5 ms·
This point is easy to mislead, though. Consider, the android kernel is probably rapidly growing in the realm of what would have once been considered for embedd
by taeric 12y ago
This point is easy to mislead, though. Consider, the android kernel is probably rapidly growing in the realm of what would have once been considered for embedded kernels.
And it isn't like most of us do not like some of the ideas behind microkernels and the like. The empiricist in me has grown to doubt that it is as much of a win as the hopefuls keep talking about. That is, even if someday microkernels make a pretty big comeback, I doubt it will be as dramatic of a change as is always heralded.
- Symmetry 12y agoI'm given to understand that on many phones Android runs in the application core on top of an L4 kernel, which provides resources to Android but also controls the various DSP and embedded cores.
- jacquesm 12y ago> I doubt it will be as dramatic of a change as is always heralded. I doubt it will happen. But if it happens the difference will be so large that you will be wondering why we didn't do that decades earlier. It's a bit like those people that work with emacs and lisp at home that then have to go to work and use Java or PHP.
- taeric 12y agoI'm one of those people, actually. To the point that I now just use emacs at work. Have slowly started using it for all things. Email, irc, im, etc. Is very very nice. Always amusing to hear folks talk about how limited it is. But, I still can't deny that the modern IDE has gone a long way to advance what can be done outside of emacs. To the point that I just can't bring myself to think the difference between the LISP world and any other is as large as it is often made out to be.
- vegggdor 12y agoAndroid is not a good example, for one, the usecase is almost no different to the desktop, except for the issue with power efficiency . secondly, the real time part of the system, ie. the controllers, doesn't run android. It rather runs L4 in the baseband processor - a microkernel.
- taeric 12y agoI think this response actually came later. Apologies for that to the other poster. This is pretty much my point. This "embedded systems use microkernels" is easy to paint in such a way that it supports either argument. Comes down almost to the scottsman falacy. More to the point, if I were to claim that my phone is really running a microkernel, I would be ignoring the majority of the software on my phone. I mean, yes it is true. But it is laughable in that the majority of the programming on the device is not in L4. To a large margin. Consider, you are at this point merely claiming that a state machine in your device is running in a microkernel. And, to the non-microkernel that runs the majority of the phone, it is but a device. So, we have a non-microkernel running a microkernel as a standard device.