3 ms·
Doesn't the setup of that incentive strike you as perverse? Years of someone's life versus government operating expenses? If the goal were efficient government,
by mindslight 12y ago
Doesn't the setup of that incentive strike you as perverse? Years of someone's life versus government operating expenses? If the goal were efficient government, there are much more straightforward ways to achieve that.
If the defendant is guilty and deserves the punishment they stand to receive at trial, then the prosecutor is doing society a disservice by letting them off easy for expedience. On the other hand, if the plea sentence is adequate punishment/rehabilitation/etc, then why are they being threatened with a much larger sentence?
It seems to me that the feedback loop on sentences operates on the time specific criminals spend in jail being deemed too short during campaign season. As such, the plea sentence (ie "worst case") reflects what society deems appropriate (modulo the problems with democracy). Everything above the offered plea really is just an added threat to encourage a defendant to forgo the trial and submit to the judgment of the prosecutor.
If the case is really so open-and-shut, then it should not take terribly long for a proper court to see so as well.
- tptacek 12y agoEvery dollar we spend on a ritualized but ultimately pointless trial for a defendant who already knows they're going to be convicted is a dollar we aren't spending on schools. So no, the logic here isn't obvious to me.
- mindslight 12y agoBy that argument, we should eliminate jury trials and set the criminal burden of proof to be a preponderance of evidence.
- tptacek 12y agoI don't see how that follows, at all.
- mindslight 12y agoThere are defendants who know that they will be convicted, yet won't be enticed by a plea bargain because their crime is so heinous (or they are already incarcerated for life). These defendants will stand for a full jury trial, hoping for the chance of an acquittal. Every dollar spent on these trials is a dollar that isn't spent on schools. Therefore, we should eliminate the inefficiencies of jury trials and "beyond a reasonable doubt" so that more money can go to schools.
- harryh 12y agoThat's a nice http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man you got there. tptacek isn't saying that we should reduce costs under any circumstances. He's saying that we should reduce costs where it is reasonable to do so. There are a huge number of cases every year where everyone knows the defendant is guilty and the defendant isn't interested in defending himself. Why, as tptacek put it, have a "ritualized but ultimately pointless trial" in these situations?
- mindslight 12y agoI argued why it was reasonable to do so. tptacek rebutted my argument with a sweeping emotional statement that money is better spent on schools than on justice. As such, one counter example suffices.
- tedunangst 12y agoThere is a difference between allowing the pointless ritual to proceed and requiring that the pointless ritual occur in all instances.
- mechanical_fish 12y agoYears of someone's life versus government operating expenses? Have you spent much time on jury duty? Hanging out in a room full of prospective jurors, some of whom are literally praying for the day's cases to get settled before they're compelled to spend days or even weeks in court, gives one a real gut-level appreciation for the court system's love of settlements. It's not just a matter of paying more taxes, because the costs of a jury trial can't all be settled with cash. Jurors get paid a stipend in my state, but it's $50 per day, which wouldn't fully compensate a minimum-wage worker, let alone a doctor, a lawyer, or a consultant. Companies must pay their salaried workers for up to three days of jury service, but lots of people don't have salaries (see above under "consultants"), and backlogs and inboxes accumulate whether you're on the job or not. And, even if it were a good idea, dialing back the right to trial-by-jury in the USA would be the opposite of a "straightforward" reform, because that right is in the Constitution.
- mindslight 12y agoYou're either in MA, or that "compensation" schedule is popular. I agree with your description of jury duty, and it has major problems as well. But I disagree with this statement: > because the costs of a jury trial can't all be settled with cash. Increase the stipend to be in line with a person's salary, or their education level if they're self-employed. Yes, this is going to be expensive. But just like government efficiency is not a justification to destroy rights, it's also not a justification to demand people's uncompensated labor. And once jurors were properly compensated, I bet it would be much easier to cancel if one really had a problem with losing the time. (Also, if the issue is only with the cost of jury trials, then I can weaken my argument to say that plea-bargains should turn into judge-bargains, where forgoing the jury will limit your punishment to the smaller amount) > the right to trial-by-jury ... is in the Constitution Yes, and my whole point is that plea bargaining has also undermined that right, only by a slow erosion over time rather than by an overt policy choice. To the extent that people would presently balk at eliminating juries for efficiency, they should also take issue with defendants effectively being denied a trial under threat of overblown punishment.
- dllthomas 12y ago