8 ms·
OECD unveils proposals to curb corporate tax avoidance
- Someone1234 12y agoThis is very good news and about damn time. While legal, this tax avoidance hurts competition (as smaller companies pay tax normally, while larger ones do not) and also means that some countries can actually lose money while hosting a business (e.g. business uses national infrastructure but doesn't pay towards it). You often hear companies use their employee's income tax as a way to justify the business's tax avoidance, but that is utter nonsense: employee's individual income tax goes to paying for infrastructure and service that that employee utilises, not the additional infrastructure cost imposed by the business itself. One thing that does need to happen is that it needs to become easier for SMBs to pay tax to dozens of different countries while operating in the digital space. If they really want things like sales tax/VAT to be paid then they need to make it relatively EASY to do. Otherwise SMBs just might start rejecting customers from smaller countries (as paying the tax for a single transaction is never worth the cost of setting it all up).
- humanrebar 12y ago> employee's individual income tax goes to paying for infrastructure and service that that employee utilise With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucket of money. Case in point: The social security surplus the U.S. ran when the baby boomers were young will be really useful as the baby boomer start retiring. That money ended up being spent just like any other tax dollars. I agree with your point about tax loopholes being easier for large actors to take advantage of. That seems like a good case for simplifying tax codes, though, not a case for adding even more regulations that rich corporations will inevitably circumvent. And don't get me started on VAT. That stuff is just a big loophole from the get-go (arbitrary tax rates based on arbitrary categorizations, etc.).
- Someone1234 12y ago> With all due respect, that is nonsense. There is nothing magic about the tax dollars I pay to enforce that they go to the things I use. It's all one big bucket of money. Yes, it all goes into a big pot of money. That doesn't preclude the fact that infrastructure and services cost money, companies utilise both, that generates additional expenses (due to wear and tear, etc). The rest of society winds up paying for the company's share. You don't really even attempt to argue why companies shouldn't pay. Unless the "big pot of money" is your argument then in which case I am not following it. > I agree with your point about tax loopholes being easier for large actors to take advantage of. That seems like a good case for simplifying tax codes, though, not a case for adding even more regulations that rich corporations will inevitably circumvent. This just reads like a generic libertarian talking point. Currently the regulations/agreements are: "You shouldn't tax companies twice on the same profits." Getting rid of those regulations wouldn't solve tax avoidance, it would just generate other problems (e.g. over-taxation, double-taxation, etc). Interestingly I cannot imagine libertarians taking too kindly to double-taxation given their views on taxation in general. But that's what international de-regulation would result in... Your solution is no solution at all. It is just giving up and hoping the problem solves itself. Which is very naive to say the least.
- innguest 12y agoInstead of defending my case I'll ask you this: why not stop taxing profits and instead start taxing consumption? Seems much easier, no? And the incentives would be in the right place.
- notahacker 12y agoBecause in general, consumption drives economic growth which makes life better for everyone, whilst retained earnings allow complacent corporations to avoid innovating because they have big enough war chests to scare potential competition away. I can't fathom why you consider that to be a better alignment of incentives.
- 12y ago
- lefstathiou 12y agoOther than risk of facing sanctions (lowe-case s), what is the incentive of say an Ireland to comply when their tax code is such an important reason why businesses go there? All else being equal, won't this hurt the development of many emerging markets (not just tax havens but even Asian countries where businesses have chosen not to re-patriot income - incentiving them to invest locally)
- Someone1234 12y agoThe concept is that even if Ireland continued to have a low tax rate, the country where the business is making their money could tax them when they try and send the money there. As the article puts it: If you're ONLY money moving to avoid tax, then it can be taxed. So if a company made tons in the US but then tried to ship it to Ireland, they would just get taxed by the US government at the normal rates instead of Ireland.
- ojbyrne 12y agoBut they don't just "ship" the money. They set up subsidiaries to provide services to the parent company. And then the services in low-tax jurisdictions just happen to have high margins. So now is government going to examine internal processes to ensure that margins are "fair?" Seems incredibly unworkable.
- ppereira 12y agoThey already do examine margins. Its called "transfer pricing". Information sharing is a key part of the proposals.
- innguest 12y ago> Amazon and Google say they pay all the taxes they should. Analysts say competitive pressures force companies to seek to minimise all costs, including tax. Amazon and Google do not have competition. They seek to minimize all costs because that's how they can free the most resources to invest in the product they're offering to consumers. Also, there's no competition when a company gets big and starts lobbying. This is really bad news for everyone; we all lose when bankers steal money from those that provide us goods and services.
- grecy 12y agoNo, Amazon and Google seek to minimize all costs so they can increase their profits. Doing this will just reduce their profits a little.
- innguest 12y agoAnd how do they increase their profits? By providing goods and services that customers want. Increasing profits and having your product/service valued and wanted by your consumer base is the same thing. Why do you say "profits" as if it's a bad thing? As the Democrats argued when Grover Cleveland was elected, taxes make goods more expensive and subsidize monopolies. This will be no different.
- bitJericho 12y agoWhen a blue collar worker can make $30/hr again maybe I'll agree with you. It isn't taxes that's lowering our paychecks (taxes are lower than in the Cleveland's day).
- innguest 12y agoYou've got it backwards. Once everyone considers these principles I'm putting forward, then blue collar workers will make $30/h again. Taxes are what is lowering paychecks. Taxing comes in several shapes, including inflation. In this sense, taxes are higher now, since the dollar was pegged to gold then.
- sseveran 12y agoWon't work. If the choice is pay tax or spend money it will get spent. Earnings may go down but the players will adapt to minimize their tax burden.
- rjtavares 12y agoBetter to spend money than hoard it...
- charlesdm 12y agoTime to load up on debt! Good thing interest is tax deductible.. This is more of a game than anything. There will always be ways to reduce the tax burden, and I find that changes are often made without really properly thinking them through. Closing loopholes is great, but rethinking critical parts of the law can also create a whole set of loopholes if not done properly. Which, considering we're human, is always the case.
- justincormack 12y agoMany people have suggested removing the tax loophole that is interest on debt. It might have to be coordinated but I would not be surprised if it happens.
- rjtavares 12y agoWe're talking in a context of companies having billions is cash/cash equivalents just to avoid paying taxes. It's pretty much a win win situation.
- innguest 12y agoThere are 3 things you can do with money: - Spend it - Hoard it - Invest it It's better to spend inflationary money than to hoard it, you've got that right. That sentence only works with the "inflationary" word there, which you forgot to add, but I fixed it for you.
- Gys 12y agoTo me basically the question is: should the money be spend by private persons and corporations, or by governments. There should be a balance, but there is a long term tendency towards governments. Because in the end they make the rules. And its difficult to control ones powers... Personally I am not sure the latter spends it better, in terms of good for the future of society. I am very happy with Google search, Gmail, my iPhone, iPad, etc. Looking forward to ever buy a Tesla hopefully ;-) There are always side effects: a handful of people getting extremely rich or presidents who spend billions on big projects. Governments should concentrate on lowering taxes (in Europe the taxes go just one way in the long run...) and keeping a very close eye the playing field: misuse of rules. Privacy and net neutrality come to mind. Software patents... As well as banks taking to high risks which are highly rewarded if it works out or payed for by society if not (which is a governmental decision !). In my humble opinion our government leaders are just as human as the leaders of companies. Does anyone of them thinks of society ? Probably. Do either one of them think about their own future ? Definitely.
- ojbyrne 12y agoI don't think you can really separate "private persons and corporations" and "governments," because the same people often switch back and forth. Goldman Sachs is the obvious example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldman_Sachs#Personnel_.22revolving-door.22_with_US_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goldman_Sachs#Personnel_.22rev...
- lifeisstillgood 12y agotl;dr If we think your cross-border transactions are moving money mostly to avoid tax, we still tax it. If we think that small divisions in tax-light countries happen to make all the profit by doing all the purchasing, we will allocate that across the business And currently just having a warehouse in a country did not make you tax resident. Amazon is nothing but warehouses and that's a trend that will continue. So we will tax you if you have a "significant digital presence" All seem sensible clear policies. Taken with things like HMRC's new whitelisting rules on tax schemes ("until we approve the scheme assume we will tax it") governments around the world might soon start to balance the equation of multi national companies and single nation citizens. A good thing all round and probably the most important activity of the next few years that will never be on the front pages
- fpp 12y agoWhile internationally supported and implemented tax avoidance rules are generally the right way, I would like to see all these new rules balances with real transparency and accountability for how this (additional) tax income of countries / governments is spend. What we have as transparency rules today is at best a good show - take the UK for example (considered as one of the best with regards to open data): DFID - the UK's development aid department publishes every £500 spent but with many 100s of millions they spend p.a. the only thing we know is that it disappeared in some opaque gov. shops in Geneva that have zero accountability, spend money on themselves as if there is no tomorrow and - when someone has a closer look - have "lost" billions or fostered corruption and organised crime globally. And the OECD - like most international organisations - is not exactly a light when it comes to efficient use of (tax) funding. First governments have to demonstrate and assure that they use the funds entrusted in an efficient way that is best for their citizens and not only for special interest groups. There must be rules to hold those in Government accountable and not only £5000 fines if someone "lost" or wasted £1Billion+ funds, and afterwards (s)he is moved to another senior post or receives a large consultancy contract from where they funds have disappeared. In the moment this looks more like trying to threaten or milk successful companies or to make them compromise e.g. on the participation in dubious spy programs on citizens. At the same time don't forget who is "running" the biggest tax heavens on this planet - its the UK and the US plus a series of "independent" island states where dozens of trillions of dollars have found a home (including for some of the largest multinational players mentioned here).