3 ms·
> employee's individual income tax goes to paying for infrastructure and service that that employee utilise With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is no
by humanrebar 12y ago
> employee's individual income tax goes to paying for infrastructure and service that that employee utilise
With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucket of money.
Case in point: The social security surplus the U.S. ran when the baby boomers were young will be really useful as the baby boomer start retiring. That money ended up being spent just like any other tax dollars.
I agree with your point about tax loopholes being easier for large actors to take advantage of. That seems like a good case for simplifying tax codes, though, not a case for adding even more regulations that rich corporations will inevitably circumvent.
And don't get me started on VAT. That stuff is just a big loophole from the get-go (arbitrary tax rates based on arbitrary categorizations, etc.).
- Someone1234 12y ago> With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucket of money. Yes, it all goes into a big pot of money. That doesn't preclude the fact that infrastructure and services cost money, companies utilise both, that generates additional expenses (due to wear and tear, etc). The rest of society winds up paying for the company's share. You don't really even attempt to argue why companies shouldn't pay. Unless the "big pot of money" is your argument then in which case I am not following it. > I agree with your point about tax loopholes being easier for large actors to take advantage of. That seems like a good case for simplifying tax codes, though, not a case for adding even more regulations that rich corporations will inevitably circumvent. This just reads like a generic libertarian talking point. Currently the regulations/agreements are: "You shouldn't tax companies twice on the same profits." Getting rid of those regulations wouldn't solve tax avoidance, it would just generate other problems (e.g. over-taxation, double-taxation, etc). Interestingly I cannot imagine libertarians taking too kindly to double-taxation given their views on taxation in general. But that's what international de-regulation would result in... Your solution is no solution at all. It is just giving up and hoping the problem solves itself. Which is very naive to say the least.
- innguest 12y agoInstead of defending my case I'll ask you this: why not stop taxing profits and instead start taxing consumption? Seems much easier, no? And the incentives would be in the right place.
- notahacker 12y agoBecause in general, consumption drives economic growth which makes life better for everyone, whilst retained earnings allow complacent corporations to avoid innovating because they have big enough war chests to scare potential competition away. I can't fathom why you consider that to be a better alignment of incentives.
- bitJericho 12y agoBecause consumption is harming the environment. That said, clearly both sides of that coin aren't particularly great. What's the third option?
- Joeri 12y agoOption 3: tax only the environmental harm of goods and services. Eco-friendly goods and services would go untaxed, while many luxury goods would become even more expensive. The trick of course is quantifying environmental harm.
- bjterry 12y agoIf there were no tax on capital gains and income, which is the whole point of a consumption tax, businesses would have an incentive to distribute much more of their retained earnings to shareholders. Part of the reason war chests have gotten so big is because dividends are disadvantaged to capital gains in the current tax code for many classes of investors. It's not totally clear that the scenario implied by innguest's comment was one of taxes on capital gains and income being removed, though. Keeping (a) income tax, and (b) tax on capital gains/income, and (c) adding a consumption tax, while removing the corporate tax on profits, doesn't seem like a particularly attractive scenario, especially as compared with moving completely to a consumption tax (which is the most favored tax among a consensus of tax economists).
- click170 12y agoI think the parent's point was that individual income tax is the employee's share of the tax, and that a company can't point to that and say "look, we pay tax through our employees!" It is fair for everyone who uses the infrastructure to pay for it. Employees use it, and they pay income tax. Corporations use it, they should pay tax too, but they can't point to an employee's income tax and claim that contribution as their own. Edit: Clarification
- humanrebar 12y agoI'm not following. How does a corporation use infrastructure except through people (employees)? And if there are particular imbalances, why can't they be resolved through more fair (and economically sensible) fee-for-use sort of taxation?
- anigbrowl 12y agoThink of the employee taking a commuter train or driving to work, vs operating a freight train or driving a semi truck for work. I'm not taking an ideological position here, just pointing out the difference between the employee as individual economic actor vs as agent of a corporation.
- humanrebar 12y agoIf semi trucks aren't paying for their infrastructure, raise taxes or fees on semi trucks. It's very non-obvious to me that raising corporate taxes (including on companies that rarely ship things) is a good way to make sure that highways and weigh stations are paid for. And, again, these actions are still discrete and still being taken by individuals. So taxes on the actions still apply whether the MASTERCARD paying the bill is owned by the citizen or her employer.
- anigbrowl 12y agoPlease read the second sentence in my comment above.
- 12y ago
- jdmichal 12y ago> Case in point: The social security surplus the U.S. ran when the baby boomers were young will be really useful as the baby boomer start retiring. That money ended up being spent just like any other tax dollars. This is a bit deceiving, as it makes it seem like Social Security surplus has been spent. The liquid money may have been spent, but it was spent to buy treasury bonds for the Social Security Trust Funds [0]. When a deficit is finally encountered, those bonds and their owed interest will be used to pay obligations. I do understand that this is a bit of hand-waving, as it's basically the government buying IOUs from the government, but it's an important note when talking about Social Security and its solvency. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Trust_Fund http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_Trust_Fund