4 ms·
As the article comments note, Thunderbolt is also not taking taking off because Intel demands all Thunderbolt peripherals have OS X drivers. Companies like Asu
by nailer 12y ago
As the article comments note, Thunderbolt is also not taking taking off because Intel demands all Thunderbolt peripherals have OS X drivers.
Companies like Asus/Silverstone (and more who don't spring to mind right now) have created Thunderbolt GPU enclosures to allow laptops to do 3D work. However Intel won't let them go to market because they don't have OS X drivers, and Apple has no interest in supporting Thunderbolt GPUs when they cold be selling people additional Macs instead.
- abritishguy 12y ago[citation needed] The GPU enclosures have been held up by Intel refusing to license them but not because of osx drivers, there are licensed thunderbolt peripherals that do not have osx drivers.
- nailer 12y agoI read about it from a bunch of sources, which eventually pointed to https://www.change.org/p/intel-allow-silverstone-and-asus-to-sell-the-asus-xg-station-2-and-allow-villagetronics-to-sell-the-4th-generation-vidock-in-essence-allow-the-sale-of-affordable-egpu-enclosures https://www.change.org/p/intel-allow-silverstone-and-asus-to.... But there hasn't been an official statement about why they've been refused from Intel, so I can't link to it. You mention you still believe Intel has refused to license the hardware - what reason do you think applies?
- MWil 12y agoI'm confused too because they are already for sale http://www.villageinstruments.com/tiki-index.php?page=Store http://www.villageinstruments.com/tiki-index.php?page=Store
- nailer 12y agoThe final ViDock 4 is actually a ExpressCard to PCIe. You have to buy a separate Thunderbolt to ExpressCard. Having ExpressCard in the middle kills your bandwidth, and ExpressCard is way narrower than PCIE or Thunderbolt.
- pjmlp 12y ago> Apple has no interest in supporting Thunderbolt GPUs when they cold be selling people additional Macs instead. One of the reasons I don't buy Macs, even though I like Mac OS X, is the fact that only high end Macs have proper GPUs for serious 3D programming.
- m_mueller 12y agoAs a developer on Mac, I think game programming is one of the last resorts where WinPCs are clearly better and/or needed - except for Unity based programming maybe. VS is quite dominant in that area, isn't it?
- Stratoscope 12y agoVS dominates for Unity development too, at least in my little circle of the world. The developers I work with all love their Macs, but they hop onto Windows for serious Unity work, just so they can use Visual Studio with ReSharper instead of MonoDevelop.
- pjmlp 12y agoYes, because the whole game industry has been created on the home markets. The gaming community has a different mindset than UNIX or FOSS communities and Mac wasn't never good at games (at least in Europe). The rise of consoles happened in parallel with the downfall of Atari ST and Amiga. So eventually the devkits for consoles happened to exist only on PCs. Also the demoscene groups started to focus on the PC as well. It doesn't help that Apple, except for the Pippin and now iOS, never had a gaming culture. So you will never see a Mac game ring with subzero temperature cooling system and a pair of SLI graphic cards powered by their own power plant. :)
- mwfunk 12y agoYou are vastly underestimating the amount of work that would be required to support Thunderbolt GPUs on OS X. Its lack of support has nothing to do with any nefarious plot to make people buy more computers. Hot-pluggable GPUs are a Hard Problem and the alternative (requiring anything with a GPU to remain connected while the OS is up, and requiring a reboot if somebody wants to connect such a device) isn't worth doing, at least not for them it's not.
- MWil 12y agosearching Youtube for "egpu" pulls up a ton of Macs...
- nailer 12y agoI understand support eGPUs on OS X a lot of work, but you misunderstand my position: I don't care if that work happens or not: I'm quite happy using Windows / SteamOS for games.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoSource for your claim that it's not worth it for "them" to do? I'd counter by arguing that the computer brand that still to this day laymen consider "better for graphics" would find value in supporting a spec that's very unveiling discussed the possibility of external GPUs.