same NASA requirements. SpaceX is saying they can do it 1.65 times cheaper than Boeing.
NASA is not currently commenting on their decision process for choosing to award these two companies.
My personal supposition is that its a best-of strategy. NASA has a high priority to get human launch capability back under our control. They also have competing requirements. Do it as inexpensively as possible. Use multiple partners to fulfill the commercial spaceflight mission. They also need the assurance that the companies they work with can actually complete the contracts.
Boeing is an old dog and partner to NASA. They have decades of experience behind them. SpaceX is relatively new and while increasingly successful with delivering launch vehicles, they've not yet built human launch craft. It makes sense, when you think of it as a way of hedging NASA's bets, to choose these two companies even though their award amounts are vastly different.
- FranOntanaya 12y agoDid SpaceX even need 2.6 billion, or did NASA have to buff their number so as Boeing's funding didn't look too out of proportion?
- geuis 12y agoLike I said, the award amounts were based on what each company asked for in their proposals.
- Flenser 12y agoI bet given the relative efficiencies of both companies development process that SpaceX's 2.6 billion will give them a lot more runway (pun intended) than Boeing's $4.2 billion.