3 ms·
My Rockboxed Sansa Clip crashes when I try anything in Opus. I keep FLACs in my music collection, but I encode to Vorbis for the Clip. I used to put the FLACs o
by theandrewbailey 12y ago
My Rockboxed Sansa Clip crashes when I try anything in Opus. I keep FLACs in my music collection, but I encode to Vorbis for the Clip. I used to put the FLACs on there directly, but with Vorbis I can put 4x more music on it. I also need to have better hardware for FLAC to make a perceptual difference.
- shmerl 12y agoIt works well for me on Sansa Fuze. Are you using the latest release or Rockbox? Vorbis is OK, but Opus allows using lower bitrates for comparable quality, so it can save space and also should be more optimal for CPU utilization. An interesting test: http://listening-test.coresv.net/results.htm http://listening-test.coresv.net/results.htm I keep FLAC for originals too, but encode in Opus for regular usage. FLAC allows reencoding in the future if anything improves, new codecs come out and so on.
- aeroevan 12y agoAs someone who is thinking about moving to opus for non-archival music playback, what sort of bitrate targets do you use for encoding? I know opusenc uses VBR, but as far as I can tell there is no V0 equivalent that is accepted for high quality lame (MP3) encoding.
- shmerl 12y agoUntil now I used to encode it with --bitrate 160 which is 160 Kbps variable bitrate. But from the test I linked above it seems to be an overkill, since 96 is already approaching encoding transparency for many people. So the optimal value can be somewhere above 96 and below 160. You can experiment for yourself, but I'd give a bit more room than your own transparency level to make it a safer bet for more people.
- theandrewbailey 12y agoYeah, latest release (3.13). I'm not too worried about saving space, since I have a 32 GB microSD card in it, and my Kickstarted 64 GB PonoPlayer should arrive before Christmas.