3 ms·
There is a lot about this article that is not to like. With tutorial articles, I am of the opinion that all analogies are false and therefore bad. And resorting
by wglb 12y ago
There is a lot about this article that is not to like. With tutorial articles, I am of the opinion that all analogies are false and therefore bad. And resorting to quantum physics to describe the impact of Maxwell's equations is another bad signal.
The thing to notice about SNR is that you can increase it by increasing amplification at the sender (where the background noise is fixed but you have a clear copy of the signal) but not at the receiver.
This presumes that the signal that you are looking for is above the detectability threshold at the receiver. It may well not be, if you are trying to capture a weak signal.
Let's put aside the concept of a MASER used in radio astronomy and the size of their antennas. Or the fact that your wifi router or dongle has an amplifier inside of it. Let's do an experiment.
I have two instances of kismet running in my lab here in the leafy suburbs. One has a 3.5 inch antenna attached to a fit pc with internal wifi, the other has a 14 inch antenna attached to an Alfa with kismet running on kali in a vm on my mac laptop. The 14 inch antenna is successfully decoding 167 wifi networks and the 3.5 inch antenna sees 35 networks. I don't know what the relative gain rating of these antennas are, or what the relative quality of the radios is, but the dramatic difference on the receive side is pretty telling.
- ssivark 12y ago"all analogies are false and therefore bad. And resorting to quantum physics to describe the impact of Maxwell's equations is another bad signal." That (EDIT: The analogy used in the article) is not just a good analogy, but summarizes our best understanding of both light and quantum physics. (Feynman knew exactly what he was talking about -- he invented/discovered some of the fundamentals). Whether you'd use quantum physics as an analogy to explain light, or light as an analogy to explain quantum physics is a matter of taste -- which one you find more intuitive and which less intuitive -- which depends on what you've been told by others previously.
- abstrakraft 12y ago"all analogies are false and therefore bad" I disagree with this statement. If you try to learn everything from first principles, you'll never get anywhere. Students need analogies to understand the big picture while learning the details. "That is not just a good analogy, but summarizes our best understanding of both light and quantum physics" And the Lesbeque integral is a more rigourously defined operator that the Riemann integral, but would you use it to introduce calculus to first year students? Of course not - you teach the basics, and in grad school, you let the students that need to worry about the more complicated stuff take Real Analysis. There are certainly connections between interferometry and quantum physics. However, I don't see how the author's explanation of the subject is enhanced by using quantum physics. For the purpose of this article, classical physics explains the phenomenology just fine. As I said in another comment below, and wglb said above, appealing to quantum physics when it is entirely unnecessary is a bad smell, and is usually nothing more than a distraction to make the author sound more sophisticated.
- ssivark 12y agoThe Lebesgue integral can be explained as intuitively as the Riemann integral (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebesgue_integration#mediaviewer/File:RandLintegrals.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebesgue_integration#mediaview...). One can certainly have the intuition for both without too much knowledge of real analysis. And in general, I believe that analogies are very useful. The author explains in the article how to understand the behaviour of light. It turns out quantum particles behave in exactly the same way. Feynman (building on Dirac's observations) built up the theory for quantum particles. With regards to light, this understanding comes from a couple of centuries ago (Ref: [Huygens principle](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens%E2%80%93Fresnel_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens%E2%80%93Fresnel_princi...) and [relations to quantum mechanics](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens%E2%80%93Fresnel_principle#Huygens.27_principle_and_quantum_electrodynamics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens%E2%80%93Fresnel_princi...)
- abstrakraft 12y ago"The author explains in the article how to understand the behaviour of light." That isn't the argument. What I'm arguing is the (lack of) utility of the explanation. In what way does it enhance, support, or in any way contribute to the article? His argument is essentially: A. We think of light as traveling in straight lines. B. But because quantum physics, they don't! They travel along infinitely many paths. C. But all of these paths cancel out except the straight line path. D. And that's how beamforming works. Except it's beam-un-forming. So he brings up a quantum phenomenon to complicate the scenario, then immediately reduces it back to the original scenario, without ever explaining how that original scenario works (i.e. how waves add together to create constructive and destructive interference: note that the words "wave" and "phase" never occur in same paragraph), then claims that this is somehow elucidating. So what's the benefit?
- judk 12y agoAs stated in the article, the point is to give an intuition for how energy appears to "move" from troughs to peaks: by going everywhere. This coincides with the Pilot Wave model, where particles travel along paths modeled by the peaks of mathematical waves.