5 ms·
> With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucke
by Someone1234 12y ago
> With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucket of money.
Yes, it all goes into a big pot of money. That doesn't preclude the fact that infrastructure and services cost money, companies utilise both, that generates additional expenses (due to wear and tear, etc). The rest of society winds up paying for the company's share.
You don't really even attempt to argue why companies shouldn't pay. Unless the "big pot of money" is your argument then in which case I am not following it.
> I agree with your point about tax loopholes being easier for large actors to take advantage of. That seems like a good case for simplifying tax codes, though, not a case for adding even more regulations that rich corporations will inevitably circumvent.
This just reads like a generic libertarian talking point. Currently the regulations/agreements are: "You shouldn't tax companies twice on the same profits." Getting rid of those regulations wouldn't solve tax avoidance, it would just generate other problems (e.g. over-taxation, double-taxation, etc).
Interestingly I cannot imagine libertarians taking too kindly to double-taxation given their views on taxation in general. But that's what international de-regulation would result in...
Your solution is no solution at all. It is just giving up and hoping the problem solves itself. Which is very naive to say the least.
- innguest 12y agoInstead of defending my case I'll ask you this: why not stop taxing profits and instead start taxing consumption? Seems much easier, no? And the incentives would be in the right place.
- notahacker 12y agoBecause in general, consumption drives economic growth which makes life better for everyone, whilst retained earnings allow complacent corporations to avoid innovating because they have big enough war chests to scare potential competition away. I can't fathom why you consider that to be a better alignment of incentives.
- bitJericho 12y agoBecause consumption is harming the environment. That said, clearly both sides of that coin aren't particularly great. What's the third option?
- Joeri 12y agoOption 3: tax only the environmental harm of goods and services. Eco-friendly goods and services would go untaxed, while many luxury goods would become even more expensive. The trick of course is quantifying environmental harm.
- bjterry 12y agoIf there were no tax on capital gains and income, which is the whole point of a consumption tax, businesses would have an incentive to distribute much more of their retained earnings to shareholders. Part of the reason war chests have gotten so big is because dividends are disadvantaged to capital gains in the current tax code for many classes of investors. It's not totally clear that the scenario implied by innguest's comment was one of taxes on capital gains and income being removed, though. Keeping (a) income tax, and (b) tax on capital gains/income, and (c) adding a consumption tax, while removing the corporate tax on profits, doesn't seem like a particularly attractive scenario, especially as compared with moving completely to a consumption tax (which is the most favored tax among a consensus of tax economists).
- humanrebar 12y agoAnd if the problem is the regressive nature of the consumption taxes, why not address those issues at the source -- by instituting an Earn Income Credit or universal basic income?
- notahacker 12y agoYou're quite right to point out that favorable tax treatment of capital gains over dividends encourages retaining earnings but replacing both with a massive new consumption tax is hardly likely to stimulate either a desire on the part of management to reinvest revenues or on the part of the shareholders to fund more consumption And for all its outspoken advocates like Kotlikoff, consumption tax is a long way from being "the most favored tax among a consensus of tax economists". If there's one thing you could get a majority of tax economists to agree on it's that tax on land ownership and various other forms of economic rent distort incentives less than most other taxes, but ironically that's more or less the complete opposite; a tax primarily on wealth. Trying to solve the regressive nature of pure consumption taxes with a Basic Income is basically squaring a circle: you lose vast amounts of tax revenue from point-one-percenters that spend very little of their taxable income, and pass that burden on to the general public. (Warren Buffett once commented that the percentage of tax he paid was less than some of his junior employees. Given his notoriously miserly spending habits, it's conceivable that the absolute amount of tax he paid would be lower than many of his employees under a pure consumption tax). It also overlooks arguably the most important benefit of higher income is not the ability to consume more in the future but the ability to work less. And to cap it all, it makes the tax free gains from speculative housing bubbles look very attractive, especially relative to investing in firms that make taxable goods.
- plorg 12y agoIt should be obvious, but taxing consumption disproportionately affects low-income people who are the least able to afford it. Conversely, as the sister comment alludes to, if a person has less money, they are far more likely to spend the money that they save from tax breaks. See also: the declining marginal utility of money.
- mahyarm 12y agoThe problems that come from corporations is the fact that they are 'derivative people' basically. What you should be advocating is abolishing corporate tax and make all corporations into S-corps, so the income and thus tax is attributed to the stockholders. Then you avoid the entire derivative people mess. But then you have the entire citizenship based taxation schema that the USA is unique in the world in having.
- humanrebar 12y agoWhich infrastructure and services are corporations using outside of their employees? Why can't that infrastructure be paid for through direct fees instead of indirect income taxes? How do we know when corporations are paying their fair share? > This just reads like a generic libertarian talking point Maybe. I'm not a libertarian, but I'm not sure why that would disqualify my points. I'd rather our discussion not be an exercise in polemics, please. > Your solution is no solution at all. I don't have "a solution", but if the problem is one of justice (that tax rules are unfair, prone to abuse, and hard to enforce), the principles I would apply are simplicity and transparency, not on-the-fly patches to already convoluted logic (spaghetti tax code if you will). At that point we can have sensible discussions about which tax schemes are fair and at which rates. If the problem is one of revenues being too low, it's far from clear that increasing the effective corporate income taxes across all the OECD will even be a revenue-positive action.